/images/members/Shubhra-003.jpg

Shubhra Gupta

The Indian Express

Shubhra Gupta, a senior columnist and acclaimed film critic at The Indian Express, boasts over 30 years of experience with her widely-read weekly review column. A prominent figure in India’s film criticism scene, she frequently attends global film festivals and has served on national and international juries. She curates and conducts the hugely popular platform, The Indian Express Film Club, in Delhi and Mumbai.

All reviews by Shubhra Gupta

Image of scene from the film Gram Chikitsalay

Gram Chikitsalay

Comedy, Drama (Hindi)

Safe and staid Panchayat redux colours itself in sameness

Sat, May 10 2025

The TVF stamp is clear, and the mandate appears to be the same -- give the viewers yet another slice of ruralcore where the clash between city and village is laid out in slow-paced easily digestible chunks.

A doctor comes to a village, there to discover a place where a familiar mix of innocence and craftiness is at play, where a quack has a bustling practice, and where he, the well-intentioned doc, learns life lessons. Replace Amol Parashar’s doctor with Jitendra Kumar’s sachivji, and you will get the set-up for Panchayat, TVF’s much-loved show, with so little difference as to be negligible. But given that clueless shehari babus having to check their privilege can make for an entertaining ride, there will always be similar shows.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film The Bhootnii

The Bhootnii

Comedy, Horror, Romance (Hindi)

This film lacks plot, production value, sense and sensibility

Mon, May 5 2025

Sanjay Dutt-Mouni Roy 'film' proudly and flagrantly stands apart from any vestiges of plot and production values, forget about sense and sensibility.

Within a few minutes of the film’s opening, I asked myself: what am I doing here? Two hours, ten minutes, and what seems like a lifetime of groaning-and-moaning later, I have zero answers to that one. Horror comedies may be the flavour of the season after the ‘Stree’ jamboree, but even its part 2 was nowhere close to the delightful original. In this new film, we get a ‘The’, emphasising that this is not your random garden variety of bhootni, but a very specific one, with a double i to boot. Ergo, this one will stand apart. Which it does. It proudly and flagrantly stands apart from any vestiges of plot and production values, forget about sense and sensibility.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Black, White & Gray: Love Kills

Black, White & Gray: Love Kills

Crime, Drama (Hindi)

A plot told with conviction, backed by solid performances

Fri, May 2 2025

Patriarchy, parental opposition, class differences, power structures, are all present in this crime drama, reminding you of several others that have come before.

There are flashes of familiarity in Black, White and Gray—Love Kills in the broad thematic connections it is attempting at, between young lovers on the run, and the obstacles that come in their way. Patriarchy, parental opposition, class differences, power structures, are all present in this crime drama, reminding you of several others that have come before. But it stands out in the way it takes us along the ride, joining and erasing the dots, while creating vivid portraits of its characters and societal mores. I watched the six episodes of about 40-45 minutes each in a single gulp, because it got me invested in the people it was tracking, and wanted to know what happens next. Yes, there are contrivances — the structure of a documentary filmmaker speaking to ‘real’ people, with a parallel track being played out by those standing in for them, is the biggest of them all — and a few slack, improbable patches, but they are not deal breakers.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Raid 2

Raid 2

Drama, Crime (Hindi)

Ajay Devgn film is so much dullness, so little fun

Fri, May 2 2025

The Ajay Devgn-starrer is wrapped in such a strong whiff of sameness that the first half comes off entirely superfluous. After a string of eye-glaze scenes in which Devgn and Riteish Deshmukh go at each other, you are left clutching at straws.

Seven years after the original ‘Raid’, IRS DCP Amay Patnaik (Ajay Devgn) returns to create yet another storm in a den of corruption. This time around, he’s in Bhoj, a town ruled by Dada Manohar Bhai (Riteish Deshmukh), whom the locals worship. Dada Bhai, in turn, worships, literally, at the feet of his Amma (Surpriya Pathak): he’s the obedient son, and the clean-as-a-whistle ruler. It’s only Amay, the sharpest card in the income tax department, who suspects that there is something jet black in this very white ‘dal’, and starts stirring the pot vigorously, hoping for the real picture to emerge.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Costao

Costao

Drama (Hindi)

Nawazuddin Siddiqui gets a role that’s worthy of his talents, but script lacks lustre

Thu, May 1 2025

Only if the Nawazuddin Siddiqui-starrer had been executed with more verve, this would have been a film to remember for all the right reasons. Instead, the telling lets down both actors and story.

Honest customs officer up against a wall of corruption. Costao, based on the real-life story of Costao Fernandes who fought with all his might to stall gold-smuggling in the Goa of the 90s, has Nawazuddin Siddiqui in a role that’s worthy of his talents, but a script which is distinctly lacklustre. A film that starts with a voiceover alerts you to the fact that the writers couldn’t find a more original way to tell their story. In this instance, Costao’s loving daughter is made the conduit, and the film becomes as much tell as it is show.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Ground Zero

Ground Zero

Action, Thriller, War (Hindi)

Emraan Hashmi’s Kashmir drama strikes a much-needed balance in these fraught times

Sat, April 26 2025

Emraan Hashmi does a good job of playing a BSF officer on the hunt for dreaded terrorist Ghazi Baba. He tones down the dialoguing and makes it sound conversational. But tighter would have been better.

An intensive search-and-combing operation which results in the capture of a dreaded terrorist in Srinagar could be the one-line theme of several similar films in the past. The difference with ‘Ground Zero’, which calls itself a ‘work of fiction based on real-life events’, are two-fold. First, it releases the same week of the Pahalgam tragedy, whose consequences will be felt for a long time to come. Second, it steers clear of the disturbing jingoism that has been part and parcel of such films, focussing instead on the tough life of the BSF jawans and other security forces in the conflict-stricken Kashmir valley Emran Hashmi plays BSF officer Narendra Nath Dhar Dubey, who managed to locate and take out terrorist kingpin Ghazi Baba and his accomplices in 2003. It was a time when PM Atal Bihari Vajpayee had visited the valley, in the midst of rising terrorist activities: there are glimpses of the 2001 attack on Parliament in the film.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Jewel Thief - The Heist Begins

Jewel Thief - The Heist Begins

Action, Thriller (Hindi)

Lazy and banal Saif Ali Khan-Jaideep Ahlawat heist thriller has zero sparkle

Sat, April 26 2025

Borrowing its title from one of Hindi cinema’s most iconic heist movies, this Saif Ali Khan-Jaideep Ahlawat-starrer cobbles together a plot in which every scene and sequence has been done to death, and you can see twists coming before they even start.

Can a film featuring Saif Ali Khan and Jaideep Ahlawat and a diamond bigger than the Ritz turn out to be a shockingly banal bauble?That’s not a trick question. It is something I’ve been asking myself since I finished watching ‘Jewel Thief A Heist Begins’, a face-off between a too-cool-for-school jewel thief (Saif Ali Khan), and a nattily-turned out mobster (Jaideep Ahlawat) who has a thing for pulping humans with his bare hands. Given that heist films are a dime a dozen, the least one can expect when you’ve got these two leads, fully capable of generating fizz, is to give us flash and pizazz and non-stop thrills, because that’s what the best high-stakes, high-on-adrenaline ‘heere-ki-chori’ films are about.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Phule

Phule

History, Drama (Hindi)

A middling, talky period drama about a remarkable revolutionary couple

Sat, April 26 2025

Both Pratik Gandhi and Patralekha as Jyotiba and Savitribai do justice to their characters, the latter given more fiery oratorial chances in her pushback against oppression.

In the 19th century Maharashtra, Jyoti Rao Phule and his wife Savitri Bai lit the flame of female education and all-round empowerment at a time when girls were married off when they were barely more than children, forced to bear and rear their own children for the rest of their lives. In an early scene, we see little Savitri learn how to read with the help of the much-older Jyotiba, and how that changed her, and made her aware of her world. The release of this bio-pic, whose opening credits claim that it is based on detailed research, was delayed because of ruffled Brahmin feathers, but nothing in it feels like a figment of the filmmakers’ imagination. It feels like an accurate if sanitised representation of social realities of that time, during which the British were playing their own crafty games of keeping the ‘natives’ in check, by using the rampant caste discrimination to keep dividng and ruling while holding out the carrot of conversion to Christianity.

Continue Reading…

Latest Reviews

Image of scene from the film A House of Dynamite
A House of Dynamite

Thriller, War (English)

When a single, unattributed missile is launched at the United States, a race begins to determine… (more)

Image of scene from the film Diés Iraé
FCG Rating for the film
Diés Iraé

Horror, Thriller (Malayalam)

Rohan's affluent lifestyle spirals out of control as he becomes convinced there is a supernatural entity… (more)

Image of scene from the film Aaryan
Aaryan

Action, Thriller, Crime (Tamil)

A struggling writer announces he'll commit the perfect crime, sparking a tense pursuit as police try… (more)

Image of scene from the film Black Phone 2
Black Phone 2

Horror, Thriller (English)

Four years after escaping The Grabber, Finney Blake is struggling with his life after captivity. When… (more)