← Previous Next →

Guild Reviews

Image of scene from the film The Morning Show S04
The Morning Show S04

Drama (English)

A behind-the-scenes look at the lives of the people who help America wake up in the morning, exploring the unique challenges faced by the men and women who carry out this daily televised ritual.

Cast: Jennifer Aniston, Reese Witherspoon, Billy Crudup, Mark Duplass, Greta Lee, Nicole Beharie, Nestor Carbonell, Karen Pittman, Jon Hamm, Marion Cotillard


FCG Member Reviewer Sonal Pandya
Sonal Pandya | Times Now, Zoom
Jennifer, Reese Starrer Remains Stuck In Same Chaos Even With New Faces

Fri, September 19 2025

Created by Jay Carson, the network drama once again addresses topical subjects, but once again the show suffers from having too many characters to focus on.

The Morning Show was launched in 2019 as a vehicle for stars Jennifer Aniston and Reese Witherspoon. The show also reflected on the changing landscape of TV journalism with topical issues like the MeToo movement, the COVID-19 pandemic, and even the January 6th riots at the Capitol. This season, the Apple TV+ returns with a focus on the 2024 Olympics in Paris while also tackling AI (artificial intelligence). Already crowded with pending storylines, The Morning Show adds fuel to the fire by introducing several new conflicts for its burdened characters. Alex Levy (Aniston) and Bradley Jackson (Witherspoon) have survived the events of the last season of The Morning Show. The new season returns two years after the events of the last, with Alex as a top executive at the new UBN network and Bradley seemingly retired as a journalist. So what reunites the two again? The TV anchors face it all this time around with deepfakes, conspiracy theories, and corporate cover-ups that keep threatening them and those around them. The stakes are even higher, as this time the two women battle a hidden enemy.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film Slow Horses S05
Slow Horses S05

Crime, Drama, Comedy (English)

Follow a dysfunctional team of MI5 agents—and their obnoxious boss, the notorious Jackson Lamb—as they navigate the espionage world's smoke and mirrors to defend England from sinister forces.

Cast: Gary Oldman, Jack Lowden, Kristin Scott Thomas


FCG Member Reviewer Sonal Pandya
Sonal Pandya | Times Now, Zoom
Gary Oldman's Spy Drama Sets Scene With Terrific Twisty Mystery, Carrying Series Ahead

Fri, September 19 2025

Created by Will Smith, the British espionage drama has plenty of juice in its tank to power several seasons.

It may not get enough awards love or attention, but Slow Horses is quietly plodding on as one of the most dependable and exhilarating spy series on streaming. With Season 5 about to premiere, the sixth and seventh seasons are already in the works at Apple TV+. The fifth season brings yet another puzzle to Gary Oldman’s spymaster, Jackson Lamb, who proves to the MI5 heads why he’s the best they’ve got. With strong performances by Jack Lowden, Kristin Scott Thomas, and Saskia Reeves, the newest season is another thrilling ride. The rejected MI5 agents of Slough House get yet another opportunity to save the day and one-up the headquarters at Regent’s Park. This time, a terror plot links back to one of their own, as tech guy Roddy Ho (Christopher Chung) has been honey-trapped. The British intelligence organisation gets a taste of their own medicine as potential terror incidents take place all over London, rattling those in power. It’s up to Lamb and his underutilised and underarmed team of ‘rejected’ spies to step in with their wits to avoid a larger catastrophe.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film Bayaan
Bayaan

Drama, Crime, Thriller (Hindi)

When a letter accuses a revered cult leader of abuse, rookie detective Roohi Kartar is sent to a small Indian town to investigate. Confronted by a wall of silence and blind devotion, she must uncover the truth before it's too late.

Cast: Huma Qureshi, Chandrachur Singh, Sachin Khedekar, Swati Das, Vibhore Mayank, Sampa Mandal, Perry Chhabra, Avijit Dutt, Aditi Kanchan Singh, Paritosh Sand
Director: Bikas Ranjan Mishra
Writer: Bikas Ranjan Mishra


FCG Member Reviewer Ishita Sengupta
Ishita Sengupta | Independent Film Critic
(Writing for OTT Play)
A Frustrating Reiteration Of India's Godmen Culture

Fri, September 19 2025

In India, the concept of godmen — spiritual leaders elevated to the status of demigod — has spawned a series of narratives. Fiction (Aashram ) and non-fiction (My Daughter Joined a Cult, Cult of Fear: Asaram Bapu, etc) alike have responded to the peculiarity of the culture. Bikas Ranjan Mishra’s new film, Bayaan, a loosely wound police procedural that premiered at the Toronto International Film Festival, is a frustrating reiteration of the template. To be fair, Bayaan is largely effective and well-made with slight exceptions. The plot is rooted in Rajasthan, where a godman, ‘Maharaj’ (Chandrachur Singh), runs an ashram full of young girls. When one of them tips off about his sexual abuse, a Delhi-based police officer, Roohi (Huma Qureshi), is assigned to the case. She might be a novice, but she knows the way. Her father (Sachin Khedekar) has been in the profession for a long time and is celebrated by peers. Mishra’s film outlines the way in which an anonymous tip opens a can of worms for the godman, only for Roohi to realise that she, a privileged urban woman, inhabits a world as compliant as that of the rural women.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Sucharita Tyagi
Sucharita Tyagi | Independent Film Critic
Tends to get patchy, occasionally tripping on clunky dialogue and rushed writing

Mon, September 15 2025

Image of scene from the film Bandar
Bandar (Monkey In A Cage)

Thriller (Hindi)

TV star Samar's life spirals when his ex Gayatri accuses him of rape after he blocks contact with her. Despite his new relationship with Khushi, he faces arrest and encounters a corrupt justice system.

Cast: Bobby Deol, Sanya Malhotra, Saba Azad, Sapna Pabbi, Joju George, Riddhi Sen, Ankush Gedam, Nagesh Bhonsle, Jeetendra Joshi, Jaimini Pathak
Director: Anurag Kashyap


FCG Member Reviewer Ishita Sengupta
Ishita Sengupta | Independent Film Critic
(Writing for OTT Play)
A Thorny Post-MeToo Drama That Provokes Needlessly

Fri, September 19 2025

In Anurag Kashyap’s Monkey in a Cage (Bandar), provocations arrive early. When a man held in custody is asked to sign papers, he refuses because he cannot read the document. “It’s in Marathi”. The cop’s retort flies back: “If you want to stay in Maharashtra, you have to know Marathi”. Later, there is an elaborate jail song, condemning everything from religion to caste-based divides. Kashyap has been angry for a while. The filmmaker’s rage has been so palpable that it percolates from social media posts to his films. His last couple of original works have been topical indictments — each more incensed than the other, and defined and undone by fury. At this point, his anger is a knotty glaze on his films — impossible to ignore but also distracting. The pattern has been so consistent that baiting seems to be the intent and the whole point. His latest, Monkey in a Cage, which premiered at the Toronto International Film Festival, is a more obvious step towards that direction.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Sucharita Tyagi
Sucharita Tyagi | Independent Film Critic
Refuses to bend to moral binaries

Mon, September 15 2025

Image of scene from the film Poetic License
Poetic License

Comedy (English)

Liz, a former therapist and soon-to-be empty nester, becomes the unexpected point of tension between two inseparable best friends and college seniors, Sam and Ari. Liz is forced to re-examine her life as the boys’ friendship unravels in a fierce competition for her affection.

Cast: Andrew Barth Feldman, Cooper Hoffman, Leslie Mann, Nico Parker, Maisy Stella, Method Man, Martha Kelly, Will Price, Jake Bongiovi, Angelina David
Director: Maude Apatow
Writer: Raffi Donatich


FCG Member Reviewer Ishita Sengupta
Ishita Sengupta | Independent Film Critic
(Writing for OTT Play)
Effortlessly Charming

Fri, September 19 2025

In films, the presence of three is inherently fodder. The arrangement can be disruptive, but it is mainly used by makers to arrive at familiar resolutions. In her wonderfully assured directorial debut, Poetic License, Maude Apatow flips the script. She takes three people, resists settling for sweeping endings and shakes things up for fun. It is a lovely detour that is consistently rewarding. Ari (Cooper Hoffman) and Sam (Andrew Barth Feldman) have been friends for a while. As students, their lives have been mostly spent on campus. Things, however, are about to change. The erudite Sam has his eyes set on a finance job, while Ari, the rich young boy prone to wearing LED face masks at leisure, is still trying to figure things out. A poetry class together becomes their latest way of hanging out. But when Liz (Leslie Mann) sits with them in class, their attention to each other wavers a little. There is only one problem: Liz is a married woman with a daughter. Her professor-husband’s new job at the university brings her to a quiet town from Chicago, as she sits with them in a poetry class to audit.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film It Was Just an Accident
It Was Just an Accident

Drama (Persian)

What begins as a minor accident sets in motion a series of escalating consequences.

Cast: Vahid Mobasseri, Mariam Afshari, Ebrahim Azizi, Hadis Pakbaten, Madjid Panahi, Mohamad Ali Elyasmehr, George Hashemzadeh, Delmaz Najafi, Afssaneh Najmabadi
Director: Jafar Panahi
Writer: Jafar Panahi


FCG Member Reviewer Ishita Sengupta
Ishita Sengupta | Independent Film Critic
(Writing for OTT PLay)
An Effective Study Of Compassion

Fri, September 19 2025

On paper, It Was Just an Accident bears the blueprint of Panahi’s work where complexity arises from an innocuous incident. A regular pitstop proves to be pivotal. It turns out that the onlooker, Vahid (a wonderful Vahid Mobasseri), has a traumatic history of knowing the man looking for help. In fact, not only does he know him, but so do a lot of people — a wedding photographer, a woman about to get married, a man still traumatised with his past. Turns out, the man in question is an officer of the state who had tortured them when they were in jail. But here’s the catch: no one is really sure. They were blindfolded when they were imprisoned, and although the man (called Eghbal, played by Ebrahim Azizi) sounds and smells like him, and even has a limp, there is uncertainty.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Shubhra Gupta
Shubhra Gupta | The Indian Express
Jafar Pahani’s Cannes drama lays bare humans’ taste for violence, how it hurts themselves

Fri, May 23 2025

Jafar Pahani’s It Was Just An Accident, his second foray into Cannes competition, is about what happens when an unexpected incident rolls over into wholly unexpected territory. Destiny and chance are play, as is, we discover, righteous vengeance.

It’s late in the night, and a family of three, a husband, wife, and their young daughter, is heading back home. Suddenly, there’s a sickening thump, and the car comes to a halt. The man gets out, looks at something on the ground, his face lit by the headlights. We do not see the exact shape or size of the roadkill, but the little girl mentions the death of a dog, the woman justifies it as an act of god, and this little interlude sets the tone for the rest of the film.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film Tango Malhar
Tango Malhar

Drama (Marathi)

When Malhar, an auto driver, accidentally discovers Argentine Tango, he finds himself torn between his conservative roots and an elite dance community. Along the way he uncovers connection, awakening something beyond his mundane existence

Cast: Akshay Gaikwad, Nitesh Kamble, Kriti Shrinivasan
Director: Saya Date


FCG Member Reviewer Tusshar Sasi
Tusshar Sasi | Filmy Sasi
Indian heart in an Argentinian dance

Thu, September 18 2025

There’s a point in Tango Malhar where it stops feeling like a promotional piece for the Argentinian dance form it’s named after. That moment arrives when siblings Malhar (Nitesh Kamble) and Rani (Kriti Vishwanathan) are secretly filmed while passionately practicing tango in a secluded building. In Saya Date’s film, this scandalous act carries the potential to ignite controversy, challenging the sanctity of familial bonds. Where will the story go from here? That question becomes the film’s most compelling suspense. Tango Malhar opens with Malhar, a 20-something autorickshaw driver, grooving to Indian hip-hop on his earphones. He lives with his widowed mother and school-going younger sister in a cramped city home. Early in the film, we see Rani’s love for dance and her brother’s latent rhythm. A man of few words, Malhar is still searching for purpose when tango unexpectedly enters his life.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film Dashavatar
Dashavatar

Drama, Thriller, Adventure (Marathi)

When evil rises, divinity manifests to defeat it. An aging Dashavatar folk theater performer faces life's storms, guided by the wisdom of this traditional Konkan art form blending myth, music, and dance.

Cast: Mahesh Manjrekar, Priyadarshini Indalkar, Dilip Prabhavalkar, Siddharth Menon, Lokesh Mittal, Ravi Kale, Bharat Jadhav, Abhinay Berde, Sunil Tawde, Aarti Wadagbalkar
Director: Subodh Khanolkar
Writer: Guru Thakur, Subodh Khanolkar


FCG Member Reviewer Keyur Seta
Keyur Seta | Bollywood Hungama
(Writing for The Common Man Speaks)
Dilip Prabhavalkar shines in the film that doesn’t live up to the interest it generates

Wed, September 17 2025

Dashavatar scores high in getting you transported to the small Konkan village where it’s based. The scenic place is shot well by cinematographer Devendra Golatkar. The village’s folk theatre culture is portrayed in a realistic manner. It also acts as a tribute to the unsung theatre artistes from various corners of India. The bittersweet relation between Babuli and Madhav also brings a smile, although the song between them could have been done away with. Dashavatar brings a shocking incident at the interval point. From here on, you expect the film to rise further. But, instead, it starts suffering from the second half syndrome. The incidents where various avatars of Lord Vishnu are brought in not only make the narrative predictable but also lack logic as it’s difficult to believe what one character keeps doing. Plus, the screenplay starts becoming messier as the film nears the climax with quite a few questionable incidents. The climax gives an important social message but it suits more in the medium of theatre than cinema.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Mihir Bhanage
Mihir Bhanage | The Times of India
Dilip Prabhavalkar is the rakhandar of this visual spectacle

Sat, September 13 2025

In the Konkan region of Maharashtra, Dashavatar presentations continue to be a huge draw. The traditional theatre form is centred around the ten incarnations of Lord Vishnu, and its performers command immense respect and popularity. Subodh Khanolkar’s Dashavatar is the story of one such performer – Babuli Mestri (Dilip Prabhavalkar). Having performed in the traditional theatre all his life, Babuli is almost synonymous to Dashavatar in his village, so much that his entry in the presentation is all that people look forward to. Age is fast catching up with Babuli, but he refuses to hang his boots despite repeated pleas from his doctor and even his son Madhav (Siddharth Menon). Babuli promises to retire only when Madhav gets a job and starts earning. When that happens, the veteran performer stays true to his word and announces his last performance during a Mahashivratri celebration. On the other hand, Madhav also decides to ask for his girlfriend Vandana’s (Priyadarshini Indalkar) hand in marriage on the auspicious day. But tragedy strikes, derailing everyone’s plans and putting in motion a series of entirely unexpected events.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film Fresh
Fresh

Horror, Thriller (English)

Frustrated by scrolling dating apps only to end up on lame, tedious dates, Noa takes a chance by giving her number to the awkwardly charming Steve after a produce-section meet-cute at the grocery store.

Cast: Daisy Edgar-Jones, Sebastian Stan, Jojo T. Gibbs, Charlotte Le Bon, Dayo Okeniyi, Andrea Bang, Brett Dier, Alina Maris, William Belleau, Lachlan Quarmby
Director: Mimi Cave
Writer: Lauryn Kahn


FCG Member Reviewer Priyanka Roy
Priyanka Roy | The Telegraph
A commentary on modern-day dating and an original take on the splatter genre

Wed, September 17 2025

Deliciously sinister and delectably unhinged, Fresh is a commentary on the perils of modern dating, with a refreshingly original take on the splatter genre. This 2022 film, available for streaming on JioHotstar, marks the debut of Mimi Cave (who has since gone on to direct this year’s middling Nicole Kidman thriller Holland), and manages to winningly (at least for the most part) be a dark comedy, a feminist tale and a horror fest at the same time. Fresh begins in a way that most films on modern-day urban loneliness do. Noa (Daisy Edgar-Jones) is striking, sharp and smart, but doesn’t seem to have much luck in the dating department. With almost no family to call her own, it is her closest pal Mollie (Jojo T. Gibbs) that Noa leans on emotionally. A few days after a particularly bad first date, Noa bumps into a charming stranger (Steve, played by Sebastian Stan) in a supermarket aisle. Numbers are exchanged, a few fun dates follow and before we know it, Noa is hopelessly charmed by the disarming Steve, who claims to be a doctor specialising in ‘reconstructive surgery’. More on that later.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film Vimukt
Vimukt (In Search of the Sky)

Drama (Hindi)

When A 26-year-old mentally unstable son of a poverty-stricken elderly couple begins to feel like a burden and the reason for constant mockery in a village they have lived their entire life. The couple's decides to travel to the Maha Kumbh, once in a 144-year pilgrimage, largest human gathering on the planet. Will this journey bring them the healing they hoped for? Or will their lives be changed forever?

Cast: Nikhil Yadav, Meghna Agarwal, Raghvendra Bhadoriya
Director: Jitank Singh Gurjar


FCG Member Reviewer Tatsam Mukherjee
Tatsam Mukherjee | The Wire
A Face to the Poor Who Are Otherwise Only Seen as a Mass

Tue, September 16 2025

The first ever film in Braj has received its premiere at the Toronto International Film Festival (TIFF).

In the last decade, it’s been heartening to see filmmaking voices emerge from the heartland, drawing raw, earthy portraits of rural life, where more than half of India still resides. We see such films hiding in the garb of a genre: comedy, satire, police procedural etc, especially when the director isn’t familiar with the milieu. Hence, the work of an assured filmmaker jumps out at us. The likes of Natesh Hegde, Anmol Sidhu, Achal Mishra etc, confidently marry sophisticated aesthetics with a lived-in grittiness. Director Jitank Singh Gurjar fits right into this mix as his feature debut, In Search of the Sky (alternate title: Vimukt) suggests. Told in Braj language, it tells the story of a family in rural Madhya Pradesh, which is trying to escape its life sentence by visiting the Mahakumbh.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Sucharita Tyagi
Sucharita Tyagi | Independent Film Critic
Despite the observational richness, Vimukt falters in pacing and basic storytelling.

Mon, September 15 2025

Image of scene from the film Su From So
FCG Rating for the film
Su From So

Comedy, Horror, Drama (Kannada)

In a peaceful village full of joy, laughter, and vibrant life, everything seems perfect—until one day, the devil arrives. What follows is a hilarious chain of events that flips the entire village upside down!

Cast: Shaneel Gautham, JP Tuminad, Sandhya Arakere, Prakash K Thuminadu, Deepak Rai Panaje, Mime Ramdas, Pushparaj Bollar, Arjun Kaje, Raj B Shetty
Director: JP Tuminad
Writer: JP Tuminad


FCG Member Reviewer Manoj Kumar
Manoj Kumar | Independent Film Critic
(Writing for Medium)
A Small Film with a Big Heart

Mon, September 15 2025

I recently watched this Kannada film called Su from So. It’s written and directed by a debut filmmaker, J. P. Thuminad and produced by Raj Shetty, and has surprisingly turned into a huge hit. The film has gone from regional obscurity to almost a national sensation. What struck me most is its vibe; it feels very much like modern Malayalam cinema. Easygoing, not trying to be grand or over-ambitious, but simply a filmmaker telling a story with a camera. And that simplicity is part of its charm. At its heart, Su from So is about small-town lives. How everyone’s closely knit, and how even the tiniest incidents become the biggest entertainment in the predictable rhythm of everyday life. The story is anchored by two characters, Ravi Anna (Shaneel Gautham), a respected, unmarried man in the village, and a younger guy Ashoka (played by J. P. Thuminad, yes the director) who has a crush on a local girl.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Sachin Chatte
Sachin Chatte | The Navhind Times Goa
Hauntingly Funny

Sat, August 2 2025

To put it in plain English, Su From So, the Kannada film playing with English subtitles, is one of the most refreshing films in recent times Amidst the chaos and juvenile humor that characterize most Friday releases, this film, directed by J. P. Thuminad, arrives like a breath of fresh air.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Subha J Rao
Subha J Rao | Independent Film Critic
(Writing for OTT Play)
Much Laughter & Lots To Think About, In This Raj B Shetty Production

Mon, July 28 2025

Director JP Thuminad creates a world that’s deeply immersive, and in a film that’s high on humour, he nudges you to be better

There’s a passing scene in JP Thuminad’s hilarious yet thoughtful Su From So (releasing on July 25), which explains why the film lands the way it does. The villagers need to head somewhere and a convoy departs — it is led by two scooters, followed by two autos and cycles. Even in that not-so-important scene that barely lasts seconds, the film does not veer off its inherent spirit. These vehicles are ‘enough’ to serve the story. This is one of the many reasons why the film, which falls somewhere in the space between a thought-provoking movie and a horror comedy, keeps you engrossed through its runtime that’s a little over two hours.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film Lokah Chapter 1: Chandra
FCG Rating for the film
Lokah Chapter 1: Chandra

Action, Adventure, Fantasy (Malayalam)

The story follows Chandra , a mysterious, goth-influenced woman who has just moved to Bangalore and begins working night shifts at a café. Across the road from her apartment live Sunny and Venu, two aimless bachelors. Sunny becomes infatuated with Chandra, observing her odd routines, strange visitors, and reclusive nature. Their dynamic changes

Cast: Kalyani Priyadarshan, Naslen, Chandu Salimkumar, Arun Kurian, Sandy, Vijayaraghavan, Mammootty, Dulquer Salmaan, Tovino Thomas, Nithya Shri
Director: Dominic Arun


FCG Member Reviewer Manoj Kumar
Manoj Kumar | Independent Film Critic
(Writing for Medium)
Malayalam Cinema Just Made Vampires Desirable, and Modern

Mon, September 15 2025

I’ll be honest — I had developed superhero fatigue. In fact, a general fatigue for anything big-scale and action-driven on the big screen. A movie that fit that bill was not my obvious choice. And looking at how juggernauts like Coolie (starring Superstar Rajinikanth) and War 2 (with Jr NTR and Hrithik Roshan) received underwhelming responses, it seems I’m not alone. So when I first saw the trailer of Lokah: Chapter 1 — Chandra, my reaction was: “Not the movie I want to watch right now.” Look at the films that have actually struck a chord with audiences recently — without over-the-top marketing or manufactured FOMO. From Tourist Family to Dragon, Thudarum to Hridayapoorvam, and even Soup from So — audiences have embraced heartfelt, emotional stories. That goes against the post-COVID “wisdom” that only large-scale spectacles will sell tickets.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Avinash Ramachandran
Avinash Ramachandran | The New Indian Express

Sun, September 7 2025

FCG Member Reviewer S. R. Praveen
S. R. Praveen | The Hindu
(Writing for Medium)
On the cusp of something truly special

Sat, September 6 2025

Folklore carries with it the natural burden of old ways of thinking and the inherent tendency to not stray from what has been handed down over the generations. Often, when filmmakers take inspiration from folklore, knowingly or unknowingly, their approach to the material too is weighed down by the past. In ‘Lokah Chapter 1 : Chandra’, folklore appears to have inspired the people behind the film to think anew, not just in terms of the film, but for the Malayalam film industry as a whole. A particular bit of folklore that almost every other Malayali has grown up with, but has been forgotten in recent years, courses through the veins of Lokah in its original form in a flashback sequence for the ages, which has some of the best use of intercuts. It is also a lesson in using well-timed flashback sequences, delaying that revelation until close to the halfway point, leaving behind some major impact. This revelation will send a chill down the spine for most Malayalis, but it is doubtful whether it will resonate in the same manner outside Kerala.

Continue reading …