← Previous Next →

Guild Reviews

Image of scene from the film Ghaati
Ghaati

Drama, Crime (Telugu)

Follows the story of an empowered woman who gets entangled with weed trade due to circumstances.

Cast: Anushka Shetty, Vikram Prabhu, Ramya Krishnan, Jagapati Babu, Ravindra Vijay, VTV Ganesh, Larissa Bonesi, John Vijay, Sudhasri Madhusmita, Devika Priyadarshini
Director: Radha Krishna Jagarlamudi


FCG Member Reviewer Janani K
Janani K | India Today
Anushka Shetty's comeback film fails to rise above basic tropes

Fri, September 5 2025

Director Krish Jagarlamudi's 'Ghaati', starring Anushka Shetty, Vikram Prabhu and others, is a strictly average tale on exploitation and oppression. The film relies on familiar tropes with very little to look forward to.

Much before Nayanthara, who is now called Lady Superstar, it was Anushka Shetty who first earned the title. She headlined female-led films and created a market for such stories. But, after ‘Baahubali’, Anushka Shetty has been struggling with her film choices. As the end credits suggest, The Queen – Anushka Shetty is back with another offering with ‘Ghaati’. But does the Krish Jagarlamudi directorial gift her the much-needed comeback? Sheelavathi (Anushka Shetty) is a bus conductor in Koraput, while her childhood sweetheart Desi Raju (Vikram Prabhu), works as a lab technician. The couple live a simple life, but their past isn’t as simple as they look. Meanwhile, two cannabis business tycoons, Kundala Naidu (Chaitanya Rao) and Kaastala Naidu (Ravindra Vijay), discovert a new form of liquid-based cannabis being smuggled and are determined to secure it. This leads them to the Ghaatis, a community inhabiting the Ghats, who act as local porters helping smuggle cannabis across the mountains. Sheelavathi and Desi Raju’s past is intertwined with Kundala and Kaastala’s dream. This sets the stage for a face-off, a tale of exploitation, oppression and revenge.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Sangeetha Devi Dundoo
Sangeetha Devi Dundoo | The Hindu
Anushka Shetty shines as rebel queen, but the film falls short

Fri, September 5 2025

Krish Jagarlamudi and Anushka Shetty’s reunion in ‘Ghaati’ leans on tropes over storytelling

As the end credits of Ghaati rolled, the words “The Queen – Anushka Shetty” appeared on screen. It felt apt. Anushka carries a regal presence and has proven across her 20-year career that she can embody powerful characters. Directed by Krish Jagarlamudi, this Telugu film is an action-heavy spectacle, with Anushka playing a woman seeking revenge and striving to lift her community out of an endless cycle of exploitation. Yet, the film struggles to fully realise its potential as a gripping action drama, leaning more on familiar tropes and sheer force than on nuance. The story’s broad contours will feel familiar. Those without a voice toil while business heads profit from their labour, ensuring that people cannot take matters into their own hands. When the oppressed are pushed to the brink, rebellion becomes inevitable, and every rebellion, of course, needs a leader.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film Secret of a Mountain Serpent
Secret of a Mountain Serpent

Drama (Hindi)

In a 1990s Himalayan town, teacher Barkha, whose husband serves at the border, develops feelings for enigmatic newcomer Manik amid a community of waiting women where silence and local myths prevail.

Cast: Trimala Adhikari, Adil Hussain, Pushpendra Singh, Richa Meena
Director: Nidhi Saxena
Writer: Nidhi Saxena


FCG Member Reviewer Saibal Chatterjee
Saibal Chatterjee | NDTV
(Writing for The Daily Eye)
A dip into the river of female desire

Fri, September 5 2025

An exquisite piece of cinema that blurs the line between the dreamily meditative and the tangible to explore the boundaries of female desire.

Secret of a Mountain Serpent by writer-director Nidhi Saxena is a poetic exploration of female desire set against the backdrop of the Kargil conflict. Premiering at the Venice Film Festival, the film weaves folklore, symbolism, and haunting performances by Trimala Adhikari and Adil Hussain into a tapestry of longing, liberation, and cinematic beauty. With its blend of myth and reality, evocative sound design, and visual mastery, it is an unforgettable contribution to Indian independent cinema. Between Dream and Reality Writer-director Nidhi Saxena’s second film, Secret of a Mountain Serpent, is an exquisite piece of cinema. It blurs the line between the dreamily meditative and the wholly tangible to explore the boundaries of female desire when it is set free from the suffocating constraints of societal stipulations. ‘

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Rahul Desai
Rahul Desai | The Hollywood Reporter India
The Artistic War Between Desire and Belonging

Fri, August 29 2025

Nobody challenges the form of Indian storytelling quite like Nidhi Saxena, whose second film is playing at the Venice International Film Festival

Most film-makers use craft to tell stories. But some use stories to craft unfilmable feelings. Nidhi Saxena did it in her feature-length debut, Sad Letters of an Imaginary Woman, which had its world premiere at Busan last year. The life of a middle-aged caregiver and her ailing mother in a crumbling ancestral home became a medium to explore the transience of memories, trauma, loneliness and everything in between. The montage of a character recording whispers and past sounds from the walls of her house with a boom mic can seem strange — pretentious, even (the house in ‘arthouse’). But it encouraged us to renegotiate their relationship with the act of watching a movie. The orthodox need to interpret fiction made way for a sensory experience of understanding life itself. Imagine the screen speaking to the viewer in a different language: where expression comes disguised as an aesthetic.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film Wednesday S02
FCG Rating for the film
Wednesday S02

Sci-Fi & Fantasy, Mystery, Comedy (English)

Smart, sarcastic and a little dead inside, Wednesday Addams investigates twisted mysteries while making new friends — and foes — at Nevermore Academy.

Cast: Jenna Ortega, Steve Buscemi, Hunter Doohan, Emma Myers, Joy Sunday, Isaac Ordonez, Moosa Mostafa, Owen Painter, Georgie Farmer, Billie Piper


FCG Member Reviewer Sonal Pandya
Sonal Pandya | Times Now, Zoom
Gothic Drama's Unwieldy, Twisty Narrative Doesn't Stick Landing In Jenna Ortega Starrer (Part 2)

Fri, September 5 2025

After a near-death experience, Jenna Ortega's Wednesday Addams returns to catch the Hyde and save her friend Enid but runs into other unforeseen troubles.

The second season of Wednesday was split into two by Netflix, and the remaining four episodes have too much action and narrative packed in. Created by Alfred Gough and Miles Millar, with Tim Burton as executive producer and director, Wednesday has a lot going for it, but the story in the latter half of Season 2 is underwhelming despite each twist it throws at you. The makers are determined to involve every single character in its overstuffed plotline, leaving a very exhausted viewer at the end. The fallout from episode four leaves two dangerous fugitives from Willow Hill psychiatric hospital, the Hyde Tyler Galpin (Hunter Doohan) and Slurp (Owen Painter), the zombie that Wednesday’s (Jenna Ortega) brother Pugsley (Isaac Cordonez) befriends. Both Addams siblings set out to find them, and it leaves everyone converging towards a wild battle. At Nevermore, Enid (Emma Sinclair) discovers some distressing information about herself, while Principal Dort (Steve Buscemi) is insistent on having a grand gala for the school with possible donor Hester Frump (Joanna Lumley), Wednesday’s grandmother.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Rahul Desai
Rahul Desai | The Hollywood Reporter India
(Writing for OTT Play)
Thank God It’s (Finally) Friday (Part 1)

Sat, August 9 2025

Not the most satisfying watch, especially because the belated comeback feels like a cash-grabbing dash to reproduce more rather than course-correcting a greedy formula.

Wednesday Season 2 (Part 1: the first four episodes) arrives nearly three years after the goth-deadpan teenager and her morbid adventures became the most watched Netflix show of all time. Immortalised (not a term these characters are fond of) by actress Jenna Ortega, a death-coded Wednesday Addams saved her unmerry school of outcasts, the Nevermore Academy, by cracking a murder mystery and discovering that the boy she liked is a serial-killing monster puppeted by a psychopathic botany teacher. Season 2 takes an interesting route, more or less writing the new-age popularity of the series into its storyline. It opens with a Sixth-Sense-weds-Unbreakable tribute — extra marks for that — to show that Wednesday has learnt to control her psychic powers. She returns to Nevermore for the Fall semester. Except now she’s famous — and it annoys the hell out of her. Everyone knows her, and as an aspiring writer, it gets on her numbed nerves.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Sonal Pandya
Sonal Pandya | Times Now, Zoom
Jenna Ortega Starrer Returns For Sophomore Year Full Of Exciting Twists, Mysteries (Part 1)

Wed, August 6 2025

The sardonic teenager Wednesday Addams is back for another year at Nevermore Academy, where strange things continue to plague her.

The quirky and mysterious Addams family is back in Netflix’s top show Wednesday for Season 2. In the first half of season two, Wednesday Addams (Jenna Ortega) happily returns to Nevermore Academy, where new mysteries await her. Created by Alfred Gough & Miles Millar, the show also focuses on the rest of the Addams clan, with mother-daughter conflicts and younger sibling woes. After the massive success of its first season, the pressure is on for this next round. The dark comedy manages to tick all the boxes that made it a success the first time around. Rooming with her werewolf bestie, Enid Sinclair (Emma Myers), again, Wednesday is actually pleased to return to school. However, she became a celebrity after saving the school last year and Wednesday doesn’t like the attention. The teen doesn’t have much time to waste, receiving a premonition of Enid’s death and another set of strange murders to solve. This time, she deals with a persistent stalker, some old enemies, and a stubborn mother, Morticia (Catherine Zeta-Jones), who wants a progress report on her psychic abilities.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film The Conjuring: Last Rites
The Conjuring: Last Rites

Horror (English)

Paranormal investigators Ed and Lorraine Warren take on one last terrifying case involving mysterious entities they must confront.

Cast: Vera Farmiga, Patrick Wilson, Mia Tomlinson, Ben Hardy, Rebecca Calder, Elliot Cowan, Shannon Kook, Steve Coulter, Kíla Lord Cassidy, Beau Gadsdon
Director: Michael Chaves


FCG Member Reviewer Renuka Vyavahare
Renuka Vyavahare | The Times of India
More exhausting than eerie, the finale is weighed down by emotional drama

Fri, September 5 2025

Overloaded with ambition, the uneven pacing may not rob its tension, but it makes the experience more exhausting than terrifying.

Paranormal investigators Ed and Lorraine Warren (Patrick Wilson and Vera Farmiga) are enjoying retirement, until a chilling case in a remote Pennsylvania home draws them back into the darkness. The haunting isn’t just another possession… it has a terrifying link to their daughter, Judy (Mia Tomlinson). The fourth movie in the Conjuring universe, also touted as the finale, is a slowburn horror that burns a bit too slow. It stays loyal to the Conjuring template— big family in a haunted house, creepy attic, and eerie musical toys delivering solid jump scares—but it takes far too long to get to the point. Overloaded with ambition, the uneven pacing may not rob its tension, but it makes the experience more exhausting than terrifying. At 2 hours and 15 minutes, the final instalment feels bogged down by its heavy-handed emotional drama. Overstuffed, this time around the demonic spirits haunt not just one home but two – the Warrens and the Smurl family. The story shuttles between these two parallel tracks until they converge in an extended climax. The fear element persists but it gets overshadowed by the family drama.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Sanyukta Thakare
Sanyukta Thakare | Mashable India
Lorraine And Ed Get A Dramatic, Emotional Send Off As Technical Horror Bounces Back

Fri, September 5 2025

Feels long, but the last act saves the day

The Conjuring: Last Rites is the final release in the hit horror film franchise that debuted in 2013 with The Conjuring. The films explored stories of real-life couple Ed Warren and his wife Lorraine Warren, who were pioneers in the supernatural community back when their findings were often mocked by the scientific community. The final film in the franchise explores a very different and dramatic tone while also bringing back some classic filmmaking techniques of the franchise. The film has more drama than expected, but the last act picks up the pace enough for a good send-off. The film begins in 1864 as young Ed and Lorraine have begun taking new cases while expecting their baby, Judy. The first encounter with this demon puts their baby at risk, and they decide to never return to the case, but years later, after Judy has grown up, it shows up at another house among the Smurl family. However, after Ed suffers due to health complications, the Warrnes decide to stay away from the field and stick to sharing their knowledge through teaching.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film Songs of Paradise
FCG Rating for the film
Songs of Paradise

Music, Drama, Family (Hindi)

A young musician, Rumi, seeks the truth behind Noor Begum, a reclusive icon of Kashmiri music. Once Zeba, the valley’s first female radio singer, Noor’s journey from silence to song broke social barriers. As Rumi unearths her past, Songs of Paradise reveals a legacy of defiance, resilience, and the power of a voice that refused to be forgotten.

Cast: Saba Azad, Soni Razdan, Zain Khan Durrani, Taaruk Raina, Sheeba Chaddha, Shishir Sharma, Lillete Dubey, Chittaranjan Tripathy, Armaan Khera, Bashir Lone
Director: Danish Renzu


FCG Member Reviewer Akhil Arora
Akhil Arora | akhilarora.com
Th Long Take: A Spotify Review

Thu, September 4 2025

Songs of Paradise is like a 1950s movie that has time-traveled to the present day. We discuss the film’s old-fashioned narrative and undemanding themes, the chasm of quality between Saba Azad and Sheeba Chaddha’s performances, and the limited ambition of writer-director Danish Renzu. Songs of Paradise could’ve worked as a metaphor for post-Independence Kashmir, but instead, it’s like a bedtime story for five-year-olds.

FCG Member Reviewer Kshitij Rawat
Kshitij Rawat | Lifestyle Asia
Who really burnt down Noor Begum’s records?

Mon, September 1 2025

Songs of Paradise traces the life of Kashmir’s first female playback singer Raj Begum, albeit through a fictionalised tale.

Biopics are volatile beasts. Too deferential, and they end up mummifying their subjects in sepia-toned sainthood. Too irreverent, and they trivialise a life that originally clawed tooth and nail for attention. Songs of Paradise, Prime Video’s ode to Kashmir’s first female playback singer Raj Begum (fictionalised here as Zeba/Noor Begum), navigates this tightrope with unexpected ease. Let’s dive into Songs of Paradise story and ending, which are both explained here. What starts as the aspiration of a young Kashmiri girl in the 1950s (with the courage to sing when women were instructed to keep silent) in this Danish Renzu movie is, by the end, a generational echo. The flames which engulfed her recordings become the flames that illuminate the way for her granddaughter. The past is not lost as long as someone is still humming its melody.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Anuj Kumar
Anuj Kumar | The Hindu
A paean to the Voice of the Valley

Sun, August 31 2025

Saba Azad shines in this plain sailing story inspired by Raj Begum, the Nightingale of Kashmir

A musical drama loosely inspired by the life of Padma Shri Raj Begum, Songs of Paradise puts into focus the rich poetic culture of Kashmir that often gets buried under the “Files” of jaundiced perceptions. It is the side of Kashmir that we have hardly seen in Bollywood. Set in a time and space when the idea of a woman singing in public was taboo, it follows the struggle of Zeba Akhtar (Saba Azad/ Soni Razdan), who emerges as the voice of freedom because of her talent and tenacity. With the support of her tailor father (Bashir Lone is outstanding), Zeba stitches her musical dreams under the tutelage of Masterji (Shishir Sharma), who urges her to participate in a singing competition organised by Radio Kashmir. She wins the contest, but the social stigma attached to music forces her to assume a pseudonym, Noor Bano.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film Param Sundari
FCG Rating for the film
Param Sundari

Romance, Drama, Comedy (Hindi)

In Kerala's picturesque backwaters, a North Indian and South Indian find unexpected love. Their cultural differences spark a hilarious and chaotic romance, full of twists and turns.

Cast: Sidharth Malhotra, Janhvi Kapoor, Manjot Singh, Sanjay Kapoor, Inayat Verma, Renji Panicker, Siddhartha Shankar, Anand Manmadhan
Director: Tushar Jalota
Writer: Gaurav Mishra, Aarsh Vora, Tushar Jalota


FCG Member Reviewer Suhani Singh
Suhani Singh | India Today
Why 'Param Sundari' is all show and little soul

Tue, September 2 2025

Param Sundari's narrative, set in stereotyped Kerala, doesn't quite make hearts flicker; the Janhvi Kapoor-Sidharth Malhotra jodi isn't a fun opposites-attract story either

In the popular teen romance series Summer I Turned Pretty, adapted from Jenny Han’s books by the same name, leading lady Belly speaks of how she just can’t imagine marrying someone who doesn’t give her the “fireworks”“you know, like electric jolts, every time I see them”. In Tushar Jalota’s Param Sundari, Kerala’s most eligible girl Sundari (Janhvi Kapoor) finds herself in a similar conundrum when Punjabi munda Param (Sidharth Malhotra) strolls into her life (read homestay) believing she is his soulmate. Only unlike Belly’s karmic connection to Conrad, to whom the observation is made, Param and Sundari hardly exude MFEO (made for each other) vibes. And this despite having Sonu Nigam sing a pretty good romantic number in Pardesiya.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Arnab Banerjee
Arnab Banerjee | Indpendent Film Critic
(Writing for The Daily Eye)
Same old love story returns

Sun, August 31 2025

North Meets South, Clichés Meet Screen

Param Sundari, directed by Tushar Jalota and starring Sidharth Malhotra and Janhvi Kapoor, attempts a North-meets-South romance but falls flat. Laden with clichés, forced chemistry, and predictable tropes, the film struggles despite Kerala’s beauty, sidekick humour, and forgettable music. At 136 minutes, this Bollywood rom-com offers visual delight but little substance, proving yet again that cross-cultural love stories need more than recycled stereotypes and surface spectacle. India’s diversity has long been the go-to spice rack for Bollywood romances, and our filmmakers haven’t missed a single masala. From Raanjhanaa to Two States and Goliyon Ki Raasleela Ram-Leela, we’ve seen lovers playing Romeo and Juliet across caste lines, language barriers, and angry elders wielding moral outrage like a family heirloom. So, it’s no surprise that Param Sundari joins the tradition—this time with a Punjabi munda and a Malayali miss, thrown together in a cross-cultural curry that aims to be spicy but ends up more sambhar-lite.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Sucharita Tyagi
Sucharita Tyagi | Independent Film Critic
With some Assured Straightforwardness, Param Sundari Maybe Even Works?

Sun, August 31 2025

Image of scene from the film Hridayapoorvam
FCG Rating for the film
Hridayapoorvam

Romance, Comedy, Drama, Family (Malayalam)

Sandeep, a middle-aged bachelor who recently got a heart transplant, travels to Pune to attend the engagement of his heart-donor’s daughter, Haritha. Her engagement gets broken and Sandeep injures his back on the same day, forcing him to stay back in Pune for a few weeks, in his heart-donor’s house – who was an adventurous Colonel.

Cast: Mohanlal, Malavika Mohanan, Sangita, Sangeeth Prathap, Siddique, Janardhanan, Salim Hassan, Lalu Alex, Baburaj, Basil Joseph
Director: Sathyan Anthikad


FCG Member Reviewer Manoj Kumar
Manoj Kumar | Independent Film Critic
(Writing for Medium)
Mohanlal in a 40-Year-Old Virgin-Esque Comedy with Indian Sensibility

Mon, September 1 2025

I watched Hridayapoorvam, the latest Malayalam film starring Mohanlal and directed by Sathyan Anthikad. Sathyan is one of those rare filmmakers who know how to turn everyday life into cinema that feels honest, entertaining, and deeply relatable. At a time when the industry is obsessed with big blockbusters, massive sets, and larger-than-life heroics, here comes a film that quietly wins you over with storytelling, humour, and heart. The film is, in a way, a Malayalam version of The 40-Year-Old Virgin. But don’t mistake that for awkward gags or over-the-top comedy. This is The 40-Year-Old Virgin reimagined with our sensibility — sensitive, clean, and packaged with humour that a family audience can comfortably enjoy. Mohanlal plays a middle-aged, unmarried man, Sandeep, who undergoes a heart transplant. His life takes an unexpected turn when he meets the family of his donor — a widow Devika (Sangita Madhavan Nair), and her daughter, Haritha (Malavika Mohanan). Sathyan sets up a delicate, almost taboo situation: a man who has never really known female attention suddenly finds himself at the receiving end of affection from two women — one closer to his age, and the other much younger.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Aditya Shrikrishna
Aditya Shrikrishna | Independent Film Critic
As Light And Harmless As They Come

Fri, August 29 2025

Quintessential Sathyan Anthikad — light on its feet, airy and like a warm beverage on a rainy afternoon.

Sandeep Balakrishnan (Mohanlal), a successful cloud kitchen owner from Kochi, possesses a generous heart. His tenants are three aspiring filmmakers who eat in his kitchen for free, and he treats them like his own children. They narrate their script to him, an ultra-violent revenge story that disgusts him to the point of disowning them. Even their insistence that “violence is trending” doesn’t change his mind. This scene, from Sathyan Anthikad’s new film Hridayapoorvam, is a comedic aside, but it also conveys the self-awareness of this film. It’s quintessential Anthikad — light on its feet, airy and like a warm beverage on a rainy afternoon, but now such a film wants to reinforce its merits. The saturation of high-octane mass entertainers has pervaded Indian popular culture so forcefully and brazenly that even a Malayalam film feels the need to acknowledge, course correct and advertise. But, no complaints, it is indeed nice to stay in a different zip code than whatever is trending.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Avinash Ramachandran
Avinash Ramachandran | The New Indian Express
A fantastic Mohanlal powers this warm hug of a film

Fri, August 29 2025

Hridayapoorvam is almost like Mohanlal’s return gift to a 2025 that has given him all of this, and much more

Mohanlal and Sathyan Anthikad have been defining the emotional core of the average Malayali for over four decades now. Despite technological advancements, the propensity for action extravaganzas in today’s times, and the seeming erosion of the audience’s attention span, Mohanlal and Sathyan reunite for a film that reminds us why these two were allowed to define emotions closest to our hearts. Anger, love, fear, guilt, regret, happiness, devastating sadness, and a smile that finds its way through it all…

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film The Roses
FCG Rating for the film
The Roses

Comedy, Drama (English)

Life seems easy for picture-perfect couple Ivy and Theo: successful careers, a loving marriage, great kids. But beneath the façade of their supposed ideal life, a storm is brewing – as Theo's career nosedives while Ivy's own ambitions take off, a tinderbox of fierce competition and hidden resentment ignites.

Cast: Benedict Cumberbatch, Olivia Colman, Andy Samberg, Kate McKinnon, Allison Janney, Ncuti Gatwa, Jamie Demetriou, Zoë Chao, Belinda Bromilow, Sunita Mani
Director: Jay Roach


FCG Member Reviewer Udita Jhunjhunwala
Udita Jhunjhunwala | Mint, Scroll.in
Benedict Cumberbatch and Olivia Colman spar memorably

Mon, September 1 2025

Director Jay Roach, Cumberbatch and Colman successfully reimagine the dark marital comedy ‘The War of the Roses’

The Roses is director Jay Roach and screenwriter Tony McNamara’s reimagining of the 1989 film The War of the Roses, which starred Michael Douglas and Kathleen Turner in an untamed marital war. In the 2025 version, Benedict Cumberbatch and Olivia Colman take on the marital troubles of a modern couple in this black comedy that feels at once familiar and also entirely new. Ivy Rose (Colman) and Theo Rose (Cumberbatch), negotiate the challenges of professional and personal life as they move from unshakable love to complete hatred. The Roses’ love story starts just as impulsively as it ends—passionate, spontaneous, till death do them part. She’s a chef, he’s an architect. They move from the UK to California to explore and expand their creativity.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Rahul Desai
Rahul Desai | The Hollywood Reporter India
Wonderfully Thorny, Deceptively Poignant

Fri, August 29 2025

The Roses is a caustic satire about a wealthy couple struggling to stay married. Unlike most couples content to survive, the Roses strive to live — they say what they feel and do what they say.

Based on Warren Adler’s novel The War of the Roses, Jay Roach’s The Roses is fundamentally different from Danny DeVito’s 1989 film adaptation starring Michael Douglas and Kathleen Turner. The caustic black comedy about a wealthy American couple going through a bitter divorce is reframed as a caustic satire about a wealthy British couple struggling to stay married. The razor-sharp humour is a coping mechanism for the characters, not so much a narrative genre. When they’re mean to each other, it’s amusing because of how creatively they weaponise words, but it’s also dark for how far they’re willing to go to wound each other. When they’re not mean, it’s tense because a barb or two — like a jumpscare in ghost stories — might just be around the corner. Watching them is like being trapped in a room with a dysfunctional couple and second-hand embarrassment.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Sucharita Tyagi
Sucharita Tyagi | Independent Film Critic
Can This Silly Film Save Your Day?

Fri, August 29 2025

Image of scene from the film Vash Level 2
Vash Level 2

Thriller, Horror (Gujarati)

Twelve years after saving his daughter Arya from a dark force, Atharva learns it never left her. When strange events begin again, he must fight to save her once more.

Cast: Janki Bodiwala, Hiten Kumar, Hitu Kanodia, Monal Gajjar, Chetan Daiya
Director: Krishnadev Yagnik
Writer: Krishnadev Yagnik


FCG Member Reviewer Keyur Seta
Keyur Seta | Bollywood Hungama
(Writing for The Common Man Speaks)
Chilling saga of black magic creating mass destruction

Sun, August 31 2025

Writer and director Krishnadev Yagnik’s Gujarati movie Vash (2023) turned out to be a thrilling saga of black magic. The film was later remade in Hindi as Shaitaan (2024). Sequels of horror films are always expected to overpower the first one but that doesn’t happen always. But Vash Level 2 actually goes up several notches as far as the vashikaran (casting a black magic spell) is concerned. Vash Level 2 continues 12 years from where Vash ended (hence, you need to watch the first film to understand the second one). Atharva (Hitu Kanodia) is leading a quiet life with his daughter Aarya (Janki Bodiwala), who is still under the black magic spell, after his son Ansh (Aaryan Sanghvi) and wife (Niilam Paanchal) are killed. But unknown to the world, inside a dark corner of his bungalow, he has kept hidden the black magic monster Pratap (Hiten Kumar), who is responsible for the tragedy in his and his family’s life, in the most inhuman condition possible. He doesn’t let him live, nor die.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Rahul Desai
Rahul Desai | The Hollywood Reporter India
Fear and Loathing in Modern Gujarat

Thu, August 28 2025

This sequel to the Gujarati horror film 'Vash' is a potent blend of craft and commentary

A pack of teenage schoolgirls wreak havoc across a city. They overpower everyone and everything in sight, seemingly possessed by superhuman strength and violent desire. The attack is visceral and unstructured, like the beginning of a dance rehearsal gone wrong. Their school uniforms become a symbol of danger. The police are clueless; the parents are terrified. The setting is notoriously sexist, so the sight of them spreading chaos is oddly empowering. In most movies, it would be. But Vash Level 2 is not most movies. The sequel to Vash (2023), Krishnadev Yagnik’s national award-winning supernatural thriller that was remade as Shaitaan (2024) in Hindi, our simplistic perception of female empowerment is thrown out of the window (or, well, off a terrace). Even their “rebellion” is defined by subservience; their agency is shaped by the crippling lack of one. For they are actually controlled by a sinister male stranger (Hiten Kumar) who laced their lunch with black-magic dust. The rampage is happening against the girls’ wishes; their bodies are weaponised but their minds are scared. Most of them attack hawkers, motorists and street-dwellers and bash their heads in, regardless of gender or status. The smash-the-patriarchy allegory unfolds like a cruel joke. The brainwashing and societal-conditioning metaphors unfold like punchlines.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film The Thursday Murder Club
FCG Rating for the film
The Thursday Murder Club

Mystery, Comedy (English)

Four septuagenarian friends living in a retirement community form the Thursday Murder Club to solve cold cases for fun. But when a shady property developer is found dead, the four find themselves in the middle of their first live case.

Cast: Helen Mirren, Pierce Brosnan, Ben Kingsley, Celia Imrie, David Tennant, Jonathan Pryce, Naomi Ackie, Daniel Mays, Henry Lloyd-Hughes, Richard E. Grant
Director: Chris Columbus
Writer: Suzanne Heathcote


FCG Member Reviewer Udita Jhunjhunwala
Udita Jhunjhunwala | Mint, Scroll.in
Affable cast sells senior citizen whodunit

Sun, August 31 2025

Richard Osman’s novel about four retirement home residents who are also amateur sleuths gets a winning screen adaptation

Richard Osman’s 2020 novel The Thursday Murder Club soon became a runaway bestseller and a book-club favourite. Its delightful premise follows four older residents living at Cooper Chase, an expansive English retirement home, who meet weekly to discuss unsolved crimes—only to find themselves entangled in a real-life murder investigation. Osman’s novel balanced wit, warmth and intricate plotting to create a clever and endearing mystery, drawing readers into piecing together clues from a wide field of suspects. The film adaptation, written by Katy Brand and Suzanne Heathcote and directed by Chris Columbus (on Netflix) embraces the same charming setup but inevitably takes a different route. The heart of the story—the idea of senior citizens becoming unlikely detectives—remains intact. The setup too remains playful and refreshing, as older characters take the spotlight in a genre usually dominated by hardened investigators, somewhat like Only Murders in the Building but with only senior sleuths, and set in an English retirement home rather than an American apartment block.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Priyanka Roy
Priyanka Roy | The Telegraph
Operates on familiar beats, but its cast keeps the film’s whodunit heart beating

Sun, August 24 2025

Picture this: A cup of steaming hot chocolate in hand, you snuggle up in your warm quilt on your favourite couch by the window and watch the rains hit the greens outside making it even more verdant. That same fuzzy feeling of familiarity and comfort is what you experience when you watch The Thursday Murder Club. Based on the best-selling 2020 whodunit by Richard Osman (who has gone on to write a few more in the series), The Thursday Murder Club takes you into the world of old-school sleuthing. One which relies on both smarts and intellect to fit together the pieces of a jigsaw puzzle to solve more than one murder, without having to rely on Gen-Z-coded cinema loaded with high-octane car chases and gravity-defying action sequences. If one were to quote a journalistic analogy, The Thursday Murder Club is the equivalent of good ol’ shoe leather reporting.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Sonal Pandya
Sonal Pandya | Times Now, Zoom
Helen Mirren, Pierce Brosnan Bring Star Power To Enjoyable British Mystery Adaptation

Sat, August 23 2025

Director Chris Columbus ably adapts the first book in Richard Osman's popular mystery series with a who's who of the British film industry

After Harry Potter, filmmaker Chris Columbus spearheads another popular franchise. The Netflix film, The Thursday Murder Club, is the first of five books about four retired senior citizens who solve murders. Richard Osman’s mysteries are bestsellers worldwide and this first film casts Oscar winners and popular British stars in the main roles. The result is a cheeky and delightful romp across the countryside as the retirees try to save their retirement home and figure out who is willing to kill for the land it’s built on.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film Maa
FCG Rating for the film
Maa

Horror (Hindi)

A mother and daughter encounter a demon in a village where girls have been disappearing.

Cast: Kajol, Ronit Roy, Indraneil Sengupta, Jitin Gulati, Kherin Sharma, Gopal Singh, Dibyendu Bhattacharya, Aashit Chatterjee, Vibha Rani, Yaaneea Bhardwaj
Director: Vishal Furia


FCG Member Reviewer Rohan Naahar
Rohan Naahar | The Indian Express
In case you didn’t know killing babies is wrong, Kajol’s movie is here to educate you; phew

Sat, August 30 2025

It would be a stretch to even describe Maa as a horror film, seeing how far it strays from the genre in its final act. This is when Kajol's character delivers a lecture about why female infanticide is bad.

The problem with Hindi horror movies used to be that they’d sabotage their scares with music and romance. This was done mainly as a promotional tactic to lure (family) audiences to theatres, and to then give them an opportunity to use the washroom or get a popcorn refill during the interval. Neither the music nor the romance had any business being in those movies, but they were left intact anyway. They contributed nothing to the plot; in fact, they actually brought it to a standstill. The music and romance issue with Hindi horror has now been replaced with an even more irritating trend: social messaging. The latest film to fall prey to this bizarre, self-defeating strategy is Maa. It would, however, be a stretch to even describe it as a horror film, seeing how far it strays from the genre in its final act. This is when Kajol’s grieving single mother, Ambika, discovers that her teenage daughter has been kidnapped by a forest-dwelling demon, who intends on impregnating her to carry forward his ‘vansh’ or some nonsense. Ambika rushes into the lion’s den, so to speak, determined to rescue her daughter from the demon’s clutches. But before she leaves on her mission, she is told by the superstitious locals that she must perform a ritual, and seek the blessings of Goddess Kali. Kali is the only one who can vanquish the demon, she is told. And so, Ambika… does a song-and-dance number.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Suhani Singh
Suhani Singh | India Today
Kajol's heroic not-without-my-daughter act can't lift up this horror

Mon, June 30 2025

Mining India's mythology and religious beliefs to craft a horror that's contemporarily relevant is a nifty idea, but to do so frighteningly well is another thing altogether

Mothers are a resilient lot. Harm their kids, then be ready for a battle. In Maa, Kajol’s maternal instincts face their toughest test as she contends with superstitions as well as a girl child-feasting, tree-residing monster who has eyes on her adolescent daughter. Kajol’s Ambika is an ordinary woman trapped in extraordinary circumstances, but then the film’s title isn’t just a nod to her but also to the powerful and dangerous deity who should not be messed with—Kali Maa. Mining India’s mythology and religious beliefs to craft a horror that’s contemporarily relevant is a nifty idea that’s been attempted before, but to do so frighteningly well is another thing altogether. Maa takes the tried and tested not-without-my-daughter formula and spins it round and round until audiences are left frustrated at the actions of characters.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Anmol Jamwal
Anmol Jamwal | Tried & Refused Productions
When intention gets weighed down by execution.

Sun, June 29 2025

Image of scene from the film Maareesan
FCG Rating for the film
Maareesan

Thriller (Tamil)

In an unusual situation, Velayudham sets out on a journey with Dhaya from Nagercoil to Tiruvannamalai-a journey that will alter both their lives in ways they never imagined.

Cast: Vadivelu, Fahadh Faasil, Kovai Sarala, Sithara, Renuka, Vivek Prasanna, P.L. Thenappan, Saravana Subbiah
Director: Sudheesh Shankar
Writer: Krishna Moorthy


FCG Member Reviewer Rohan Naahar
Rohan Naahar | The Indian Express
Fahadh Faasil’s film fools you into forgiving terrible crimes with its farfetched plot twist

Sat, August 30 2025

Starring Fahadh Faasil and Vadivelu, the Tamil-language film Maareesan gaslights you into giving a thumbs-up to a mass murdering maniac.

At what point do you start feeling bad about the idea of wanting someone dead? While watching the new Tamil-language film Maareesan, you crave nothing more than the satisfaction of seeing a middle-aged man murder child molesters. The movie aims to appease a primal desire buried deep within us, and it does so with patience and skill. But the catharsis is temporary. After a while, you’re going to have to live with yourself, a person who wouldn’t mind a few murders here and there as long as the ones being murdered are terrible people. But, the service that Maareesan is accidentally providing has a greater purpose. In its efforts to manipulate our inherent goodness — who wouldn’t want to watch bad people be punished? — it is exposing our blood lust.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Akhil Arora
Akhil Arora | akhilarora.com
The Long Take: A Spotify Review

Wed, August 27 2025

In the Tamil-language film Maareesan, the plot twist comes not at the end, but midway through. We talk about the sudden change in tone, and how the film handles it. We also discuss Fahadh Faasil’s comedic performance, and wonder why the film is presented through the perspective of his character. But mainly, we talk about the film’s shady morality, which seems to champion extrajudicial killings if the cause is perceived as noble enough.

FCG Member Reviewer Janani K
Janani K | India Today
Fahadh-Vadivelu's road trip takes wrong turn post-interval

Thu, July 24 2025

Director Sudheesh Sankar's 'Maareesan', starring Vadivelu and Fahadh Faasil, is a comedy thriller. While the film wows you with a brilliant first half, it takes a formulaic turn in the second half.

‘Maareesan’ brings together Tamil comedy legend Vadivelu and brilliant performer Fahadh Faasil for the second time after ‘Maamannan’. While the two have their individual strengths, they are terrific performers. Give them any role, their eyes are enough to pull them off. Director Sudheesh Sankar’s ‘Maareesan’ is a comedy thriller, a genre that could either be effective or a total misfire. Dayalan (Fahadh Faasil) is a thief who is just out of the infamous Palayamkottai prison. In his words, certain houses talk to him and call him, so he could rob them. Soon after his return, he finds Velayudham Pillai’s (Vadivelu) house calling him. He breaks into the house to steal, but only to find Velayudham chained to his bed.

Continue reading …