/images/members/ROHANNAHAAR221.jpg

Rohan Naahar

Independent Film Critic

Rohan Naahar is based out of New Delhi, India, and has been reviewing films and television shows for over a decade. He has written for the Hindustan Times and currently writes for the Indian Express.

All reviews by Rohan Naahar

Image of scene from the film Superboys of Malegaon

Superboys of Malegaon

Comedy, Drama (Hindi)

Piracy can’t be condoned, but Reema Kagti’s film believes it’s essential to the survival of theatres

Fri, March 14 2025

In Reema Kagti's Superboys of Malegaon, the protagonist discovers that an act of piracy can save the theatrical ecosystem. Illegal file-sharing and the big-screen experience often go hand-in-hand.

“Jackie Chan could come to Malegaon,” says a young man who has had the misfortune of being born there. “But his films won’t.” The young man is Nasir, the protagonist of director Reema Kagti’s new film, Superboys of Malegaon. Played by Adarsh Gourav, Nasir is the sort of cinephile who would have been logging at least three movies a day on Letterboxd had he been born a decade later, perhaps in a metropolitan city. And as hyperbolic as his words are, there is an element of truth to them. As we speak, the German auteur Wim Wenders is touring the length and breadth of India, taking selfies with Madhabi Mukherjee and reclining on Satyajit Ray’s favourite armchair. But you could be forgiven for not remembering the last time one of his films received a theatrical release here.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Mrs

Mrs

Drama (Hindi)

Mrs: Sanya Malhotra is Bollywood’s posterchild for smash-the-patriarchy cinema, and her Neglected Housewife trilogy is one for the ages

Fri, March 14 2025

In her career, Sanya Malhotra has inadvertently curated a spiritually connected trilogy in which she plays neglected housewives. The latest, Mrs, cements her stature as a star blessed with uncommon screen presence.

A few years ago, the global cinephile community — the sort of people who compose their Letterboxd reviews even before a film has ended — was thrown headfirst into a heated debate. As far as these folks were concerned, this was a debate of presidential magnitude — the kind of debate that could make a disagreement about Marvel movies seem like a ‘kavi sammelan’ in Lucknow. The British magazine Sight & Sound, which compiles a list of the greatest films of all time every decade, had published its latest rankings. And for the first time ever, the Belgian film Jeanne Dielman, 23 quai du Commerce, 1080 Bruxelles — previously viewed as a favourite only in niche circles — had claimed the top spot, sneaking past perennial favourites such as Citizen Kane, Tokyo Story, and Vertigo.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Nadaaniyan

Nadaaniyan

Romance, Comedy (Hindi)

Ibrahim Ali Khan makes one of the worst debuts in years; is Karan Johar determined to set fire to his career before it even begins?

Fri, March 14 2025

Ibrahim Ali Khan essentially plays a high class escort in Netflix's new film, Nadaaniyan, one of the worst that the streamer has ever produced in India. Couldn’t Dharma(tic) have erased this movie from their hard drives and claimed the insurance money?

Inviting Javed Akhtar to the premiere of Nadaaniyan, and making him sit through it — it doesn’t matter that he had a recliner to relax on — is tantamount to elder abuse. Directed by Shauna Gautam, the Netflix romantic drama singlehandedly demolishes any argument that nepotism apologists might have preemptively constructed in the run-up to its release. Ineptly put together, lacking any insight whatsoever into the human experience, Nadaaniyan is a blot on Karan Johar’s career as a film producer, and one of the most questionable originals ever produced by Netflix India — remember, this is the streamer that deemed Shirish Kunder’s Mrs Serial Killer to be worthy of sharing the same server space as Alfonso Cuaron’s Roma.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Rekhachithram

Rekhachithram

Mystery, Thriller (Malayalam)

Indian movies have been mistreating women for decades, but Asif Ali’s Malayalam thriller attempts to redeem the entire industry

Fri, March 14 2025

In Rekhachithram, director Jofin T Chacko observes the doctrines of police procedurals, pays due respect to them, and then sends the movie down an altogether unexpected path in the final 30 minutes.

Malayalam filmmakers aren’t just pushing the boundaries of genre cinema in India, they’ve evolved to a stage where they can confidently toy with tropes. In Aattam, director Anand Ekarshi created magic within the framework of murder mysteries by unraveling the expectations that they come attached with. Ekarshi performed a deft act of cinematic misdirection, revealing that Aattam wasn’t a mystery at all, but a sharp satire of patriarchy. In Rekhachithram, director Jofin T Chacko observes the doctrines of police procedurals, pays due respect to them, and then sends the movie down an altogether unexpected path in the final 30 minutes.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film The Electric State

The Electric State

Science Fiction, Adventure, Drama (English)

The Russo Brothers deliver the worst film of their career; even The Gray Man wasn’t this grim

Fri, March 14 2025

Starring Chris Pratt and Millie Bobby Brown, the Russo brothers' new Netflix tent pole is the kind of movie that seems to get longer while you're watching it.

Someone on social media the other day posted that each of the last 15 Best Picture winners at the Oscars could’ve been funded for the amount that Netflix spent on The Electric State, the astronomically expensive new movie from directors Joe and Anthony Russo. We’re talking about films like Oppenheimer, which itself would’ve taken up $100 million of this cash pool, leaving the remaining $220 million to be spent on landmark films such as Parasite, 12 Years a Slave, and this year’s Anora. Starring Chris Pratt and Millie Bobby Brown, The Electric State is the kind of movie that seems to get longer while you’re watching it. No matter how deep into it you are — it could be the end of the first act or the second — it always feels like there’s an hour still left. On the face of it, The Electric State isn’t a particularly long movie. It taps out at around 120 minutes, which is positively merciful of the Russos, whose first gig after the global success of the three-hour-long Avengers: Endgame was Cherry, a 141-minute drama about a drug addict who robs banks to fund his habit.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Broken Rage

Broken Rage

Crime, Drama, Comedy, Action (Japanese)

The weirdest movie of the year, courtesy Takeshi Kitano; no wonder Amazon buried it

Sun, February 23 2025

We live in a world where Mr Beast's show gets more respect from Amazon Prime Video than Japanese icon Takeshi Kitano's new film.

In a recent interview, actor Rajiv Thakur admitted that audiences that have seen him as a fixture on Kapil Sharma’s comedy shows will have no idea that he played a menacing terrorist in the spectacular streaming series IC 814: The Kandahar Hijack. And those who discovered him through IC 814 wouldn’t know that he has spent years as a part of Sharma’s silly troupe. In the Venn diagram of Indian entertainment, these audiences will never intersect, even though both IC 814 and The Great Indian Kapil Show are available on Netflix. Similarly, it is possible that cinephiles familiar with Takeshi Kitano through his art-house yakuza movies, or his memorable appearance in the hyper-violent Battle Royale, will collapse in shock they are told that he was so central to the game show Takeshi’s Castle that they named it after him. Kitano gets to play with his two creative personalities — the Golden Lion-winning filmmaker and the court jester — in his latest movie, Broken Rage, which was released on Prime Video with less fanfare than what you’d find at funerals in certain cultures.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Apple Cider Vinegar S01

Apple Cider Vinegar S01

Drama, Crime (English)

What if the shadiest Shark Tank pitcher scored the most lucrative deal in the show’s history?

Fri, February 14 2025

The new Netflix mini-series goes back to the basics of dramatic storytelling, tackling themes as timeless as jealousy, betrayal, and ambition.

Both Mark Zuckerberg and the movie based on his early life, The Social Network, are referenced in the new Netflix mini-series Apple Cider Vinegar. Named after the snake oil that was being peddled online by seemingly every lifestyle influencer a few years ago, the show is inspired by the rather unbelievable story of Belle Gibson, a young Australian woman who scammed millions into subscribing to her personalised diet plans. Belle claimed that she’d beaten brain cancer by consuming clean food instead of conventional chemotherapy. The truth was that Belle was never diagnosed with cancer at all; it was the neglect that she experienced in childhood that compelled her to con the world. She’s played in the six-episode series by the wonderful Kaitlyn Dever, who rose to fame with the coming-of-age film Booksmart, and the even better Netflix series Unbelievable. In Apple Cider Vinegar, she puts on a convincing Australian accent, and finds a balance between Belle’s delusion and ambition. Abandoned by her troubled mother, Belle supposedly ran away from home at the age of 12. She gave birth to her first child when she was still a teenager, and subsequently embarked on a career as a huckster. Fuelled by a desire to be loved and accepted, she turned to social media to scratch this itch. Belle founded The Whole Pantry mobile app, through which she literally influenced terminally ill men and women into shunning traditional forms of treatment.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film The Gorge

The Gorge

Romance, Science Fiction, Thriller (English)

Miles Teller and Anya Taylor-Joy jolt Apple’s plodding sci-fi thriller to life

Fri, February 14 2025

Apple's new film relies heavily on Miles Teller and Anya Taylor-Joy's performances, but suffers from mediocre pacing and an overuse of CGI.

The Gorge is four movies in one. Some might describe this as a value-for-money proposition. But others might find it a bit all over the place. There is no doubt, however, that the film bites off more than it can chew. And in the age of snackable ‘content’, this could be construed as high praise. Directed by Scott Derrickson, a filmmaker who has routinely shown skill at elevating genre movies, The Gorge coasts by for the majority of its two-hour run-time on star-power alone. There are long stretches of plodding nonsense, yes, but the film’s biggest strength lies in its constant determination to be unpredictable — relatively speaking, at least. Miles Teller and Anya Taylor-Joy play Levi and Drasa, two snipers who are hand-picked to keep guard at watchtowers on opposite ends of a mysterious gorge. We aren’t told where the gorge is located, or what our heroes are even supposed to be guarding. In time, however, we learn that the facility is strategically located somewhere between America and Russia, and that protecting it from being discovered was one of the biggest objectives during the Cold War. Levi and Drasa have been drafted to keep watch for exactly a year, following which they’ll be replaced by two others.

Continue Reading…

Latest Reviews

Image of scene from the film Made in Korea
FCG Rating for the film Made in Korea: 26/100
Made in Korea

Romance, Drama (Tamil)

A woman from a small town in Tamil Nadu moves to South Korea — a place… (more)

Image of scene from the film Tighee
FCG Rating for the film Tighee: 74/100
Tighee

Drama (Marathi)

Swati has built a respectable life in Mumbai, but everything is unravelling. Her predatory boss exploits… (more)

Image of scene from the film Sankalp
FCG Rating for the film Sankalp: 55/100
Sankalp

Drama (Hindi)

SANKALP is a premium Indian socio-political drama that explores how power is manufactured not through elections,… (more)

Image of scene from the film Aspirants S03
Aspirants S03

Drama (Hindi)

Aspirants is a story of 3 friends - Abhilash, SK, and Guri. The story takes place… (more)