/images/members/Saibal Chatterjee.jpg

Saibal Chatterjee

NDTV

Saibal Chatterjee is an independent film critic based in Delhi. His weekly reviews appear on www.ndtv.com. He also writes on cinema for The Tribune and The Gulf Today newspapers.

All reviews by Saibal Chatterjee

Image of scene from the film Alaav

Alaav

Drama (Hindi)

(Written for The Daily Eye)

AGE, STILLNESS, CINEMA

Thu, December 4 2025

Stands apart as one of the most quietly affecting Indian independent films of recent years, resonating with audiences at global festivals for its authenticity and emotional precision.

Life stands still and yet flows inexorably in Alaav – Hearth and Home, written and directed by Prabhash Chandra. The uncompromisingly austere film approximates the restrained tempo of existence when old age takes its toll on both the giver and recipient of geriatric care. With its meticulously composed frames and strikingly unhurried rhythm, Alaav delineates the weight of ageing and its repercussions on a 95-year-old woman and her sexagenarian son sheltered in a well-appointed Delhi home.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Tere Ishk Mein

Tere Ishk Mein

Romance, Drama, Action (Hindi)

A Love Story So Bloated Even Dhanush And Kriti Sanon Can't Salvage It

Fri, November 28 2025

It is a love story that is an advertisement that love can do without.

Director Aanand L Rai’s new film poses an old question: can love douse the flames that violence sparks? Its search for an answer takes it nowhere in particular. But inevitably for a film dedicated to “Mahadev and his Ganga”, Tere Ishk Mein makes a brief stopover in the holy city of Benaras, where a priest-philosopher (Mohammed Zeeshan Ayyub in a special appearance) holds forth on love, death and salvation.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film 120 Bahadur

120 Bahadur

Action, War (Hindi)

Farhan Akhtar's Film Is Consistently Watchable

Fri, November 21 2025

Farhan Akhtar fleshes out the Param Vir Chakra-recipient without overstretching himself.

Shorn of jingoism, free of gratuitous frills and delivered with fitting deference to the memory of the Indian soldiers (many of them unsung) who laid down their young lives in the battle of Rezang La in 1962, 120 Bahadur is a Bollywood war movie of a refreshingly different timbre. Directed by Razneesh “Razy” Ghai and written by Rajiv G. Menon with dialogues by Sunit Arora, 120 Bahadur strikes a balance between emotion and action in its fictionalisation of a military face-off that took a heavy toll of lives but helped India stop China from marching into Ladakh.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Delhi Crime 3

Delhi Crime 3

Crime (Hindi)

Shefali Shah Is As Good As Ever, Huma Qureshi Is Rock-Solid

Thu, November 13 2025

It holds its ground when it matters

Given the high benchmark it has to reckon with, Delhi Crime Season 3 has its task cut out. It does all it can to measure up but falls just a tad, (yes, just a tad!), short of replicating the powerful wallop that the first two seasons packed. The thrilling and disquieting true-crime drama is not the sort of gut punch that would send one reeling, nor is the nature of the violence that it depicts as terrifyingly severe as it was the last time around. Much of the brutality on show - the victims are teenage girls captured by a gang of vicious traffickers - is either only suggested or palpably curbed rather than shown in graphic detail.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Haq

Haq

Drama (Hindi)

Emraan Hashmi And Yami Gautam's Film Stays Rooted In Real World

Sat, November 8 2025

Yami Gautam Dhar and Emraan Hashmi make the most of it with some effort to spare.

Until two prolonged and pointed courtroom soliloquies are staged in quick succession late in the film – one is delivered by Emraan Hashmi, the other by Yami Gautam Dhar, with both actors acquitting themselves to perfection – Haq opts for sustained restraint even in its most dramatic passages. It is this temperance that defines the film. It is rare for a Bollywood film these days not to froth at the mouth when talking about India’s principal minority community and summarily stereotyping it. Directed by Suparn S. Varma and written by Reshu Nath, Haq tackles an emotive and sensitive topic. It could easily have gone overboard. That it does not is the film’s greatest strength.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film The Taj Story

The Taj Story

Drama (Hindi)

Even Paresh Rawal Can't Save This Throw Of Dice That Is All Over The Place

Sat, November 8 2025

Erratic writing is the film's biggest, but by no means the only, drawback

Notwithstanding the title, The Taj Story does not have much of a story to tell. What it does peddle by way of a narrative has not only been done to death over the decades but has also been debunked in several courts of the land, including the apex one. The writer of the film is constrained to admit as much in a series of title cards before the end-credits begin to roll. The Taj Story is bargain-basement filmmaking that draws inspiration from unsubstantiated history to create a piece of cinema that expects full-on explosions from dud-bombs. It wends its way through prickly territory only to end up without a case strong enough to make itself essential viewing for those who care for the truth.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Thamma

Thamma

Comedy, Horror (Hindi)

Rashmika Mandanna And Ayushmann Khurrana Film Is Compact, Impactful

Wed, October 22 2025

Nawazuddin Siddiqui brings an exceptional level of flash and flair to bear upon the titular role.

A genre-breaching inter-species love story, Munjya and Zombivli director Aditya Sarpotdar’s Thamma harks back to a character or two that are integral to the Maddock Horror Comedy Universe (MHCU) while it marks out the way forward for the evolving franchise with a pair of new all-powerful figures who now have their tasks cut out. Does Thamma have enough crackle to be a fitting Diwali release? For the most part, yes. Rooted in all-encompassing folklore, it mashes up a medley of fantasy conventions and rustles up a tale in which the boundaries of credulity are constantly tested but in a fun sort of way.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Bison Kaalamaadan

Bison Kaalamaadan

Action, Drama (Tamil)

Mari Selvaraj Film Is Vibrant, Vivid, Uncluttered

Fri, October 17 2025

Dhruv Vikram demonstrates sustained patience and skill in capturing the arduous journey of Kittan

Underdog stories tend to traverse a predictable arc - from incipient dream to dogged pursuit, from frequent stumbling blocks to rousing, triumphal finale. On the face of it, Bison Kaalamaadan, writer-director Mari Selvaraj’s fifth film, is cast in pretty much the same mould. But that isn’t all there is to it. While the Tamil film largely swings to a familiar beat, it isn’t just another sports drama. Selvaraj puts on it a significant spin that liberates the film from the confines of genre. The urgent social commentary at the core of the film is draped in popular storytelling trappings. The audience gets the best of both worlds.

Continue Reading…

Latest Reviews

Image of scene from the film Dhurandhar
FCG Rating for the film Dhurandhar: 56/100
Dhurandhar

Action, Thriller (Hindi)

After the hijacking of IC-814 in 1999 and the Parliament attack in 2001, India’s Intelligence Bureau… (more)

Image of scene from the film Stephen
FCG Rating for the film Stephen: 57/100
Stephen

Thriller (Tamil)

A psychiatrist evaluating a self-confessed serial killer unravels a twisted web of trauma, deceit, and psychological… (more)

Image of scene from the film Kalamkaval
Kalamkaval

Crime, Drama (Malayalam)

Early 2010s. A routine Kerala Police inquiry in the quiet village of Kottayikonam takes an unexpected… (more)

Image of scene from the film The Girlfriend
FCG Rating for the film The Girlfriend: 67/100
The Girlfriend

Romance, Drama (Telugu)

A young woman explores love, compatibility and self-discovery during college, experiencing relationship complexities and personal growth.… (more)