/images/members/ROHANNAHAAR221.jpg

Rohan Naahar

Independent Film Critic

Rohan Naahar is based out of New Delhi, India, and has been reviewing films and television shows for over a decade. He has written for the Hindustan Times and currently writes for the Indian Express.

All reviews by Rohan Naahar

Image of scene from the film Mission: Impossible - The Final Reckoning

Mission: Impossible - The Final Reckoning

Action, Adventure, Thriller (English)

Tom Cruise deserved better than a goofy Abbas-Mustan movie that chooses spoon-feeding over spectacle

Sat, May 24 2025

So Bollywood-coded that all the mask-ripping, triple-crossing, and spoon-feeding seems like sirka-pyaaz and chutney before the action-packed main course.

There’s a scene in Mission: Impossible — The Final Reckoning where Hayley Atwell’s character, Grace, looks Ethan Hunt dead in the eye, and suggests with stone-faced seriousness that he accepts his destiny and becomes God. Played by Tom Cruise, Ethan could soon gain possession of an incredible artefact that’ll nudge him in that direction. His buddy Luther has invented a gizmo that basically functions as a magic lamp in which he plans to trap the rogue genie that he is after — an AI villain called The Entity. Ethan’s reluctance to handle absolute power, however, is about as believable as something like The Entity being caught and captured in a fancy pen drive. But if there’s one thing that we’ve learnt about him in these last decades, it’s that when he’s given a choice — there’s always a choice — he doesn’t say no.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film American Manhunt - Osama bin Laden

American Manhunt - Osama bin Laden

Documentary (English)

Netflix series could lowkey be a CIA-funded propaganda piece, but it’s undeniably thrilling

Sat, May 17 2025

The three-episode Netflix documentary features a host of high-ranking CIA officials, and also Robert O’Neill, the Navy SEAL who has controversially claimed to have killed bin Laden.

Every single high-ranking official who appears in American Manhunt: Osama bin Laden — and there certainly is a murderer’s row of them — knows that they are in a Netflix documentary. They’re prone to speaking in blurbs; in declarations and pronouncements, almost as if they want to make sure that they make the cut. The sprawling three-episode series, which was suspiciously released two months after it was supposed to, traces the decade-long hunt for Osama bin Laden, the notorious Al Qaeda leader who remained, for a long period of time, the most wanted man in the world. At the peak of America’s war on terror, there was a $25 million price on his head. Bin Laden kept taunting the Americans for years, somehow evading capture despite having being driven out of his stronghold in Afghanistan following the 9/11 attacks. The documentary series begins on the fateful day when two passenger airliners crashed into the World Trade Centre, while another hit the Pentagon. A fourth plane, United 93, crashed into a field in Pennsylvania after passengers overpowered the hijackers and took control of the cockpit. It was the worst terrorist attack in modern history, resulting in the deaths of nearly 3,000 people. President George W. Bush vowed to bring those responsible to justice, and essentially gave the Central Intelligence Agency carte blanche to capture or kill bin Laden.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film The Diplomat

The Diplomat

Thriller, Drama (Hindi)

If John Abraham wants to save his career, he needs to stop saving damsels in distress first

Sat, May 17 2025

In a regular movie, John Abraham's titular character would've been a supporting presence who shows up in the final 10 minutes. But in The Diplomat, he exists to rob the female heroine of her agency.

There is a difference between ambition and delusion. Ambition often depends on one’s means; delusion, on the other hand, hinges on one’s capability. The Diplomat isn’t an ambitious film for barring the brawny John Abraham from lifting a finger. But it’s certainly delusional for thinking of itself as a desi answer to Argo. There is, however, a more unexpected comparison that the movie invites, without realising that it is guilty of committing the same mistakes that it is so confidently calling out. But more on that later. Directed by Shivam Nair, The Diplomat projects itself as a feminist film, but it is actually a tribute to male ego. A dramatically inert distillation of a multi-pronged story, The Diplomat takes a typically Bollywood approach to telling a story about a woman’s emancipation and empowerment. It frames its narrative from the perspective of Abraham’s character, India’s Deputy High Commissioner in Pakistan, JP Singh. But it is actually the story of Uzma Ahmed, an Indian woman played by Sadia Khateeb, who is conned into marrying a Pakistani man named Tahir. They met in Malaysia, where he was working as a taxi driver. A few months into their relationship, Tahir moved back home and invited her to join him there. But he had an ulterior motive.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film The Four Seasons

The Four Seasons

Comedy (English)

The Friends reunion you never got; Tina Fey and Steve Carell’s Netflix show is a star-studded misfire

Fri, May 9 2025

Featuring an all-star cast that includes Tina Fey and Steve Carell, Netflix's new mini-series can't decide if it wants to be a broad comedy or a sentimental meditation on middle-age.

If they can keep all the dads satisfied with shows about burly men going on secret missions and feuding families in the American West, they can certainly take care of the moms as well. Netflix’s The Four Seasons, a comedy drama that follows three married couples across one year, is designed as something of a palate cleanser for middle-aged audiences to watch between the latest true crime offerings. It’s pleasant enough to qualify as undemanding, and has enough moments of insight to elevate it above the ambient TV line. The Four Seasons isn’t good, but it’s good enough. And good enough is good enough these days, especially if you’ve just survived stuff like Jewel Thief or Nadaaniyan. Co-created by and starring Tina Fey, The Four Seasons features a stacked cast that also includes her Saturday Night Live buddy Will Forte — they play a couple — as well as Steve Carell and two-time Oscar nominee Colman Domingo. Think of The Four Seasons as the Friends reunion you never got. These characters could just as easily have been living in New York City apartments back in the late 1990s and early 2000s, worried about where life will take them.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Bad Boy

Bad Boy

Drama (Hebrew)

A grittier, more gruesome companion piece to Adolescence; Netflix’s teen drama is a brutal coming-of-age tale

Fri, May 9 2025

From the creator of the original Euphoria and Homeland, the new Netflix drama is a grittier, grimier companion piece to Adolescence.

A comedian recounts the four traumatic years that he spent in a juvenile detention centre as a teen in the Israeli coming-of-age drama Bad Boy, now out on Netflix. The eight-episode series is interspersed with grainy footage of the comedian, who goes by Daniel, telling jokes about his troubled youth and life-threatening stint in juvie. He used to be called Dean Shaiman back then, and it’s a miracle that he survived. Co-created by Ron Leshem, who remains best-known for the original Euphoria, the series can best be described as the unholy lovechild of Adolescence and Seinfeld. Like that landmark Netflix mini-series, which shattered viewership records only a few weeks ago, Bad Boy opens with a teenage boy being arrested by cops armed with a search warrant of his house. His bedroom is turned upside down, and within minutes, he’s shoved into the back seat of a police car before his mother can even get him his clothes. Like Jamie Miller from Adolescence, Dean is a deeply troubled kid. The difference is that Bad Boy lets us in on his psyche from minute one. The question, then, isn’t if he’s a problem child, but why he’s a problem child.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Asterix & Obelix: The Big Fight

Asterix & Obelix: The Big Fight

Animation, Action & Adventure, Comedy, Kids, Sci-Fi & Fantasy (French)

By Toutatis! Netflix quenches thirst for nostalgia with magic potion for the soul

Sat, May 3 2025

Boasting a striking visual style and filled with hat-tips to the original comic book series, Netflix's five-episode adaptation is as indomitable as the characters in it.

Unlike his fellow Franco-Belgian comic book icon Tintin, Asterix has a rich history of representation in cinema and on television. While Tintin has inspired mainly the beloved Canadian cartoon adaptation and a criminally underrated feature film directed by Steven Spielberg, the adventures of Asterix the Gaul have spawned 18 films, 15 board games, 40 video games, and one theme park. The latest is a glossy Netflix mini-series, originally announced in 2021 but released only this week. Asterix & Obelix: The Big Fight is based on the 1964 comic of the same name, and will likely delight generations of readers who’ve grown up with the character.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Havoc

Havoc

Action, Crime, Thriller (English)

Tom Hardy unleashes a tornado of violence in Netflix’s blood-drenched action-thriller

Sat, May 3 2025

Tom Hardy unleashes his trademark brand of mumbling mayhem in director Gareth Evans' noir action thriller.

Everybody just needs to calm down in Havoc, the long-awaited new movie from Welsh director Gareth Evans. Starring Tom Hardy, it appears to be an attempt by Evans to deliberately distance himself from his two Raid films. Those movies introduced the world to a Pencak Silat, an Indonesian martial art that had previously never been represented on screen in such delectable detail. Evans filmed the combat scenes in those movies the way that Quentin Tarantino films feet. In Havoc, however, he replaces the frenetic fisticuffs with gory gunfights. The result is about as brutal, and far more stylish than anything he’s ever done before.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Jewel Thief - The Heist Begins

Jewel Thief - The Heist Begins

Action, Thriller (Hindi)

How many times will Saif Ali Khan facilitate the destruction of Bollywood (after restoring it)?

Sat, May 3 2025

Jewel Thief, the new heist film on Netflix, isn’t merely a reflection of the state that Bollywood is currently in; it’s a reflection of what Bollywood thinks of you, the viewer.

Many years ago, Netflix announced a grand prequel series to SS Rajamouli’s landmark Baahubali films. A cast was assembled and paraded before the press in Singapore; the series was even given a title: Baahubali: Before the Beginning. It was filmed at Ramoji; people were taken on tours of the set. But the final show was deemed unworthy of Netflix’s server space, and, in an admirable display of creative integrity, it was decided that the project be revamped before being shown to the world. A new creative team was brought on board, and the entire thing was redone with a different cast. Remarkably, even the 2.0 version failed to meet Netflix’s high standards — we are, after all, talking about the same streamer that nodded in approval when presented with Jewel Thief: The Heist Begins — and the mega-budget project, on which hundreds of crores had already been spent, put out of its misery.

Continue Reading…

Latest Reviews

Image of scene from the film Mayilaa
Mayilaa

Drama (Tamil)

Mayilaa embarks on a journey as a travelling salesperson in Southern India to fulfil her expensive… (more)

Image of scene from the film Mardaani 3
FCG Rating for the film Mardaani 3: 57/100
Mardaani 3

Action, Crime, Thriller (Hindi)

Officer Shivani Shivaji Roy returns to hunt down those behind the disappearance of young girls, risking… (more)

Image of scene from the film Om Shanti Shanti Shantihi
Om Shanti Shanti Shantihi

Comedy (Telugu)

Prashanthi gives up her dreams for love, only to fall into abusive relationships first with her… (more)

Image of scene from the film Mayasabha
FCG Rating for the film Mayasabha: 54/100
Mayasabha

Fantasy, Thriller (Hindi)

The monsoons have washed Mumbai. RAVARANA has just come out on parole. He is nothing but… (more)