





Guild Reviews

Kumaara Sambavam
Drama, Comedy (Tamil)
Cast:
Kumaran Thangarajan, Paayal Radhakrishna, Balasaravanan, Elango Kumaravel, G. M. Kumar, Vinodh Munna, Shiva Aravind, Livingston, Vinod Sagar, Gowtham Sundararajan
Director:
Balaji Venugopal
Writer:
Balaji Venugopal

Fri, September 12 2025


Humans in the Loop
Drama (Hindi)
A single mother from the Oraon tribe balances training AI systems and reconnecting with her roots, while her pre-teen son struggles to accept their new life away from the city.
Cast:
Sonal Madhushankar, Ridhima Singh, Geeta Guha, Anurag Lugun
Director:
Aranya Sahay
Writer:
Aranya Sahay

Nature’s edge in an AI world
Fri, September 12 2025
How does artificial intelligence interact with a developing economy, particularly at its lowest rung? Humans in the Loop hits like the casual threats you hear in corporate offices: “Everyone’s replaceable. This is the AI era,” echoing memories from when computers began replacing paper and people. The immediate question then, as I recall, was: “Who will operate them?” Okay, let’s face it. There is no running away from technology. It will only get sharper and smarter, but will human beings grow more intelligent alongside it? In Aranya Sahay’s quiet yet powerful feature, we meet a sharp woman whose natural intellect is tested as she struggles to earn a livelihood. Set in India’s rural Jharkhand, the film opens with Nehma (Sonal Madhushankar), who belongs to the Oraon tribe, failing a CAPTCHA test in a village recruitment drive. She fidgets her fingers, applying human logic as she identifies traffic lights, taxis, and zebra crossings. It is important to mention her caste identity in light of her marital status (or its legitimacy at all). Nehna’s ex-husband, Ritesh (Vikas Gupta), seeks custody of their children, one of them a toddler. A regular job is the only way Nehma would stand a chance against the upper-caste man who lives in the state capital, Ranchi.

The Depiction of the Contradictions in Modern Society is Nothing Short of Marvellous
Sat, September 6 2025
I’ve always likened the opening stretch of a film to a train about to leave the station. The best films give the impression that the train has been running long before we boarded, and one that will continue after we get off. It’s during these opening moments that, as viewers, we decide if we want to get on the train and go on a journey the director has planned for us. In Aranya Sahay’s Humans in the Loop, this opening stretch features a woman waiting to take a test at a data labelling centre, in rural Jharkhand. Haunted by visions of a childhood spent with a porcupine in her ancestral village, one she’s forced to unceremoniously return to after her divorce begins, Nehma (Sonal Madhushankar) fails the test for a job at the centre. She has an infant tied to her back, as her friend pleads her case in front of a superior. “She belongs to the local tribe, and is undergoing her divorce. She really needs it,” the friend advocates in front of the manager (Gita Guha). “She’s a graduate and fairly acquainted with computers.”

A Profound Take on Artificial Intelligence and Natural Order
Wed, March 12 2025
A great concept can be a curse. Take the one-liner of Humans in the Loop, for instance. An Adivasi single mother named Nehma (Sonal Madhushankar) starts working as a ‘data labeller,’ a job that requires her to train AI models to recognise the world in pictures and videos. This one-liner alone is so fertile — so ripe with cultural parables and documentary minimalism — that it’s hard to imagine a fictional film that expands on it. What can a feature-length story express that isn’t already implicit?


Inspector Zende
Comedy, Drama (Hindi)
When serial killer Carl Bhojraj escapes prison and resurfaces in Mumbai, the determined Inspector Zende steps up to nab the cunning fugitive once more.
Cast:
Manoj Bajpayee, Jim Sarbh, Bhalchandra Kadam, Sachin Khedekar, Girija Oak, Harish Dudhade, Vaibhav Mangle, Onkar Raut, Bharat Savale, Devaang Bagga
Director:
Chinmay Mandlekar

The Long Take: A Spotify Review
Thu, September 11 2025
Inspector Zende, the new spoof movie starring Manoj Bajpayee and Jim Sarbh, succeeds as a concept but fails in execution. What could’ve been a homegrown homage to The Naked Gun comes across as a first draft in need of clever rewrites. While Bajpayee is going full ham in the central role, matching the movie’s energy, Sarbh seems to have been told to tone it down. The result is a tonally uneven ride that could’ve been worse, but also better.

A Breezy, Playful Retelling of the Pursuit of the Criminal Charles Sobhraj
Tue, September 9 2025
A markedly distinct genre of Mumbai films have emerged in the Hindi mainstream (Kaun Pravin Tambe?, Lootcase, Madgaon Express) in the last decade. The director is Mumbai-bred for the most part, the dialogues flits from Hindi, Marathi and the in-between language laced with Mumbai slang. The underdog protagonist usually lives in a cramped central Mumbai chawl, and the films tend to have the wry humour and the wisdom of the city’s many pot-holed streets. Chinmay Mandlekar’s Inspector Zende fits into this slew of breezy, playful and intentionally cartoonish films — which are modest in their ambitions, enjoyable in the moment and rarely able to sustain the joys of their first hour. Madhukar Zende (Manoj Bajpayee) is a cog in the Mumbai police machinery, battling the underworld. Like any good fielder in the 30-yard circle, Zende can anticipate his moment to shine. Whether it’s out of a sense of duty or his ‘supercop’ ego is up for debate. A thing I liked about Mandlekar’s film is how it accounts for someone’s ability to exaggerate while regaling anecdotes. It’s amused by the self-mythologising, while also being affectionate towards its subject. It results in a film that is consistently amusing, even if it doesn’t break any new ground.

झंडू फिल्म बना दी ‘इंस्पैक्टर झेंडे’
Sun, September 7 2025
70 के दशक में ‘बिकनी किलर’ के नाम से मशहूर हुए और दिल्ली की तिहाड़ जेल से कैदियों व स्टाफ को नशीला खाना खिला कर फरार हुए कुख्यात अपराधी चार्ल्स शोभराज पर दुनिया भर में किताबें लिखी गईं और उसकी कहानी को सिनेमा में भी उतारा गया। तो नेटफ्लिक्स पर आई इस फिल्म में नया क्या हो सकता है? जवाब है-यह फिल्म चार्ल्स की बजाय मुंबई पुलिस के उन इंस्पैक्टर मधुकर झेंडे के बारे में है जिन्होंने चार्ल्स को पहले 1971 में पकड़ा था और फिर 1986 में उसके तिहाड़ से भागने के बाद गोआ से। चूंकि चार्ल्स ने अपनी कहानी के अधिकार यहां-वहां बेचे हुए हैं इसलिए इस फिल्म में सिर्फ इंस्पैक्टर झेंडे का नाम असली है और बाकी सब के नाम, काम बदल दिए गए हैं। मसलन चार्ल्स शोभराज यहां कार्ल भोजराज है, ‘बिकनी किलर’ की बजाय ‘स्विमसूट किलर’ है, नशीले खाने की बजाय नशीली खीर है, वगैरह-वगैरह…! लेकिन इससे क्या फर्क पड़ता है, कहानी मज़ेदार होनी चाहिए, काल्पनिक हो या वास्तविक। और बस, यहीं आकर यह फिल्म मात खा गई है क्योंकि इसे ‘मज़ेदार’ बनाने के लिए जो रंग-ढंग चुने गए हैं उससे यह हल्की, कमज़ोर और उथली हुई है।


Baaghi 4
Action, Thriller (Hindi)
After waking up from a coma, a grieving man sets out to uncover the truth about his missing girlfriend.
Cast:
Tiger Shroff, Sanjay Dutt, Sonam Bajwa, Harnaaz Kaur Sandhu, Jimmy Shergill, Shabbir Ahluwalia, Sunny Hinduja, Raj Zutshi, Sai Ketan Rao, Mahesh Thakur
Director:
A. Harsha

The Pain is Real
Wed, September 10 2025

Tiger Shroff disappoints in this corny actioner
Sun, September 7 2025
During the pan-Indian wave, one thing that has reached Bollywood shores from the South is the toolkit of the Iron Age. Armed with cleavers, these days our heroes are slashing and slashing hard. It is not always when the stakes or tempers run high. It is just for the hack of it. Bored of firing gunshots from a distance, now they wield an axe and a hammer to grind the opposition to pulp. With an adult certificate becoming a sign of misplaced maturity, the makers can play with as much blood as they want. There is nothing like excess anymore. If Ranbir Kapoor can do it, how can Tiger Shroff be far behind? In this fourth installment of the action franchise, Ronny (Tiger) is madly in love with a girl named Alisha (debutante Harnaaz Sandhu), who the world feels doesn’t exist.

I think it’s time to draw the curtains
Sat, September 6 2025

Only Murders in the Building S05
Comedy, Mystery, Crime (English)
Three strangers share an obsession with true crime and suddenly find themselves wrapped up in one.
Cast:
Steve Martin, Martin Short, Selena Gomez

Steve, Martin, Selena Starrer Brings Back Magic In New Mystery
Tue, September 9 2025
How many murders can you have in a building? Turns out one every season, and we hope the corpses continue to fall because the fifth season of Hulu’s Only Murders in the Building is warm, funny, and oddly delightful. Several new characters are added this season, but it doesn’t take away from the core protagonists as they investigate the murder of one of their own. Steve Martin, Martin Short, and Selena Gomez are once again the highlight, while Meryl Streep is the best addition to the stellar show. Season 5 of the series looks at a New York institution, the doormen of the Big Apple who keep the buildings running. Viewers knew from last season that the Arconia’s beloved doorman, Lester (Teddy Coluca), was found dead in the courtyard fountain. Charles (Steve Martin), Oliver (Martin Short), and Mabel (Selena Gomez) decide to investigate the mysterious circumstances, which takes them down memory lane into the history of the Arconia itself with interactions with mobsters and billionaires that provide more clues.

Its The Beginning Of The End, But Still Good
Mon, September 8 2025
Only Murders In The Building season 5 returns to the hallways of the Arconia after touring to LA in the previous season. This time, our podcast hosts stay in the building and in and around New York as far as the iconic Godfather would take them. The new season doubles down on what works best for them and brings back some iconic characters while introducing another set of crazy characters New York has to offer. The show is obviously coming to an end, but it still maintains its niche writing, and that’s the biggest win for Only Murders In The Building. The show begins at the end of the previous season when the now beloved doormen Lester is found dead in the pool of his own blood in the building’s fountain. Charles, Oliver and Mabel don’t take much time to start looking for clues around the building and among their neighbours before the body is cold and under. However, it isn’t enough, especially when the police reports claim it was an accident. As every season of the show unfolds, the latest instalment also follows the trio as they track a list of trails left behind by the killer, which may or may not lead them to the end.

Demon Slayer: Infinity Castle
Animation, Action, Fantasy, Thriller (Japanese)
The Demon Slayer Corps are drawn into the Infinity Castle, where Tanjiro, Nezuko, and the Hashira face terrifying Upper Rank demons in a desperate fight as the final battle against Muzan Kibutsuji begins.
Cast:
Natsuki Hanae, Akari Kito, Yoshitsugu Matsuoka, Hiro Shimono, Toshihiko Seki, Reina Ueda, Nobuhiko Okamoto, Takahiro Sakurai, Katsuyuki Konishi, Kengo Kawanishi
Director:
Haruo Sotozaki

Heavy And Heartbreaking With Endless Battles
Mon, September 8 2025
Demon Slayer Infinity Castle has finally hit the big screen in India, and though the tickets have caused quite the ruckus among fans, the 155 minutes are worth the long wait. The film kicks off right at the end of the last season, with almost the entire Demon Slayer corps being pulled into the Infinity Castle after Muzan is attacked by the Hashiras at Kagaya Ubuyashiki’s house. Infinity Castle is filled with fan service as each character is touched upon, while also diving deeper into the story for a few of the characters in the same format that the show goes through. All Demon Slayer films, or other franchise anime films, have focused on providing a recap of the final battle and then diving into the new season. However, with the new films for the Infinity Castle arc the makers are taking a filmmaking approach. For the first time, we do get a recap, but through a new perspective to avoid any kind of repetition. Instead of watching the final moments of Muzan’s fight or Kagaya Ubuyashiki’s interaction with Muzan, we get the preparation he put into the trap through Hashira Gyomei Himejima’s perspective.

Songs of Forgotten Trees
Drama (Hindi)
Migrant and aspiring actress Thooya navigates Mumbai by leveraging beauty and wit, occasionally trading intimacy for opportunity. When she sublets her sugar daddy’s upscale apartment to Swetha, a fellow migrant working a corporate job, the two women from seemingly different worlds begin sharing more than just living space. Amid Mumbai’s relentless pulse, they discover silent empathy, though personal histories and wounds test their delicate connection in a strange and tender unfolding – of selfhood, of survival, of unexpected kinship.
Cast:
Naaz Shaikh, Sumi Baghel, Bhusan Shimpi, Ravi S Mann, Pritam Pilania, Lovely Singh
Director:
Anuparna Roy
Writer:
Anuparna Roy

Anuparna Roy’s Debut Finds Tenderness Amid Hardship
Sun, September 7 2025
Songs of Forgotten Trees is a clear-eyed, restrained, moving story of two young women, lonely and bruised, finding solace in each other. Thooya and Swetha are migrants in Mumbai. Thooya, played by Naaz Shaikh, is an aspiring actress and part-time sex worker — it helps to pay the bills. Swetha, played by Sumi Baghel, is a call center employee, hoping to find a soulmate in the matrimonial market. Both are navigating an indifferent, manic city. Swetha, a new arrival, is still a little starry-eyed. She really wants to see the ‘samudra’ but Thooya tells her with the amused awareness of an old timer – itna bhi khubsoorat nahi hai. The film, presented by Anurag Kashyap, is the debut feature of Anuparna Roy and the only Indian film selected for the prestigious Orizzonti section of the 82nd Venice Film Festival (Karan Tejpal’s Stolen and Chaitanya Tamhane’s Court also premiered here). The scenario might remind you of Payal Kapadia’s All We Imagine as Light, also about the bond between two migrant women in Mumbai. But Anuparna’s vision is far less lyrical. With stillness, long takes and an understated tone, she creates an anguished portrait of what it takes for women to survive. The heart of this film is a scene in which the two women are in two bathrooms next to each other — one is washing clothes in the bathing space, and the other is using the commode as a chair. What starts out as buoyant banter shifts seamlessly into grief and tears. The scene is beautifully staged and performed.

Kammattam
Crime (Malayalam)
Inspector Antonio George smells foul play in the mysterious death of Samuel Umman. As his investigation leads him to Samuel's employee, Francis, Antonio realises that a much larger game is in play.
Cast:
Sudev Nair, Jins Baskar, Arun Sol, Ajai Vasudev, Jeo Baby, Akhil R C Kavalayoor, Jordi Poonjar, Sree Rekha, Rakesh Murali, Viviya Santh
Director:
Shan Thulaseedharan
Writer:
Sanjith RS, Sudheesh Sugunanandhan, Jose Thomas Polackal

(Writing for M9 News)
Pacy Thriller Leads Nowhere
Sun, September 7 2025
Samuel Umman, a businessman involved in real estate, is killed in a road accident. Antonio George, entrusted with the case, smells something fishy. An investigation into Samuel’s life leads him to a confidante, Francis. He unearths an alleged loan scam in connection with a local cooperative bank. A thug Shaji, Samuel’s own son Ebin, and a few bank employees are also under the scanner. It’s Sudev Nair and Arun Sol, who enjoy bulk of the screen-time in the show. Sudev’s past appearances in both positive/negative roles work in favour of his casting, though Arun gets better scope to deliver a portrayal with space for histrionic talents. Akhil Kavalayoor, Ajay Vasudev, and Kalfan have one-note roles, and they deliver okayish performances. The women hardly have any prominence and get to make much impact.

Solid Source Material, Mid Storytelling
Sat, September 6 2025
In Shan Thulasidharan’s frantically paced Kammattam (Coinage), not a minute is wasted to push us into the world of crime. A man named Samuel (Jeo Baby) has been struck down by a moving car, and it’s clear, right from the word go, that this “accident” was very much intentional. A police officer named Antonio (Sudev Nair) is deputed to investigate. Within the first 10 minutes, the crime, the world around and the people involved have all been established with reasonable efficiency. Samuel is said to have had a chequered past, and this makes him susceptible to almost everyone around him, including close family. The red herrings are laid out with similar swiftness, and by the end of the first episode, we’re left with a handful of suspects, each with enough reason to have committed the crime(s).

Little Hearts
Comedy, Romance, Drama (Telugu)
Akhil, when failed in EAMCET exam, is forced into long-term coaching after heartbreak teaches him the difference between true and shallow love. At the center, he meets Khatyayani and falls for her, only to be rejected for a strange reason. Determined not to lose her, his humorous and transformative journey to win her heart becomes the soul of the story.
Cast:
Mouli, Shivani Nagaram, Rajiv Kanakala, S.S. Kanchi, Anitha Chowdary, Satya Krishnan
Director:
Sai Marthand
Writer:
Sai Marthand

(Writing for The Hindu)
This young romance is a relentless laughathon
Sun, September 7 2025
Cinema, a melange of art and commerce, is no exception to the rule of demand and supply. As fascination with hyper-masculine angry men, larger-than-life missions, and the love for grey shades is on the wane, there emerges a need for cinema that is more relatable and inhabited by characters who don’t hesitate to poke fun at their own flaws and vulnerabilities. A few Telugu films this year — Sankranthiki Vasthunnam, Mad Square, Single, Subham, Sarangapani Jathakam — highlight this gradual shift, which is reiterated by this week’s release, Little Hearts, directed by Sai Marthand. It exemplifies an often-quoted perception among cinephiles on social media — a film aware of its own silliness is indeed intelligent. Little Hearts is a love story about two misfits (as deemed by their families). Unable to clear his engineering entrances, Akhil (Mouli Tanuj) is compelled to undertake long-term coaching due to his father’s (Rajeev Kanakala) insistence. Khatyayini (Shivani Nagaram), daughter of a medico, is no different — except she is attempting MBBS for the fourth time. The scenario is ripe for love to blossom.


The Bengal Files
Drama, History, Thriller (Hindi)
A criminal investigator uncovers a web of corruption during a missing person investigation, while a figure connected to the case reflects on the communal violence which broke out ahead of India's partition.
Cast:
Darshan Kumaar, Anupam Kher, Saswata Chatterjee, Pallavi Joshi, Saurav Das, Mithun Chakraborty, Dibyendu Bhattacharya, Eklavya Sood, Simrat Kaur, Namashi Chakraborty
Director:
Vivek Agnihotri
Writer:
Vivek Agnihotri, Saurabh M. Pandey

When history meets histrionics
Sun, September 7 2025
The Bengal Files directed by Vivek Agnihotri continues his polarising Files Trilogy after The Tashkent Files and The Kashmir Files. With a cast featuring Darshan Kumar, Saswata Chatterjee, Pallavi Joshi, Mithun Chakravarthy, and Anupam Kher, this 205-minute political drama revisits the 1946 Great Calcutta Killings and the Noakhali riots. Framed as historical revelation, the film blends propaganda, performative outrage, and distorted memory into a cinematic spectacle. Positioned conveniently before the 2026 Bengal elections, The Bengal Files raises questions about political cinema in India, propaganda-driven storytelling, and the weaponization of Partition-era trauma. Political cinema in India has long mastered the art of selective amnesia—where history is less a chronicle of facts and more a buffet of “patriotic” fiction, seasoned heavily with rage bait. Most of these films claim to “speak truth to power” while actually whispering sweet nothings into the ears of a very specific, very angry demographic. The result? Predictably controversial, conveniently banned (wink wink), and almost always marketed as “the film THEY didn’t want you to see.”

मत देखिए ‘द बंगाल फाइल्स’
Sat, September 6 2025
‘प्रहार’ में मेजर चव्हाण बने नाना पाटेकर कोर्ट से पूछते हैं-‘देश का मतलब क्या है? सड़कें, इमारतें, खेत-खलिहान, नदियां, पहाड़, बस इतना ही? और लोग, लोग कहां हैं?’ सच तो यह है कि देश की बात करते समय हुकूमतों ने कभी लोगों के बारे में सोचा ही नहीं। विवेक रंजन अग्निहोत्री की यह फिल्म ‘द बंगाल फाइल्स’ उन्हीं लोगों, हम लोगों, ‘वी द पीपल ऑफ भारत’ की बात कहने आई है, सुनाने आई है। पर क्या सचमुच कोई ‘वी द पीपल’ की बात सुनना भी चाहता है? समझना चाहता है? आज के पश्चिम बंगाल के मुर्शिदाबाद में एक दलित लड़की के गायब होने के मामले की तफ्तीश करने के लिए दिल्ली से सी.बी.आई. अफसर शिवा पंडित को भेजा जाता है। शक स्थानीय विधायक सरदार हुसैनी पर है। शिवा पर वहां हमला होता है क्योंकि उस इलाके में पुलिस की नहीं सरदार हुसैनी की चलती है। वही सरदार हुसैनी जो सीमा पार से अवैध लोगों को वहां लाकर बसा रहा है, उन्हें यहां का नागरिक बना कर उस इलाके की डेमोग्राफी बदल रहा है, हर चीज़ को हिन्दू-मुसलमान बना रहा है ताकि उसकी हुकूमत चलती रहे। तफ्तीश के दौरान शिवा को भारती बैनर्जी मिलती है जिसने आज़ादी की लड़ाई लड़ी थी, अगस्त 1946 का बंगाल का वह ‘डायरेक्ट एक्शन डे’ देखा था जिसमें हज़ारों लोग मारे गए थे, नोआखाली के दंगे देखे थे और जो आज भी बात-बात पर बीते दिनों की उन भयानक यादों में खो जाती है। शिवा पंडित पाता है कि हालात आज भी कमोबेश वैसे ही हैं। हुकूमत में बैठे लोग आज भी अपने स्वार्थ के लिए ‘वी द पीपल’ को इस्तेमाल ही कर रहे हैं।

Vivek Agnihotri injects a booster dose of communal poison
Sat, September 6 2025
During the pandemic, a booster dose of the vaccine became a common term. It was intended to boost the immune system’s response to the virus. This week, Vivek Agnihotri injects a booster dose of cinematic virus that he unleashed with The Kashmir Files lest people develop immunity against communal politics. Once again, blending a discriminating version of the past with a myopic vision of the present, The Bengal Files not only scratches the wounds of the Partition but also punctures them to manipulate emotions. Soaked in blood and hate against one community and religion, the film uses cinema as a tool to divide. Juxtaposing the present State of affairs in West Bengal with the Calcutta riots of August 1946 in the wake of the Muslim League’s call for Direct Action Day, followed by the Noakhali riots, the film says that Partition is an unfinished business, instigating majoritarian fear about demographic change and illegal migration.

Uff Yeh Siyapaa
Comedy, Action (Hindi)
Kesari Lal Singh’s wife leaves him, believing he was flirting with the neighbor—he wasn’t. To make matters worse, a drug parcel is mistakenly delivered to his home, leading to chaos when a dead body turns up. As he tries to dispose of it, another body arrives, plunging him deeper into mayhem.
Cast:
Sohum Shah, Nushrratt Bharuccha, Nora Fatehi, Guru Shivam, Omkar Kapoor, Sharib Hashmi
Director:
Ashok G.
Writer:
Ashok G.

Two hours of drivel
Sat, September 6 2025
A film scored by A R Rahman, no less, cannot, in all honesty, be called a silent film. It can also be a big reason for drawing us into a film labelled a silent comedy, because music is key to telling us what words cannot. But looks can be deceptive. Let me warn you, this is two hours of drivel. How on God’s good earth did Rahman get inveigled into a project so vacuous? That’s a mystery which is destined to go unsolved; meanwhile, let me inflict upon you the misery I had to undergo.

There Are No Words
Fri, September 5 2025
If not for movies like Ufff Yeh Siyapaa, I’d be in denial about my age. Denial is not an option when I try to pull out my hair only to be met with a receding hairline. Thanks to the constant face-palming, I also realise that my skin has wrinkles. Thanks to the involuntary sighing and eye-rolling, I realise that yoga might be good for my stamina. Thanks to the inability to keep my eyes on the screen, I realise that my mind needs glasses too. And thanks to the resolute awfulness of a 116-minute silent comedy in 2025, I realise that my life is truly too short.

Unknown Number: The High School Catfish
Documentary (English)
Vulgar, taunting texts blow up the phones of a teen and her boyfriend. Who's sending them — and why? This twisty documentary reveals the shocking answer.
Cast:
Lauryn Licari, Sophie Weber, Macy Johnston, Owen McKenny, Shawn Licari
Director:
Skye Borgman

An outrageous true crime story gets peak Netflix treatment
Sat, September 6 2025
Every so often, Netflix releases a true crime documentary so algorithmically rigorous, so obnoxiously constructed, and so casually exploitative that its success is almost a foregone conclusion. It would, in fact, be a miracle if the film didn’t break through the clutter. Unknown Number: The High School Catfish follows in the undignified tradition of films such as The Tinder Swindler and The Social Dilemma, narrating a story so bizarre that they could’ve made 15 different versions of it and still had material left over. The version presented to us, although undeniably engaging, is perhaps the least responsible way that the filmmakers could’ve approached this scandalous tale. The crime that it revisits wasn’t entirely victimless. And while Unknown Number understands the tragedy at its core — the final 15 minutes contain enough evidence to support this theory — the way it chooses to present its findings is rather odd. The film revolves around… nobody. While it could’ve chosen to approach it from the perspective of at least three different people, it decides to make the story itself the protagonist. Actively ignoring all the different human interest angles on the table is unusual for any documentarian — one could argue that it is their job to uncover human arcs by sifting through hours and hours of raw footage — but that is what director Skye Borgman does here.