
Saibal Chatterjee
Saibal Chatterjee is an independent film critic based in Delhi. His weekly reviews appear on www.ndtv.com. He also writes on cinema for The Tribune and The Gulf Today newspapers.
All reviews by Saibal Chatterjee

| Director: | Potsy Ponciroli |
|---|---|
| Cast: | Himesh Patel, Joseph Gordon-Levitt, Lily James, Uzo Aduba, Tim Blake Nelson, Simon Rex, Nina Arianda, Jim Gaffigan, José María Yázpik, Joey Lauren Adams |
| Writer: | Mike Vukadinovich |
Greedy People
Comedy, Mystery, Crime (English)
The Film Has Its Share Of Passably Bright Moments
Sat, November 30 2024
The film is marred a touch by a marked lack of chemistry between the two male actors but that lacuna actually seems intended at times.
A brisk opening that holds some promise, a meandering middle that scuttles much of the early potential, and an overly rushed climax make Greedy People a mixed bag – an action comedy that never kicks into top gear despite all the scampering that it does in search of a sweep spot. Greedy People, premiering in India exclusively on Lionsgate Play and available in English and Hindi, is frequently enlivened by dashes of deadpan humour. With Joseph Gordon-Levitt imparting immense charm and chutzpah to his flamboyant cop and punchlines flying thick and fast between him and his partner in ‘crime’, the film has its share of passably bright moments.

| Director: | Amith Krishnan |
|---|---|
| Cast: | Nayanthara, Vignesh Shivan, Sathyan Anthikad, Fazil, Vishnuvardhan, Bharadwaj Rangan, Anu Vardhan, Rana Daggubati, Radha Krishna Jagarlamudi, Nagarjuna Akkineni |
Nayanthara: Beyond the Fairy Tale
Documentary (English)
The Documentary Serves Its Purpose To Perfection
Sat, November 30 2024
The tale begins of course with her birth into the family of an Indian Air Force officer and his homemaker-wife (whose role in Nayanthara's life is repeatedly emphasised).
In an industry overwhelmingly dominated by men, Nayanthara is a rarity. A “lady superstar” who earned her spurs the hard way and went on to upend many an established showbiz norm, she has over the years fronted numerous big South Indian films that have ridden on her crowd-pulling prowess. This self-produced Netflix documentary seeks to capture the rise and rise of Nayanthara in the face of several reverses. It isn’t an objective account but, notwithstanding the limitations of its format, Nayanthara: Beyond The Fairy Tale is entertaining and insightful.

| Director: | Siva |
|---|---|
| Cast: | Suriya, Bobby Deol, Disha Patani, B. S. Avinash, Kovai Sarala, Yogi Babu, Jagapati Babu, Natarajan Subramaniam, Redin Kingsley, Anandaraj |
Kanguva
Action, Thriller, Fantasy (Tamil)
Its Intent On Being The Tamil Baahubali And KGF Remains Untapped
Sat, November 30 2024
Kanguva is a visual treat enhanced by Suriya's tremendous screen presencekanguva-7
Its ambition is sky-high. Kanguva seeks to derive power from the elements (wind, water and fire), the ambitious merger of two timelines separated by a millennium, and the immense magnetism of lead actor Suriya. Nothing wrong with that of course, but the building blocks would have come together far more effectively had the writing and treatment been more organised and coherent.

| Director: | Nikkhil Advani |
|---|---|
| Cast: | Sidhant Gupta, Chirag Vohra, Rajendra Chawla, Arif Zakaria, Ira Dubey, Rajesh Kumar, Luke McGibney, Cordelia Bugeja, Malishka Mendonsa, K.C. Shankar |
| Writer: | Abhinandan Gupta, Adwitiya Kareng, Gundeep Kaur, Divy Nidhi Sharma, Revanta Sarabhai, Ethan Taylor |
Freedom at Midnight
Drama (Hindi)
Crafted With Utmost Diligence, The Show Gives History Its Due
Fri, November 15 2024
Freedom at Midnight isn't driven by A-list stars but by actors who painstakingly and confidently flesh out the towering historical figures
In Freedom of Midnight, showrunner and director Nikkhil Advani, working with a script by a team of six writers, blends solid historicity with elements of fiction and imagination to bring to the screen the agonizing final leg of India’s freedom struggle. The SonyLIV drama series produced by Emmay Entertainment and StudioNext, is crafted with utmost diligence. It blends grandeur with intimacy, swept with precision, sustained gravitas with an acute awareness of the timeless contemporaneity of political decisions of far-reaching consequences made in an era of great upheavals by the architects of a free nation forged in fire.

| Cast: | Samantha Ruth Prabhu, Varun Dhawan, Kay Kay Menon, Kashvi Majmundar, Simran, Saqib Saleem, Sikandar Kher, Shivankit Singh Parihar, Soham Majumdar |
|---|
Citadel: Honey Bunny
Action & Adventure, Drama, Sci-Fi & Fantasy (English)
The Series Misses The Bull's Eye By Miles
Thu, November 7 2024
The series does not exactly go down in flames but neither does it have us holding our breath as its action set pieces explode on screen.
It hits the ground running all right but the mission of sustaining the momentum is an abject failure. Much of what Citadel: Honey Bunny attempts to do proves way too much for a script that, even at its best, can only laboriously inch its way forward - and backwards. Citadel: Honey Bunny is an Indian spinoff of Amazon Prime Video’s Citadel Spyverse that was birthed last year in an espionage thriller series fronted by Priyanka Chopra and Richard Madden and executive produced by the Russo brothers. While it has its share of action, it runs low on intrigue and suspense.

| Director: | Shashanka Chaturvedi |
|---|---|
| Cast: | Kajol, Kriti Sanon, Shaheer Sheikh, Tanvi Azmi, Brijendra Kala, Prachee Shah, Vivek Mushran, Rohit Tiwari, Chittaranjan Tripathy, Shastra Prashant Gajbhare |
Do Patti
Thriller, Mystery, Drama, Crime (Hindi)
Kriti Sanon's Film Needed Much Better Cards To Make A Game Of It
Fri, October 25 2024
The film is purply dark, a little suspenseful and somewhat twisted.
Identical twins of the kind that we encounter in Hindi popular cinema are always temperamentally polar opposites. The pair in Do Patti, a Netflix film directed by Shashanka Chaturvedi, is no exception - they look the same but are dissimilar in disposition and demeanour. The film, however, deviates from the larger narrative template that governs the genre. Mumbai movies may have stumbled upon a degree of freedom thanks to the advent of the streamers, but old habits die hard. Do Patti, scripted by Kanika Dhillon, has an old trope at its core. It, however, eschews the usual confusion-caused-by-mistaken-identity construct.

| Director: | Vikramaditya Motwane |
|---|---|
| Cast: | Ananya Panday, Vihaan Samat, Devika Vatsa, Kamakshi Bhat, Suchita Trivedi, Samit Gambhir, Ravish Desai, Aparshakti Khurana, Tanmay Bhat, Rohan Joshi |
CTRL
Thriller, Drama (Hindi)
An Uncategorisable Film That Is Equal Parts Entertaining And Sobering
Fri, October 4 2024
CTRL, in spirit and substance, reinforces Vikramaditya Motwane's proven penchant for turning an established genre on its head.
Conjuring up a life that plays out in a virtual space - in other words, setting up a gauzy existence that floats in a dimension far removed from the real and the tangible - has its wages. Vikramaditya Motwane’s inventive, sparky CTRL examines the nature and extent of the toll that burrowing into a rabbit hole of constructed personas and enhanced engagements can extract.

| Director: | Himank Gaur |
|---|---|
| Cast: | Bhuvan Bam, Shriya Pilgaonkar, Deven Bhojani, Prathmesh Parab, Shilpa Shukla, Nitya Mathur, Atisha Naik, Vijay Nikam, Samarth Kaimliya, Jaaved Jaffery |
| Writer: | Aziz Dalal, Hussain Dalal, Abbas Dalal |
Taaza Khabar S02
Drama, Sci-Fi & Fantasy (Hindi)
Bhuvan Bam Gives The Role His Best Shot
Mon, September 30 2024
The series certainly isn't a junkpile but it does end up in a puddly heap more often than is good for it. Go in with your eyes open.
Bhuvan Bam’s Vasant Gawde, Mr. Vardaan to the world owing to his ability to see events before they come to pass, is back seeking to make a killing from the prescient news updates that he receives on a mobile phone app. This time around, the Taaza Khabar protagonist is either on the backfoot or, worse still, down on his haunches. His plight necessitates desperate measures as he faces new challenges hurled at him by a man who will stop at nothing. But the show, notwithstanding a series of dramatic confrontations, struggles to skirt around the pitfalls of an idea that is beginning to wear thin.
Latest Reviews



Babita Singh Reporting
Crime, Drama (Hindi)
People-pleasing cop Baby accepts a fake charge to get leave for her sister-in-law’s baby shower in… (more)


Toxic: A Fairy Tale for Grown-ups
Action, Crime, Drama (Kannada)
A powerful drug cartel pulls the strings behind a facade of sun-soaked beaches as a gritty,… (more)
