/images/members/Shubhra-003.jpg

Shubhra Gupta

The Indian Express

Shubhra Gupta, a senior columnist and acclaimed film critic at The Indian Express, boasts over 30 years of experience with her widely-read weekly review column. A prominent figure in India’s film criticism scene, she frequently attends global film festivals and has served on national and international juries. She curates and conducts the hugely popular platform, The Indian Express Film Club, in Delhi and Mumbai.

All reviews by Shubhra Gupta

Image of scene from the film The Phoenician Scheme

The Phoenician Scheme

Drama, Comedy, Crime (English)

Wes Anderson ratchets up the whimsy in The Phoenician Scheme, doesn’t stick the landing

Fri, May 23 2025

There’s Scarlett Johansson too in a cameo, playing Korda’s second cousin with a whole scene to herself, where she is proposed to

If whimsy had an address, it would be Wes Anderson, whose confections can either delight or dismay. His Cannes competition entry The Phoenician Scheme has nestled firmly into the latter for me: his latest flight of fancy, quite literally, with his lead character traversing the skies in a private jet, being ejected at regular intervals, turns the film into a survival manual. The film is set in the 50s. Benicio Del Toro plays Zsa Zsa Korda, a wealthy businessman who has a half-brother (Benedict Cumberbatch, almost unrecognisable under a thatched beard), a daughter who is a nun, and nine sons. If Korda wasn’t properly eccentric, he wouldn’t be a Wes character: accordingly, he decides to bequeath his empire to Liesl (Mia Threapleton), whether she likes it or not.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Nouvelle Vague

Nouvelle Vague

Comedy, Drama, History (French)

A warm homage to the pioneers of French New Wave

Fri, May 23 2025

Linklater’s film will make those who adore Breathless nostalgic. Set in 1969, it is black and white, but it’s not the luscious-lambent period black-and-white which could have distanced us; the matter-of-fact palette makes it all very life-like.

A film about cinephiles for cinephiles is one way to describe ‘Nouvelle Vague’ (New Wave), Richard Linklater’s love letter to movies. You could also say that it is about the making of ‘Breathless’, which it is. But it’s truly, gloriously more. It’s about being young and alive, broke and audacious, lucking into friends who make you come alive, having each other’s backs — all while changing the world. In the 50s, a bunch of French film critics were busy discovering the joys of ‘middlebrow Hollywood commercial’ cinema, which was treated with disdain by a high-minded earlier generation. Jacques Rivette, Eric Rohmer, Chaude Chabrol, Francois Truffaut and Jean-Luc Godard were among those who contributed to Cahiers du Cinema, a journal which published these rebels-with-a-righteous-cause.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film The Royals

The Royals

Drama (Hindi)

Ishaan Khatter, Bhumi Pednekar series struggles for air under all that costumery

Sat, May 10 2025

Ishaan Khatter had more bite in his small part in the Nicole Kidman starrer ‘The Perfect Couple’. All that coupling with Bhumi Pednekar doesn’t really get as steamy as it should have.

The Rajkumar and the Aam Kumari. He is royalty, she is middle-class. He rides horses on the beach, sculpted bare chest a-gleam. She’s shiny too, but more from the plebeian pursuit of running. Cool tracks, though, and very sculpted too, but of course, chalk and cheese. Aviraaj Singh (Ishaan Khatter) and Sophia Kanmani Shekhar (Bhumi Pednekar) spark, clash, part, meet again. You know the drill; classic rom com territory. Add in big baubles and bigger palaces, , a phalanx of princes and princesses, and the full Rajasthan rajasi retinue, with the the constant flurry of hukum, khammaghani, leheriya headgear, in place.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Gram Chikitsalay

Gram Chikitsalay

Comedy, Drama (Hindi)

Safe and staid Panchayat redux colours itself in sameness

Sat, May 10 2025

The TVF stamp is clear, and the mandate appears to be the same -- give the viewers yet another slice of ruralcore where the clash between city and village is laid out in slow-paced easily digestible chunks.

A doctor comes to a village, there to discover a place where a familiar mix of innocence and craftiness is at play, where a quack has a bustling practice, and where he, the well-intentioned doc, learns life lessons. Replace Amol Parashar’s doctor with Jitendra Kumar’s sachivji, and you will get the set-up for Panchayat, TVF’s much-loved show, with so little difference as to be negligible. But given that clueless shehari babus having to check their privilege can make for an entertaining ride, there will always be similar shows.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film The Bhootnii

The Bhootnii

Comedy, Horror, Romance (Hindi)

This film lacks plot, production value, sense and sensibility

Mon, May 5 2025

Sanjay Dutt-Mouni Roy 'film' proudly and flagrantly stands apart from any vestiges of plot and production values, forget about sense and sensibility.

Within a few minutes of the film’s opening, I asked myself: what am I doing here? Two hours, ten minutes, and what seems like a lifetime of groaning-and-moaning later, I have zero answers to that one. Horror comedies may be the flavour of the season after the ‘Stree’ jamboree, but even its part 2 was nowhere close to the delightful original. In this new film, we get a ‘The’, emphasising that this is not your random garden variety of bhootni, but a very specific one, with a double i to boot. Ergo, this one will stand apart. Which it does. It proudly and flagrantly stands apart from any vestiges of plot and production values, forget about sense and sensibility.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Black, White & Gray: Love Kills

Black, White & Gray: Love Kills

Crime, Drama (Hindi)

A plot told with conviction, backed by solid performances

Fri, May 2 2025

Patriarchy, parental opposition, class differences, power structures, are all present in this crime drama, reminding you of several others that have come before.

There are flashes of familiarity in Black, White and Gray—Love Kills in the broad thematic connections it is attempting at, between young lovers on the run, and the obstacles that come in their way. Patriarchy, parental opposition, class differences, power structures, are all present in this crime drama, reminding you of several others that have come before. But it stands out in the way it takes us along the ride, joining and erasing the dots, while creating vivid portraits of its characters and societal mores. I watched the six episodes of about 40-45 minutes each in a single gulp, because it got me invested in the people it was tracking, and wanted to know what happens next. Yes, there are contrivances — the structure of a documentary filmmaker speaking to ‘real’ people, with a parallel track being played out by those standing in for them, is the biggest of them all — and a few slack, improbable patches, but they are not deal breakers.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Raid 2

Raid 2

Drama, Crime (Hindi)

Ajay Devgn film is so much dullness, so little fun

Fri, May 2 2025

The Ajay Devgn-starrer is wrapped in such a strong whiff of sameness that the first half comes off entirely superfluous. After a string of eye-glaze scenes in which Devgn and Riteish Deshmukh go at each other, you are left clutching at straws.

Seven years after the original ‘Raid’, IRS DCP Amay Patnaik (Ajay Devgn) returns to create yet another storm in a den of corruption. This time around, he’s in Bhoj, a town ruled by Dada Manohar Bhai (Riteish Deshmukh), whom the locals worship. Dada Bhai, in turn, worships, literally, at the feet of his Amma (Surpriya Pathak): he’s the obedient son, and the clean-as-a-whistle ruler. It’s only Amay, the sharpest card in the income tax department, who suspects that there is something jet black in this very white ‘dal’, and starts stirring the pot vigorously, hoping for the real picture to emerge.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Costao

Costao

Drama (Hindi)

Nawazuddin Siddiqui gets a role that’s worthy of his talents, but script lacks lustre

Thu, May 1 2025

Only if the Nawazuddin Siddiqui-starrer had been executed with more verve, this would have been a film to remember for all the right reasons. Instead, the telling lets down both actors and story.

Honest customs officer up against a wall of corruption. Costao, based on the real-life story of Costao Fernandes who fought with all his might to stall gold-smuggling in the Goa of the 90s, has Nawazuddin Siddiqui in a role that’s worthy of his talents, but a script which is distinctly lacklustre. A film that starts with a voiceover alerts you to the fact that the writers couldn’t find a more original way to tell their story. In this instance, Costao’s loving daughter is made the conduit, and the film becomes as much tell as it is show.

Continue Reading…

Latest Reviews

Image of scene from the film Dhadak 2
FCG Rating for the film
Dhadak 2

Romance, Drama (Hindi)

When Neelesh, an idealistic law student from a marginalised section of society, steps into an prestigious… (more)

Image of scene from the film Su From So
Su From So

Comedy, Horror, Drama (Kannada)

In a peaceful village full of joy, laughter, and vibrant life, everything seems perfect—until one day,… (more)

Image of scene from the film Mahavatar Narsimha
Mahavatar Narsimha

Animation, Action, Fantasy, Drama (Kannada)

Hiranyakashyap, the tyrannical demon, challenges Vishnu, proclaiming himself a god. However, his son Prahlad remains devoted… (more)

Image of scene from the film Son of Sardar 2
FCG Rating for the film
Son of Sardar 2

Comedy, Drama (Hindi)

Years after settling an epic family feud and surviving house arrest in Punjab, Jassi Singh Randhawa… (more)