4,544 Reviews ● 1,330 Films/Shows ● 59 Top Critics
37 Languages ● And Growing!

/images/members/rohan-naahar.jpg

Rohan Naahar

Independent Film Critic

Rohan Naahar is based out of New Delhi, India, and has been reviewing films and television shows for over a decade. He has written for the Hindustan Times, the Indian Express, Collider, and more.

All reviews by Rohan Naahar

Image of scene from the film Dhamaal 4
Director:Indra Kumar
Cast:Ajay Devgn, Arshad Warsi, Riteish Deshmukh, Javed Jaffrey, Sanjay Mishra, Ravi Kishan, Upendra Limaye, Anjali Anand, Sanjeeda Sheikh, Esha Gupta

Dhamaal 4

Comedy (Hindi)
This Review appeared in 'The Federal'

A film in its own special category of lazy

Fri, July 10 2026

At 2 hours 20 minutes long, Indra Kumar film starring Ajay Devgn, Riteish Deshmukh, Arshad Warsi and Jaaved Jafferi is a collection of gags, weakly stitched together.

It doesn’t take a genius to know that Dhamaal 4, directed by Indra Kumar, isn’t a good movie. At 2 hours and 20 minutes long, it’s simply a collection of gags, stitched together with weaker connective tissue than a physiotherapist could detect in the body of a 90-year-old. The film begins with a suspiciously AI-generated-looking prologue about pirates — you read that correctly. Years later, a collection of greedy buffoons sets out on a quest to locate treasure that these pirates left hidden.

Continue Reading…


Image of scene from the film Couture
Director:Alice Winocour
Cast:Angelina Jolie, Anyier Anei, Ella Rumpf, Louis Garrel, Vincent Lindon, Garance Marillier, Grégoire Colin, Aurore Clément, Yuliia Ratner, Mona Tougaard

Couture

Drama (French)
This Review appeared in 'Collider'

'Couture' Wastes Angelina Jolie's Emotionally Bare Performance

Sun, July 5 2026

Miranda Priestly probably wouldn’t tolerate Angelina Jolie’s character from Couture, a new drama set in the world of high fashion that premiered at the Toronto International Film Festival in 2025. Jolie plays Maxine, an indie filmmaker who’s been hired to bring her brand of transgressive edginess to a promotional short for Paris Fashion Week. With neither the patience nor the experience for promotional work, Maxine can barely mask her contempt for her new gig — and that’s before a call from her doctor flips her world upside down. Couture couldn’t be further removed from the glossy world of this summer’s fashion world-set blockbuster The Devil Wears Prada 2. And while that movie makes excuses for the same industry that Couture wants to dress down, director Alice Winocour’s attempt to offer a ground-level perspective of an industry that has been glamorized for far too long turns out dull, directionless, and mildly delusional.

Continue Reading…


Image of scene from the film The Death of Robin Hood
Director:Michael Sarnoski
Cast:Hugh Jackman, Jodie Comer, Bill Skarsgård, Murray Bartlett, Noah Jupe, Jade Croot, Faith Delaney, Tabitha Smyth, Beau Thompson, Alfie Lawless
Writer:Michael Sarnoski

The Death of Robin Hood

Adventure, Drama, Thriller, Action (English)
This Review appeared in 'The Federal'

Despite Hugh Jackman’s towering performance, this is A-grade fan-film

Fri, July 3 2026

Michael Sarnoski film is neither a mood piece nor a swashbuckling thrill-ride. It is a character study of a deeply unpleasant man whose self-hatred borders on the repulsive.

The term “deconstruction” is often thrown around in the world of haute cuisine, which director Michael Sarnoski took a long whiff of in his phenomenal debut feature, Pig. It starred Nicolas Cage as a reclusive former chef who lives in a self-imposed exile in the woods, accompanied by a pet truffle pig and his many demons. Pig remains one of the finest directorial debuts of the last decade, and is a great lead-in to Sarnoski’s latest film, The Death of Robin Hood.

Continue Reading…


Image of scene from the film Pritam and Pedro
Director:Amir Satyaveer Singh, Avinash Arun
Cast:Vir Hirani, Arshad Warsi, Vikrant Massey, Mona Singh, Rajesh Sharma, Mohit Chauhan, Shruti Marathe, Naina Sareen, Satyadeep Misra, Harshika Kewalramani

Pritam and Pedro

Crime, Drama, Mystery (Hindi)
This Review appeared in 'The Federal'

Hotstar series glorified micro-drama with cliched plot, half-baked characters

Fri, July 3 2026

Produced and co-created by Rajkumar Hirani and starring Arshad Warsi as Goa cop Pedro, the crime-comedy series acts as a launchpad for Hirani's son Vir, who plays the mysterious Pritam. But the series works neither as a procedural drama nor as a comedy.

A computer whiz and a tech-challenged cop team up to solve a missing person case in Hotstar’s new crime-comedy series Pritam and Pedro, co-created by the illustrious Rajkumar Hirani. The series essentially serves as a launch vehicle for his son, Vir, who plays the mysterious Pritam. We meet the young man as he’s trying to report his grandfather’s missing tape recorder at a Goa police station run by Pedro, played by Arshad Warsi. The cops throw him in jail when he refuses to leave without registering his complaint. Instantly, Pritam stands out as an honourable young man, while Pedro comes across as a no-nonsense veteran who has seen it all. On paper, they make for the perfect odd-couple — the Indian film industries don’t make nearly enough buddy comedies. However, that’s about as interesting as things get, because, at the end of the day, this is a Hirani production.

Continue Reading…


Image of scene from the film Baby Do Die Do
Director:Nachiket Samant
Cast:Huma Qureshi, Rachit Singh, Sikandar Kher, Seema Pahwa, Chunky Panday, Saqib Saleem, Vidya Malvade, Himanshu Malik, Marudhar Shekhawat, Arun Kushwah

Baby Do Die Do

Mystery, Thriller, Crime (Hindi)
This Review appeared in 'The Federal'

Huma Qureshi film had no excuse to be made

Fri, July 3 2026

Directed by Nachiket Samant and produced by Qureshi and her brother Saqib Saleem, the film stars Qureshi as an assassin. The film flouts basic technique and is a mindless clutter. It takes confidence bordering on delusion to juggle as many elements as Samant does here.

We often underestimate the power that comes with having a backup plan. This is probably what people with standbys feel when they get cheated on. Or what folks with a lucrative job offer in their pocket think to themselves when they’re presented with peanuts during appraisal season. Having a backup plan affords you the agency you normally wouldn’t have in everyday life. But as immensely privileged a responsibility as reviewing movies may be, it often leaves you without a plan B. And where there is no plan B, there is no power. For two, sometimes three hours, you’re at the mercy of whatever is projected in front of you. No running, no hiding, no sneaking into the theatre next door to sacrifice precious brain cells to Cocktail 2 again. These are the thoughts that run through your mind when you watch something like Baby Do Die Do, the new movie starring the otherwise capable Huma Qureshi.

Continue Reading…


Image of scene from the film Enola Holmes S03
Director:Philip Barantini
Cast:Millie Bobby Brown, Henry Cavill, Helena Bonham Carter, Louis Partridge, Himesh Patel, Sharon Duncan-Brewster, Hattie Morahan, Susan Wokoma, Joe Azzopardi, Nicholas Aaron
Writer:Jack Thorne

Enola Holmes S03

Adventure, Crime, Mystery (English)
This Review appeared in 'The Federal'

Millie Bobby Brown starrer retains earnestness of franchise's first two films

Fri, July 3 2026

Her family's repute is revealed to be seemingly ill-gotten; a rebel hopes to overthrow the British Empire someday and Moriarty’s politics is hard to question, as Enola races to find her kidnapped brother, Sherlock, in this third offering in the Enola Holmes franchise.

​Make no mistake, it is a minor miracle that Enola Holmes, the Netflix film franchise which had its first outing in 2020, hasn’t been corrupted by everything that has happened in the past half-decade. The franchise has survived two Trump administrations, a pandemic and whatever the Russo Brothers (filmmakers Joe and Anthony Russo, known for directing four Marvel films) have done to the streaming industry (they reportedly tried to revolutionise the space with offerings like Citadel and The Electric State, but received limited success). And yet somehow, the Enola Holmes movies — revolving around the adventures of the newly-imagined sister of English literature’s legendary detective, Sherlock Holmes — are still as earnest as ever.

Continue Reading…


Image of scene from the film Colony
Director:Yeon Sang-ho
Cast:Gianna Jun, Koo Kyo-hwan, Ji Chang-wook, Kim Shin-rock, Shin Hyun-been, Go Soo, Lee Jung-ok, Kim Jong-tae, Hwang Jae-yeol, Lee Dam-hee
Writer:Yeon Sang-ho, Choi Gyu-seok

Colony

Action, Thriller, Horror (Korean)
This Review appeared in 'The Federal'

Korean zombie film from Train to Busan director Yeon Sang-ho lacks heart amidst mayhem

Fri, June 19 2026

The action unfolds inside a massive office tower in the middle of a densely populated city, when a disgruntled scientist launches a bioterror attack during a seminar conducted by his former partner.

A sporadically clever but ultimately convoluted affair, Colony is somehow both underwritten and over-plotted. The Korean horror-thriller marks a long-awaited return to the zombie genre for director Yeon Sang-ho, who broke out internationally almost exactly a decade ago with the clutter-breaking horror hit Train to Busan. That film took a deceptively simple premise, injected it with some old-fashioned melodrama, and managed to appeal both to Western and Asian sensibilities. In the subsequent decade, Yeon has remained highly sought-after, having directed several movies and as many as three Netflix shows. With Colony, he returns to his roots, armed with a bigger budget, seemingly brighter ideas, and a significantly larger canvas to splatter with gore and other grimy fluids.

Continue Reading…


Image of scene from the film Cocktail 2
Director:Homi Adajania
Cast:Shahid Kapoor, Kriti Sanon, Rashmika Mandanna, Rohit Saraf, Dimple Kapadia, Arjun Rampal, Ishita Dutta, Sanjay Dutt
Writer:Luv Ranjan

Cocktail 2

Romance, Comedy (Hindi)
This Review appeared in 'The Federal'

Shahid Kapoor, Rashmika Mandanna, Kriti Sanon serve up a misogynistic mocktail

Fri, June 19 2026

Cocktail 2 has absolutely nothing to do with the 2012 original, Cocktail, starring Saif Ali Khan, Deepika Padukone and Diana Penty, aside from a remixed song and the returning director, Homi Adajania.

Laziness in mainstream Bollywood isn’t conditional; it’s constitutional. Cocktail 2 is a mocktail of a movie; sugary slop pretending to be the real deal. It’s populated by caricatures and not characters, set in locations that feel like postcards and not actual, lived-in places. Perhaps this is all by design; perhaps inauthenticity is the aspiration. But there has to be an element of truth even in the most far-fetched of falsehoods; there has to be something for those being duped, in this case, the audience, to latch on to. You could put Cocktail 2 under a microscope, or dip it in a chemical, and you still wouldn’t be able to decipher what truth it’s trying to get at. One thing is for sure, though, it is among the most misogynistic movies that mainstream Bollywood has made in a long time, which, for an industry that thrives on misogyny, is saying something.

Continue Reading…


Latest Reviews

Image of scene from the film Udta Teer
FCG Rating for the film Udta Teer: 54/100
Udta Teer

Comedy, Action (Hindi)

An amnesiac Pakistani spy wakes up believing he is a patriotic Indian counter-terrorism officer.… (more)

Image of scene from the film Doosra
Doosra

Drama (Hindi)

The 2002 NatWest Final was more than a cricketing victory for India. It was a moment… (more)

Image of scene from the film Gajab Raat
FCG Rating for the film Gajab Raat: 47/100
Gajab Raat

Thriller, Crime (Hindi)

A corrupt, troubled cop's night spirals out of control when a reluctant act of mercy toward… (more)

Image of scene from the film 418
418

Horror, Thriller (Telugu)

Set in a medical college in a dread-stricken village, the film confronts the science behind superstitions,… (more)