/images/members/Vishal Menon.jpg

Vishal Menon

The Hollywood Reporter India

Vishal Menon is the Assoiciate Editor at The Hollywood Reporter, India. He was previously with Film Companion and The Hindu. He writes about Malayalam and Tamil Cinema.

All reviews by Vishal Menon

Image of scene from the film Good Bad Ugly

Good Bad Ugly

Action, Crime, Comedy (Tamil)

Ajith Indulges The Ultimate 'Thala' Fanboy in This Reels’ Era Tribute

Fri, April 11 2025

The Ajith fanboy in Adhik Ravichandran ends up shooting so many references from the star's filmography at us, that he nukes the fourth wall and builds a grand tomb over it in 'Good Bad Ugly'

One is unsure if it’s even ethical to call Good Bad Ugly a feature film. From a safe distance, one can argue that it’s the length of a regular movie and it also features a major movie star in the lead. If you want to push it, one may even argue that it has a something resembling a plot and a screenplay that holds characters and plot points in place. But if you’re willing to wake up and accept reality, you’ll soon realise that Good Bad Ugly is just the Instagram Reels homepage of Ajith’s most obsessive fanboy. Directed by Adhik Ravichandran, the film doesn’t even try to worry about delicately breaking the fourth wall; this Ajith fanboy ends up shooting so many references from the star’s filmography at us, that he nukes the fourth wall and builds a grand tomb over it.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Test

Test

Drama, Thriller (Tamil)

Complex Characters Get Benched In This Middling Drama

Sat, April 5 2025

Director Sashikanth's drama, starring the likes of Madhavan, Nayanthara and Siddharth, gives us a set of fascinating characters, but deserved better writing

One could be half an hour into the setup of Sashikanth’s Test and still be unsure of the genre of the film. When seen from the point of view of 34-year-old Kumudha (Nayanthara), Test is arguably about the testing phase leading up to her last attempt at being a mother. As for Indian team cricketer Arjun (Siddharth), who struggles with his form in what could be his final test match, the movie could be a sports drama about regaining respect from oneself. Finally, when you lean closer into Sara (Madhavan), the out-of-luck MIT scientist just one step away from changing the world, you could even look at Test as a sci-fi film about hydro-fuels. Not that this mix of genres in Test isn’t necessarily a bad thing. The film spends so much time planting us within the conflicts of each of these characters that you feel like you’re being set up for the ebbs and flows of a juicy mini-series, wherein each character is as important as the last. It’s a film that could have gone anywhere with its complexities; however, instead of going deeper into any of them, Test chooses to settle on one central plot line as it approaches the halfway mark.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Ponman

Ponman

Drama (Malayalam)

A Stunning Basil Joseph Shines In This Stressful, High-Stakes Drama

Sun, March 30 2025

As viewers, it’s never easy to hitch your loyalty to any one character in 'Ponman' in which all the great writing decisions are complemented with equally great performances

Ponman seems like a silly title for the film this turned out to be. The title translates to ‘kingfisher’, but it’s also a play on the phrase ‘pon’ meaning gold and man, because it’s about a man who deals in gold. By the end of the film, though, one might find other reasons to justify this title, but to begin with, you understand that it’s referring to the character played by Basil Joseph, a strange character named PP Ajesh. Going by the term the film uses, he runs what is called a “Madiyil Jewellery”, the kind of mobile jewellery in which the gold, literally, ends up on your lap. I’m not sure if this business is specific to Kollam, where the film is set in, but from my understanding of the trade, Ajesh is a broker who supplies gold to brides right before they get married, expecting to be repaid using the money they earn in the form of gifts during the wedding. It’s a peculiar practice, something many of us will discover as we watch Ponman. It is also ideal as a plot device in a film that talks about dowry, that too within the fascinating Latin Catholic community of the region. So, when we first meet PP Ajesh, he’s supplying 25 sovereigns of gold to a bride named Stefi Graf (Lijimol Jose), a night before she gets married to the “big, mountain-like” Mariyano (Sajin Gopu).

Continue Reading…

L2: Empuraan

Action, Crime, Thriller (Malayalam)

Mohanlal shines in moments of emotional heft, but, the film’s overreliance on formulaic twists and underdeveloped antagonists leaves it trailing behind its predecessor’s legacy.

Fri, March 28 2025

Image of scene from the film Mithya

Mithya

Drama (Kannada)

A Coming-Of-Rage Classic About Lost Innocence

Sat, March 8 2025

Starring a wonderful Athish Shetty, filmmaker Sumanth Bhat's drama is about a boy in transit — not just physically but also emotionally.

How much does a young boy have to go through to be allowed the freedom to have an emotional breakdown? When we first meet Mithya (Athish Shetty), what we see is his back turned towards us as he travels on a train from somewhere to somewhere else. We later learn that he’s not travelling out of choice. He’s being displaced from his home in Mumbai to Udipi in Southern Karnataka where he will live with his uncle, aunt and their two daughters. Like Mithya, the film about him too has its back turned towards us. It’s not a film that grants you the solace of having empathised with its broken protagonist. Instead, it reveals these broken pieces so sparsely that we feel as lost and helpless as he does.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Kadhal Enbadhu Podhu Udamai

Kadhal Enbadhu Podhu Udamai

Drama, Romance, Family (Tamil)

An Intense Coming-Out Drama About a Not-So-Modern Family

Sat, February 15 2025

Jayaprakash Radhakrishnan's 'Kadhal Enbadhu Podhu Udamai' doesn’t want to preach to the choir; it instead chooses the far more complex route of speaking to people who are not looking to be convinced.

The first 30 minutes of Kadhal Enbadhu Podhu Udamai (Love Is Common Property) is not an easy film to sit through. It’s frothy and hollow and you’d be surprised that you’re watching the work of writer-director Jayaprakash Radhakrishnan, known for intense psychological dramas such as Lens (2016) and Thalaikoothal (2023). It begins with Sam (Lijomol Jose) confessing to her mother (Rohini) that she’s in love and wants her to meet this person. With the flowery set-up you’d find in silly rom-coms, we get scene after painful scene of the mother, preparing to welcome her future son-in-law. We learn that they hail from the upper middle class, and we also learn that Sam’s parents separated years ago. The film uses this time to introduce us to a handful of characters, including Sam’s father (Vineeth), Sam’s bestie Ravi (Kalesh) and Deepa (Deepa Shankar), the cook who is more than family.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Painkili

Painkili

Romance, Comedy (Malayalam)

A Wildly Original, Mildly Frustrating Comedy

Sat, February 15 2025

If you’re willing to let go of your defences, 'Painkili' becomes a mausoleum of madness, a citadel of cringe that gets you to laugh for the kind of jokes you’ve never seen or heard of before.

In Sreejith Babu’s debut Painkili, cringe isn’t the after-effect as much as it is the aesthetic the film aspires for. It is self-aware and loud and made by a director with such an original style that he hasn’t yet found ways to bring it under control. How else would you describe some of the wild ideas that are dime a dozen? Take the example of a character named Jaffer, one of the many “gundas” in the film. Not only does Jaffer introduce himself each time he runs into a friend, but he goes on to call everyone around him Jaffer too. It doesn’t make any sense and oftentimes ideas like these are so strange that we’re unsure if we’re expected to laugh or wince. But in the odd instance one of these wild swings begin to make sense, it’s next to impossible to stop laughing.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Vidaamuyarchi

Vidaamuyarchi

Action, Thriller (Tamil)

A Solid Marriage Story Stuck In A Middling Action Flick

Fri, February 7 2025

Ajith and Trisha's 'Vidaamuyarchi' directed by Magizh Thirumeni, begins with a fascinating setup about a lost couple having to find their way back into love, but soon gets sidelined into a generic action movie

There are lovely additions Magizh Thirumeni makes to Breakdown (1997) to humanise what was otherwise a straightforward Hollywood action movie. This begins right with the way he re-interprets the title ‘Breakdown’. Not only does this mean that Magizh’s version begins way before Arjun’s (Ajith Kumar) car breaks down in the middle of nowhere as he travels with his wife to Tbilisi, but the title also alludes to the ‘breakdown’ they are experiencing in their marriage. It’s middle of the road in a sense, but the not the kind you’re thinking about. They’ve been together for 12 years and they’ve lost the magic that had once brought them together. In another awkward meet-cute that we’ve now come to expect from Magizh Thirumeni, we’re told that Arjun once sent “Happy Birthday” messages every day to Kayal (Trisha) for six consecutive months. But after 12 years, Arjun doesn’t even remember the date anymore, even when the world stays up to wish Kayal.

Continue Reading…

Latest Reviews

Image of scene from the film Saiyaara
FCG Rating for the film
Saiyaara

Romance, Drama (Hindi)

Short-tempered musician Krish is paired with a no-nonsense lyricist in Vaani, for the music company to… (more)

Image of scene from the film The Fantastic Four - First Steps
FCG Rating for the film
The Fantastic Four - First Steps

Science Fiction, Adventure (English)

Against the vibrant backdrop of a 1960s-inspired, retro-futuristic world, Marvel's First Family is forced to balance… (more)

Image of scene from the film Happy Gilmore 2
Happy Gilmore 2

Comedy (English)

Happy Gilmore isn't done with golf — not by a long shot. Since his retirement after… (more)

Image of scene from the film Sarzameen
FCG Rating for the film
Sarzameen

Drama, Thriller (Hindi)

A father who refused to bowl down to threats, a son who was given up for… (more)