← Previous Next →

Guild Reviews

Image of scene from the film Blink
Blink

Documentary (English)

The Pelletier family sets out on an epic journey to see the beauty of the world when three of their four children are diagnosed with an incurable eye condition.

Cast: Edith Lemay, Sébastien Pelletier, Mia Pelletier, Léo Pelletier, Colin Pelletier, Laurent Pelletier, François Lemay, Pauline Sirois
Director: Edmund Stenson, Daniel Roher


Image of scene from the film Madha Gaja Raja
Madha Gaja Raja

Action, Romance, Comedy (Tamil)

Raja, a witty and fearless young man, becomes entangled in a conflict with a corrupt industrialist while trying to protect his family, friends and the woman he loves.

FCG Rating for the film

Cast: Vishal Krishna, Santhanam, Varalaxmi Sarathkumar, Anjali, Sonu Sood, Manobala, Rajendran, Swaminathan, Nithin Sathya, Manivannan
Director: Sundar C
Writer: Sundar C, Venkat Raghavan


FCG Member Reviewer Avinash Ramachandran
Avinash Ramachandran | The New Indian Express
Vishal, Santhanam power this Sundar C throwback to simpler yet sus times

Sun, January 12 2025

The laughs keep on coming, and it is a terrific mix of nostalgia and wistful thinking about the times that were that makes us throw our weights behind this Vishal-Santhanam film, directed by Sundar C

When one looks at films that are over a decade old, it is but natural to see if it has aged well. Are the dialogues still relevant? Is the narrative still fresh? Have the actors and filmmaker evolved? In fact, many a time, it takes us back to the time we first saw it, and our response to it today is a reflection of our own evolution. But what if it is a movie that you never saw, and you are watching it for the first time a decade after it was made. What if it is a movie that no one saw because it didn’t release when it had to, and is finally hitting the screens 12 years later? Do you see it as a 2013 film? Do you see it as a 2025 film? That is the conundrum one finds themselves in while watching Sundar C’s long-delayed Madha Gaja Raja, which was supposed to hit screens for Pongal 2013, but a time traveler moved a chair somewhere in the past, and it saw the light of day for Pongal 2025.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Vishal Menon
Vishal Menon | The Hollywood Reporter India
Sundar C Serves Up An Amusing Cocktail Of Silly And Sleaze

Sun, January 12 2025

Sundar C and Vishal's long-delayed comedy gets you to laugh out loud, even when you’re trying your hardest not to.

Sundar C’s long-delayed Madha Gaja Raja is not the sort of film you enter expecting complex interpersonal relationships or technical finesse. Even if we’d watched the film in 2012 — when it was originally set to release — we may still have found its scenes dated or objectionable. It’s as though we’re forced to remind ourselves that this film is a product of its time, urging us to be kinder because none of us knew any better. Simpler times we no longer have the patience for; like that scene that follows when Raja (Vishal) learns that his friend’s wife has misplaced her gold necklace. Instead of launching an investigation, Raja offers his own gold chain and urges his friends to pool in to make up for the lost necklace. Or the other scene in which Raja deliberately loses a race, just so his rival feels respected in his hometown. Or even the over-the-top nobility with which Raja moves to Chennai to get a corporate honcho to return ₹ 52,20,350 to his broke bestie. It’s all sickeningly sweet, but you’d be shocked at how badly we want to buy into all this.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Janani K
Janani K | India Today
Vishal, Sundar C's film takes you on a nostalgic ride

Sun, January 12 2025

Director Sundar C's Madha Gaja Raja aka MGR, starring Vishal, Sonu Sood and Santhanam, is a comedy caper reminding you of the good old days

Imagine it’s the 2010s. You are back from school, and you switch on the TV, you flip through the channels only to land on one showing comedy clips. You know which movie it is from, the dialogue by heart, and yet it brings laughter every time you watch. Now, imagine watching a typical Sundar C film, which is known for its comedy, 12 years after it was actually made. Madha Gaja Raja follows the story of Raja (Vishal) attending a wedding at his school teacher’s house, where he reunites with his school gang. One of his friends (Santhanam) is going through marriage issues, while the other two are involved in a case that concerns business tycoon Karkuvel Vishwanath (Sonu Sood).

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film Madraskaaran
Madraskaaran

Action, Thriller (Tamil)

A minor argument between two strangers escalates into a life-altering conflict, exploring how a seemingly insignificant event can drastically alter a person's perception and circumstances.

Cast: Shane Nigam, Kalaiyarasan, Niharika Konidela, Aishwarya Dutta, Karunas, Pandiarajan, Super Subbarayan, Geetha Kailasam, Lallu Prasath, Deepa Shankar
Director: Vaali Mohan Das
Writer: Vaali Mohan Das


FCG Member Reviewer Gopinath Rajendran
Gopinath Rajendran | The Hindu
Shane Nigam and Kalaiyarasan headline an outdated action drama

Sun, January 12 2025

Shane Nigam and Kalaiyarasan try their best to save ‘Madraskaaran’, but the film is weighed down by tiresome contrivances

One of the oldest tricks in the cinematic book of twists is introducing car accidents. Tamil cinema’s tryst with it has been a long-standing one. Just a small flip through the memory reminds me of films like Kushi, Kovil, Manmadan Ambu and even recent flicks like Star and Thiruchitrambalam. When it results in impending tragedy for our protagonist or those affiliated with them, most films leave us wishing that fateful day never happened. While the conflict in Shane Nigam’s Tamil debut Madraskaaran also happens to be the same, given the number of times it happens, it’s also the first time one might probably feel that the protagonist should never be allowed to take the wheel and his driving license immediately cancelled.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film All We Imagine as Light
All We Imagine as Light

Drama (Malayalam)

In Mumbai, Nurse Prabha's routine is troubled when she receives an unexpected gift from her estranged husband. Her younger roommate, Anu, tries in vain to find a spot in the city to be intimate with her boyfriend. A trip to a beach town allows them to find a space for their desires to manifest.

FCG Rating for the film

Cast: Kani Kusruti, Divya Prabha, Chhaya Kadam, Hridhu Haroon, Azees Nedumangad, Tintumol Joseph, Anand Sami, Lovleen Mishra, Madhu Raja, Shweta Prajapati
Director: Payal Kapadia
Writer: Payal Kapadia


FCG Member Reviewer Akhil Arora
Akhil Arora | akhilarora.com
All We Imagine As Light: A Spotify Review

Sun, January 12 2025

Ahead of the Oscar nominations, we discuss one of the most acclaimed films of 2024, writer-director Payal Kapadia’s All We Imagine as Light. We talk about the film’s bittersweet exploration of urban loneliness and the migrant experience, its depiction of Mumbai, and Kapadia’s command over tone. We also talk about the bold mid-movie pivot and how it affects the narrative.

FCG Member Reviewer Tatsam Mukherjee
Tatsam Mukherjee | The Wire
As Light' Is a Sentient Ode to – and a Lament for – the Spirit of Mumbai

Sat, November 30 2024

Payal Kapadia’s debut fiction feature follows the lives of three women who navigate the big city.

Payal Kapadia’s All We Imagine As Light (AWIAL) establishes its Mumbai DNA early on. A visibly-tired Anu (Divya Prabha), an upstart nurse in a city hospital, is jotting down details of a patient. Age? “24… oh no sorry, it’s 25,” a young woman says, holding on to her child. “Pfft!” reacts Anu, showcasing her mild annoyance for having to strike out what she’d written earlier.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Ishita Sengupta
Ishita Sengupta | Independent Film Critic
(Writing for OTT Play)
A Moving Ode To Mumbai & Sisterhood

Tue, November 26 2024

Payal Kapadia's All We Imagine as Light is one of those life-altering gems that is transcendental and a moving memoir of mundane, transformative and a crushing reiteration of community sustenance.

Three women, monsoon and a severe city. If Payal Kapadia’s iridescent All We Imagine as Light was a novel, there would be dried flowers stuck between its pages. Since it is a film, the intangible feeling is imbued with visual tactility. It is present in the way Prabha (Kani Kusruti), a middle-aged woman, holds a totem of cold technology within the warmth of her embrace. It is embossed on the face of Parvaty (Chhaya Kadam), a woman in the middle of a crisis, as she listens to a fiery political speech about reclaiming what is hers. And it drips from the text messages a young Anu (Divya Prabha) sends to her lover: “I am sending you kisses through the clouds so that when it rains my kisses touch your lips.” Kapadia’s film is suffused with such ache that if you extend your hand you can touch it.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film Sangeet Manapmaan
Sangeet Manapmaan

(English)

Dhairyadhar, a loyal soldier, and Bhamini, a princess, navigate a love triangle as Bhamini evaluates Dhairyadhar's character while her admirer, Chandravilas, schemes to influence her.



FCG Member Reviewer Keyur Seta
Keyur Seta | Bollywood Hungama
(Writing for The Comman Man Speaks)
Subodh Bhave’s second directorial turns out to be just a one-time watch

Sun, January 12 2025

Actor Subodh Bhave’s directorial debut Katyar Kaljyat Ghusli (2015) turned out to be a spectacular affair. There were much expectations for his second film as a director Sangeet Manapmaan, not just because he is in the director’s chair. This film is also adapted from an old classic musical play, just like the 2015 movie. But this time, the end result turns out to be just a one-time watch. Sangeet Manapmaan is adapted from Krushnaji Prabhakar Khadilkar’s musical play of the same name, which was first staged way back in 1911. The story takes place in a kingdom in Maharashtra called Sangrampur in an unspecified era. The chief of army Kakasaheb (Shailesh Datar) expresses his wish to the queen of Sangrampur (Nivedita Saraf) to retire from his services because of his advanced age. Although the queen believes he is irreplaceable, she suggests Kakasaheb’s deputy Chandravilas (Sumeet Raghvan) as the next chief. Kakasaheb subtly disagrees with the queen as he believes, despite being a brave warrior, Chandravilas doesn’t possess the exact qualities to be the next chief.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film Vanangaan
Vanangaan

Drama, Action (Tamil)

The story is about one who bows down only to love but rises against injustices inflicted on those around him.

FCG Rating for the film

Cast: Arun Vijay, Roshini Prakash, Samuthirakani, Mysskin, Ridha, Chhaya Devi, Bala Sivaji, Shanmugarajan, Yohan Chacko, Kavitha Gopi
Director: Bala
Writer: Bala


FCG Member Reviewer Kirubhakar Purushothaman
Kirubhakar Purushothaman | News 18
Bala Caters To The Very Monster He Wants To Slay

Sat, January 11 2025

Shockingly, Vanangaan, starring Arun Vijay, a revenge drama about a protagonist on a hunt for three perverts, ends up catering to their gaze.

Vanangaan is another addition to Bala’s list of tragedies that make the audience leave the theatre with a heavy heart. Above all, make them wonder: “Why does Bala do it every single time?" Perhaps, he aims to jolt the everyday people and show them the devastating side of life they choose to ignore. That’s why Bala’s protagonists are strangers. They don’t conform to the ways which are termed ‘normal’. Almost all of his protagonists – Pithamagan’s Chithan, Nandha, and Naan Kadavul’s Rudran–are taciturn and choose to interact less with society as their very existence is odd with the society they live in. Set in Kanyakumari, Vanangaan is about one such anomaly named Koti (Arun Vijay), a deaf and dumb ruffian, who is depicted as this beast with a heart.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Janani K
Janani K | India Today
Director Bala's film on sexual violence has contrasting ideologies

Sat, January 11 2025

Director Bala's Vanangaan, starring Arun Vijay, Roshini Prakash and Ridha, is a film where the hero takes justice into his hands. The film is yet another addition to movies insensitively portraying sexual crimes against women.

In the 25 years of his career, director Bala has created quite a niche for himself. His films are far from the ‘ideal’ moral compass or political correctness. Violence or murder is a form of justice in most of his films, while death acts as a liberation for some of his characters. With 10 films to his credit, director Bala is back with Vanangaan, after the disastrous Varmaa, which is a remake of the Telugu superhit film, Arjun Reddy. Vanangaan follows the story of Koti (Arun Vijay) and Devi (Ridha), a brother-sister duo living a content life in Kanniyakumari. While Koti, who is hearing and speech impaired, does odd jobs to put money on the table, Devi works at a tattoo studio. Koti joins as a security guard at an orphanage where many visually impaired people live. An untoward incident happens and Koti gets to know about it. He takes up violence to offer justice.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Vishal Menon
Vishal Menon | The Hollywood Reporter India
Bala Returns With An Insipid Parody Of His Own Movies

Fri, January 10 2025

The Arun Vijay-starrer is so dated and lifeless that we watch with apathy, even when we witness a series of events that must have sounded shocking on paper.

Bala probably forgot that he is Bala. Why else would a director with an obsession for the same pet themes begin a film with a song like ‘Irai Nooru’? The song composed by GV Prakash, isn’t the issue. It’s another one of those mirthful songs about a brother and the unending love he feels for his sister. They have fun, they go to the beach, they go to temples, they go to church, and they are obviously very happy. The year is 2025 and by now, we have a 100-year history of movies telling us that something terrible is going to happen when a film begins with such a lazy, happy montage. And then we must remember that this movie is being made by Bala, a man who has built his brand around tragedies. The remaining runtime of Vanangaan, then, isn’t so much about what’s going to happen and why, as much as it is about how many people are going to die and if we will care when they do.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film Game Changer
Game Changer

Action, Drama (Telugu)

Ram, a newly appointed district collector, takes charge in a city in Andhra Pradesh and immediately confronts the deeply entrenched corruption and inefficiency plaguing the government. Determined to bring reforms, he initiates sweeping changes, sparking a fierce conflict with a powerful state Minister.

FCG Rating for the film

Cast: Ram Charan, Anjali, Kiara Advani, S. J. Suryah, Srikanth, Jayaram, Samuthirakani, Sunil Varma, Naveen Chandra, Rajiv Kanakala
Director: Shankar


FCG Member Reviewer Priyanka Roy
Priyanka Roy | The Telegraph
Ram Charan is in fine form, but Game Changer isn't

Sat, January 11 2025

For a film in which the leading man’s signature line is ‘I am unpredictable’, Game Changer feels as old as cinema itself. In fact, the plot of this film — stretching over an abominably long 165 minutes — is so stale that every second of it will remind you of some terrible movie you may have had the misfortune of sitting through in the past. Game Changer is vintage Shankar, which is more of a bad than a good thing these days. The man who once gave us films like Gentleman and Anniyan, Enthiran and Indian, has been stuck in a creative rut, recently illustrated by the torture fest called Indian 2. Game Changer is a definite improvement over Indian 2 but that isn’t saying much about a film that relies on every overused trope in the masala movie book — physical (over) acting, grating background score, expensively-shot but totally unnecessary songs and a story that goes here, there, everywhere… and ultimately, nowhere.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Sudhir Srinivasan
Sudhir Srinivasan | The New Indian Express
Big ideas, thin characters, little feeling

Sat, January 11 2025

Game Changer begins with the promise of thematic depth and an evolved Shankar protagonist, but a lack of emotional resonance and uneven execution means that this is a missed opportunity

Perhaps it’s the repetition of certain ideas, or perhaps it’s the undeniable power of Shankar’s hit cinema, but it’s impossible not to think of his earlier works—his heyday, shall we dare call it—while watching Game Changer. A road grinding to a halt due to governmental apathy reminds you of Mudhalvan. A government authority dismantling corruption? That’s from the same film. There’s even a self-aware reference to Kadhalan as Ram Charan’s shoes perform a little jig during a song. A love-meter reminds you of Anniyan. When the hero lands out of a helicopter, it’s impossible not to think of Sivaji, especially with Jayaram’s character doing the signature tap on the villain’s shaved head.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Janani K
Janani K | India Today
Ram Charan excels, Shankar settles for mediocrity

Sat, January 11 2025

Director Shankar's Game Changer, starring Ram Charan, Kiara Advani and SJ Suryah, is a handbook on electoral politics. The film looks spectacular, but the story is mediocre at its best.

After the monumental success of SS Rajamouli’s RRR, Game Changer marks Ram Charan’s return to a big solo release. Directed by Shankar, Game Changer is his first solo release and features him in dual roles, guaranteeing double dhamaka for the audience. After the debacle of Indian 2, Shankar is back with Game Changer, which marks his Telugu debut. Is it a ‘Game-Changing Day’ or ‘Game Over’ for Shankar-Ram Charan duo? Let’s find out! Ram Nandan (Ram Charan) is an IAS officer battling anger issues. He is an honest, upright officer who doesn’t bend to corruption. As a high-ranking official, he wants to make Visakhapatnam corruption-free. Meanwhile, Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister Bobbili Satyamurthy (Srikanth), who so far has corrupted the government, undergoes a transformation and instructs his sons, Mopidevi (SJ Suryah) and Maavera Munimanikam (Jayaram), and his ministers to stop favouring anyone and run a corruption-free government for the next year while they remain in power.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film Viduthalai Part 2
Viduthalai Part 2

Action, Thriller, Drama (Tamil)

Troubles worsen for Kumaresan after the capture of Perumal, and soon he is confronted with having to make a choice between performing his duties as a police constable, or taking a stand for what is right.

Cast: Vijay Sethupathi, Soori, Manju Warrier, Chetan, Tamizh, Rajiv Menon, Gautham Vasudev Menon, Kishore, Sundareswaran CVC, Ilavarasu
Director: Vetrimaaran


FCG Member Reviewer Sudhir Srinivasan
Sudhir Srinivasan | The New Indian Express
When words overpower feeling

Sat, January 11 2025

A film rich in ideas and craft, though its emotional resonance doesn’t always match its ambition

In Viduthalai Part 2, a film that leans more on thought than emotion, more on words than feelings, my favourite portion is a brief, tender exchange between Perumal (Vijay Sethupathi) and Mahalakshmi (Manju Warrier). They are united by their disillusionment with life and society. Mahalakshmi has almost adopted the appearance of a man (and we later learn why), while Perumal, when tentatively reaching out to her about the prospect of a relationship, stammers and stutters, unsure of himself. Vetrimaaran beautifully allows Mahalakshmi time to respond to Perumal’s proposal, time to think, time in which to give us a beautiful Ilaiyaraaja song. And when you hear his melody, love, expectedly, blooms.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Kirubhakar Purushothaman
Kirubhakar Purushothaman | News 18
Vetrimaaran Delivers A Noble But Generic Political Drama

Mon, December 30 2024

Viduthalai 2 suffers from something as basic as exposition. Characters keep telling you what’s happening with the story.

Vetri Maaran’s Viduthalai Part 1, told from the perspective of a new police constable Kumaresan (Soori), posted in a rural hillside Tamil Nadu village, explored the story of an extremist organisation named Makkal Padai and its head Perumal Vaathiyar (Vijay Sethupathi). Makkal Padai has a history, but when we entered the world in the first part, the conflict was immediate as the terrorist organisation had just bombed a passenger train killing and injuring several lives. The premise answered both ‘why and why now’ of the film’s existence. It ended with the arrest of Vaathiyar, aided by Kumaresan, who is on the brink of getting disillusioned with the government’s propaganda against the organisation. The effective first part left us with many questions about Vaathiyar and how it will affect Kumaresan.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Vishal Menon
Vishal Menon | The Hollywood Reporter India
Vetrimaaran's Preachy Yet Compelling Character Study About A Terrorist Who Becomes A Hero

Wed, December 25 2024

This sequel is a powerful portrait showcasing how one man’s terrorist is another man’s freedom fighter.

In the first part of Viduthalai, you’d remember the long trek Kumaresan (Soori) undertakes to reach the camp where he is posted as a police constable for the first time. Even for a story that takes more than five hours to unfold, you’d remember the slow pace with which he treks across terrains, water bodies and hills to finally get to the top. Until today, I felt the pacing was intentional because we needed to understand how remote and challenging it was going to be for Kumaresan to work there. Narratively too, it was important for us to register the hostile terrain everyone in this movie was fighting over, right from the locals to the police and the mining corporation that wants to set up shop there.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film Identity
Identity

Action, Thriller, Mystery (Malayalam)

A sketch artist and a cop work together to unravel the identity of an elusive killer using the descriptions of his face, etched into the memory of an eye-witness to the brutal crime

Cast: Tovino Thomas, Trisha Krishnan, Vinay Rai, Mandira Bedi, Shammi Thilakan, Aju Varghese, Druvan, Arjun Radhakrishnan, Archana Kavi, Gopika Ramesh
Director: Anas Khan, Akhil Paul
Writer: Akhil Paul, Anas Khan


FCG Member Reviewer Vishal Menon
Vishal Menon | The Hollywood Reporter India
Tovino Thomas And Trisha's Overstuffed Thriller Has Identity Issues

Fri, January 10 2025

In its excitement for having landed on a series of excellent concepts — and all the research that went in — we end up with a confused film that shares the same identity issues with its protagonists.

There is a 10-minute-long sequence in Identity, in which an important character explains a medical condition called prosopagnosia—a rare cognitive disorder where damage to a particular part of the brain affects the patient’s ability to identify faces. The scene itself is loaded with exposition, almost like a TED Talk, but it is effective in explaining the condition of the film’s most important character. As a detail, it sounds just about right to make the character appear mysterious, vague and, of course, human. But on a screenplay level, it forms a solid base to explore the unreliable narrator trope—where the only person whose observations matter, is the one who cannot be relied on at all.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Kirubhakar Purushothaman
Kirubhakar Purushothaman | News 18
Trisha And Tovino Thomas' Thriller Is Engaging But Wants To Be Many Things At Once

Fri, January 10 2025

Director-writer duo Akhil Paul and Anas Khan pack a lot into Identity. While individually, each idea is left unexplored, the film overall is a gripping watch.

Identity sets off as a film about Haran Shankar (Tovino Thomas), a boy with an abusive father, who turns him into a perfectionist with obsessive-compulsive disorder. As we expect the film to be about this eccentric personality solving cases, we are thrown into a story of a serial rapist, who blackmails his victims with videos of the crimes. When we think it is going to be about nabbing this criminal, he gets killed by an unknown person (we instantly know who it is). Alisha (Trisha), the witness of the crime, gets a peculiar disease called Prosopagnosia aka face blindness, due to an accident right after witnessing the murder, which renders her incapable of recognising faces. Now, we settle for a concept film about this person with face blindness trying to identify the killer with the help of Haran, who also happens to be a good sketch artist (thanks to his mom). But no. Identity is neither that. It keeps turning into a different film every 20 minutes. You have a gripping flight sequence where Haran tries to stop a collision. Later, we also get an enjoyable Bondish fight sequence in a private jet. Clearly, Identity has an identity crisis.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer S. R. Praveen
S. R. Praveen | The Hindu
Tovino Thomas-Trisha Krishnan investigative thriller gets lost in a convoluted plotline

Thu, January 2 2025

At its core, there is a fairly interesting and mostly uncomplicated storyline holding the film up until the interval point. After that, one can witness the screenwriter succumbing the pressure to keep the audience guessing

If someone were to narrate the story of Identity, directed by Akhil Paul and Anas Khan, chances are that halfway through, the person will get lost in a maze of complicated side stories. It need not have been that way, for at its core, there is a fairly interesting and mostly uncomplicated storyline which holds up the film until the interval point. After that, one can witness the screenwriter being acted upon by the pressure to keep the audience guessing. For, by the halfway point, we almost get an idea of all the principal players and there is little left to uncover. It is at this point that the tedious work of the writer begins, building up elaborate plotlines for the villain’s true intentions and the hero’s real identity (which reminds one of such surprise reveals in quite a few other movies). Several of these plotlines are convoluted. It would require immense amounts of patience to untangle all the motives of the multiple villains in the narrative.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film Miss You
Miss You

Romance, Comedy (Tamil)

What happens when a guy falls in love with the girl he thought he hated the most? Why does her simple `no` mean so much more than it seems?.

FCG Rating for the film

Cast: Siddharth, Ashika Ranganath, Karunakaran, Balasaravanan, Sastika Rajendran, Lollu Sabha Maaran, Ponvannan, Sharath Lohitashwa, Jayaprakash, Nakkalites Arun Kumar
Director: N. Rajasekhar


FCG Member Reviewer Kirubhakar Purushothaman
Kirubhakar Purushothaman | News 18
Siddharth’s Old-School Rom-Com Is Nearly Decent

Fri, January 10 2025

Miss You seems real despite its commercial cinematic absurdities like bar songs and street fights

It’s been a minute since a rom-com like Miss You was made in Tamil. It is not to say the film is rare or great, but it is just one of those old-school rom-coms that harps just on a straightforward story and drama. A kind that hasn’t been around for a while now. Directed by N Rajasekar, starring Siddharth and Ashika Ranganath in the lead roles, Miss You reminds you of the times when not every single release had to be unique or bearing a USP or having the need to cater to the whole nation. It has low stakes, featuring normal people, cliched songs, and fights that evoke a sense of nostalgia. The strong point of Miss You is that is aware of its limitations and contrivances. At one instance, when a character is forced to narrate the past, he lets out a disclaimer that the ‘flashback’ is going to feature a story within the story. That doesn’t absolve the film of its mistakes, but it is nice to know now and then that the filmmakers aren’t in a bubble.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Srivathsan Nadadhur
Srivathsan Nadadhur | Independent Film Critic
(Writing for All in a Frame)

Tue, December 17 2024

In times when films have become social/ideological statements, it’s refreshing how Miss You still wants to be a simple story about ordinary people, everyday situations. The plot, centred on memory loss, fragility of modern-day marriages and second chances, banks on its slice-of-life treatment to see itself through. Yet, its simplicity paves the way for mediocrity due to the jaded treatment, time-tested storytelling tropes and poor music. There are flashes of Siddharth’s good-ol charm and decent performances by Ashika Ranganath and Karunakaran for intermittent relief. Miss You has its moments but is too casual and lacks conviction to be a memorable romance drama.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Sudhir Srinivasan
Sudhir Srinivasan | The New Indian Express
Much potential without payoff

Tue, December 17 2024

In this film about memory loss, the real loss is the inability of the film to treat its premise with the love it deserves

You know, it sometimes feels like films don’t quite appreciate the promise of their premise as much as we do. Miss You, for instance, teases a fascinating idea: a man forgets a significant period of his life after an accident—how does this affect his love life? It’s not exactly a groundbreaking premise; memory loss is a well-worn trope. But within this framework lie rich possibilities: repercussions on relationship dynamics, explorations of vulnerability, and the bittersweet beauty of rediscovery. We see this potential, but the frustration is in the film’s failure to do so.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film Soodhu Kavvum 2
Soodhu Kavvum 2

Comedy, Crime, Thriller (Tamil)

A gang of kidnappers find they have bitten off more than they can chew.

Cast: Shiva, Karunakaran, Aruldoss, Ramesh Thilak, Yog Jappie, Harisha Jestin, M. S. Bhaskar, Radha Ravi
Director: S. J. Arjun
Writer: S. J. Arjun


FCG Member Reviewer Kirubhakar Purushothaman
Kirubhakar Purushothaman | News 18
A Dishonour To Vijay Sethupathi’s Phenomenal Dark Comedy

Fri, January 10 2025

Soodhu Kavvum 2 pales in comparison to its predecessor, failing to capture the dark humor and cynical brilliance of Nalan Kumarasamy's original.

Watching Soodhu Kavvum 2 makes one realise the genius of the first part and its director Nalan Kumarasamy. More than the delicious dark houmour and wacky texture, the life of Soodhu Kavvum (2013) lies in its sarcastic pessimism. Nalan doled out a cynical comedy about a corrupt society beyond reckoning. Yet, his dark comedy made everyone overlook the philosophical core of his world. The title of the film Soodhu Kavvum (Evil Engulfs) is part of the Hindu god Krishna’s sermon in Bhagavad Gita, which goes: Dharmathin Vaazhvuthanai Soodhu Kavvum, Aanaal Dharmam Irudhiyil Vellum (Evil will engulf the dharma, but the good will always triumph in the end)." Though director Nalan’s film just takes part of it, ‘Soodhu Kavvum’ is a complete statement in the context of the movie. Evil engulfs. Period. The truth doesn’t triumph here, but that doesn’t seem to be a bad thing as it looks at life with a sense of sardonic humour that is soothing and pleasurable.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film On Call
On Call

Animation (English)

A bear hunter tells Porky the tale of a hunt 30 years ago: a bear got a taste of his chewing tobacco and chased him down to get it; the hunter took the bear on with his bare hands rather than lose the tobacco. Or at least, that's the way he told the story.

Cast: Mel Blanc, Robert C. Bruce
Director: Robert Clampett


FCG Member Reviewer Sonal Pandya
Sonal Pandya | Times Now, Zoom
Dick Wolf's Streaming Police Drama Starts Strong But Fights To Maintain Pace

Thu, January 9 2025

Created by Tim Walsh and Elliot Wolf, the new police thriller follows a rookie cop on the beat at the Long Beach Police Department.

After Law & Order, NCIS, and Chicago TV universes, veteran producer Dick Wolf makes his first streaming show with On Call. The new series is situated in Long Beach, California, where a seasoned police officer trains a newbie after one of her former trainees is murdered on the job. Starring Troian Bellisario and Brandon Larracuente in the leads, Amazon Prime Video’s On Call flies right out of the gate but circles around the same few issues over and over again. Troian Bellisario is by-the-books officer Traci Harmon, who never fired a weapon in 12 years. Meanwhile, Alex Diaz is an overeager rookie who wants to do it again. Following the death of officer Delgado (Monica Raymund) for a routine traffic stop, the Long Beach police force is on the hunt for a cop killer. However, it is Harmon who takes the search to heart while maintaining the on-the-job lessons for the new guy on the beat.

Continue reading …