/images/members/ROHANNAHAAR221.jpg

Rohan Naahar

The Indian Express and Secretary FCG

Rohan Naahar is based out of New Delhi, India, and has been reviewing films and television shows for over a decade. He has written for the Hindustan Times and currently writes for the Indian Express.

All reviews by Rohan Naahar

Image of scene from the film Tehran

Tehran

Action, Thriller (Hindi)

John Abraham’s geopolitical thriller isn’t smarter than a fifth grader, no matter how many newspapers it reads

Sat, August 23 2025

John Abraham has perfected the art of remaining apolitical, even when he's starring in geopolitical thrillers such as Tehran.

There is a scam in Punjab that Rajkumar Hirani would’ve heard about while researching Dunki. Shady travel agents are charging crores from desperate (and mostly uneducated) Indians with the promise of arranging safe passage to the American state of Georgia. The scam? These poor men are being sent to the country of Georgia instead. In most cases, they’ve sold off family land, quit their jobs, and exhausted their entire life savings; some of them even have wives and children with them. All to be sent to the land of khachapuri. To put it simply, there are a bunch of people from Bathinda knocking about in the Caucasus right now. Anyway, the folks who made the new John Abraham film Tehran are no smarter. The movie opens with a voiceover in which we are told about an operation carried out by Iran in 2012, where Israeli diplomats were targeted in Thailand, India, and Georgia. They meant the country. But the map that the movie shows instead is that of the US state.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Saare Jahan Se Accha

Saare Jahan Se Accha

Drama (Hindi)

Netflix sabotages Suhail Nayyar’s performance, humiliates Tillotama Shome by editing her scenes out

Sat, August 23 2025

Netflix's new spy drama, Saare Jahan Se Accha, feels like it has been edited by Edward Scissorhands; it's tantamount to self-sabotage. Poor Tillotama Shome, Sunny Hinduja, and Suhail Nayyar are done particularly dirty.

The new Netflix series Saare Jahan Se Accha begins with Pratik Gandhi’s character being posted to the R&AW’s Islamabad station, and it ends with him foiling a major nuclear operation and blowing things up real good. All of this happens in six episodes of roughly 45 minutes each. In these six episodes, we are introduced to several characters — field agents, a journalist, the chief of the ISI; even Indira Gandhi drops by. Most of these characters, including the protagonist’s wife, is introduced with enough fanfare to suggest that they are going to be important to the plot. Some of them are, most aren’t. But you can never shake the feeling that Saare Jahan Se Accha was stripped to the bone after somebody interfered with either the scripts or the first assembly. Nearly everybody in the cast suffers, not to mention the show itself. But nobody is done quite so dirty as Tillotama Shome.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Night Always Comes

Night Always Comes

Thriller, Drama, Crime (English)

Vanessa Kirby wouldn’t look like a mess even if she tried, and this hurts her Netflix thriller

Wed, August 20 2025

A handsomely manicured movie about the grimy realities of the working class, Vanessa Kirby's new thriller needed to be nastier.

It’s perhaps no coincidence that Julia Fox has a cameo in Night Always Comes, the new thriller on Netflix starring Vanessa Kirby. Modelled on the movies of the Safdie brothers, Night Always Comes stares more than just a structure with Uncut Gems, in which Fox played a memorable cameo. That ticking timebomb thriller followed a desperate New York jeweller weaponising his gambling addiction in a breakneck attempt to gather cash. It was a movie that a third-act basketball match into a life-and-death scenario. In Night Always Comes, Kirby plays a working class woman staring at sure-shot eviction if she isn’t able to come up with a $25,000 deposit in one night.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Fixed

Fixed

Animation, Comedy (English)

Utterly deranged, it’s perhaps the only cartoon film that could realistically be banned by the CBFC

Sat, August 16 2025

From the legendary animator Genndy Tartakovsky, the man behind childhood classics such as Dexter's Laboratory and Samurai Jack, comes a cartoon movie that could realistically be banned by the CBFC.

Animation hall-of-famer Genndy Tartakovsky latest film, Fixed, was originally set for a theatrical release, but was offloaded by Warner Bros. during a cost-cutting drive. While movies such as Coyote vs. Acme and Batgirl — both were dealt similar blows — remain sight unseen, it’s easy to imagine why the studio would’ve wanted to wash the scent of Fixed off of itself. A wiser move would’ve been to bury it in the backyard. Painfully unfunny, the train wreck of a movie feels interminable at even 80 minutes long; it’s crude, cringe, and filled with juvenile dialogue that makes you feel like you’re eavesdropping on a group of 12-year-old boys at the playground.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Weapons

Weapons

Horror, Mystery (English)

Indian directors are more terrified of making meaningful horror movies than you are of watching them

Sat, August 16 2025

There is a grave idea at the core of Weapons: what is worse; the grief of losing a loved one to a tragedy, or the guilt of having to resume regular life after some time has passed?

Can a society that is terrified of confronting the evil at its core ever produce a single subversive piece of art? Certainly, Indian cinema is still taking baby steps when it comes to addressing our immorality; here, a movie about caste discrimination is a movie about caste discrimination, a movie about corporate greed is a movie about corporate greed, a movie about political corruption is a movie about political corruption. But it will be a while before our cinema is empowered to subvert. It will be a while before someone makes a gothic horror about crimes against women, or a creature feature about the Kashmir issue. It will be a while before we get a homegrown version of Barbarian director Zach Cregger’s brilliant new film, Weapons.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Materialists

Materialists

Romance, Drama, Comedy (English)

Dakota Johnson plays the world’s biggest red flag in Celine Song’s misguided rom-com; she should be banned from dating anybody

Wed, August 13 2025

Writer-director Celine Song's Materialists can't distance itself from the objectively concerning worldview of its protagonist, played by Dakota Johnson.

The most distressing observation that Materialists makes about modern romance is that not much has changed since Elizabeth Bennet went on a quest to find a ‘single man in possession of a good fortune’ back in the 1800s. The business of marriage is still just that: a business, a financially motivated arrangement that many pretend is something purer. They do this to delude themselves into thinking that they aren’t as superficial as the sort of people they enjoy passing judgement at. In writer-director Celine Song’s highly anticipated second film, Dakota Johnson plays a rom-com version of Seema Taparia, a matchmaker who weighs her client’s ‘criteria’ and connects them with potential life partners with the dispassion of someone tying two shoelaces together.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Sitaare Zameen Par

Sitaare Zameen Par

Comedy, Drama (Hindi)

If you need Aamir Khan to manipulate you into being a good person, maybe you’re beyond redemption

Sat, August 9 2025

Sitaare Zameen Par asks its audience to get behind a particularly nasty man before preaching to them about things that, truth be told, they should already know. Sure, many might not, but it's probably going to take more than an Aamir Khan to convert them.

While watching any film, it is important to understand who the target audience is, especially Hindi movies, which are often slotted into rigid categories. It’s theoretically possible for a 65-year-old ‘tirth yatri’ from Rithala to enjoy the fourth Twilight movie on a bus to Amarnath, but, you’d agree that they probably wouldn’t care much for shiny vampires and their politics. The Twilight movies are aimed at teenage girls, just as Aamir Khan’s Sitaare Zameen Par is targeted at the sort of folks for whom kindness doesn’t come naturally. Khan plays their surrogate in the film, directed by RS Prasanna and based on the Spanish-language hit Campeones. It’s the star’s second remake in a row, after the poorly received Laal Singh Chaddha from a couple of years ago.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Dhadak 2

Dhadak 2

Romance, Drama (Hindi)

Shazia Iqbal destroys ancient Bollywood Dharma in the best Karan Johar production since Jigra

Thu, August 7 2025

It's an unusual comparison to make, but Shazia Iqbal's Dhadak 2 has more in common with Joaquin Phoenix's billion-dollar-grossing Joker movie than you'd imagine.

Something that Quentin Tarantino said recently rings true for director Shazia Iqbal’s Dhadak 2. In an interview, he explained why he admires the controversial blockbuster film Joker, despite the divisive reactions that it opened to. Tarantino said that the movie pulled off ‘subversion on a massive level’, when it got audiences across the globe to root for a madman to shoot a celebrity in the face on live TV. These were all civilised people, Tarantino said. And yet, for around 10 minutes, they were hungry for blood. It’s an unusual comparison to make, but Dhadak 2 has more in common with a billion-dollar-grossing Hollywood movie than you’d imagine. In an alternate universe, Siddhant Chaturvedi’s character in the film, a Dalit man named Neelesh, could have very easily turned into a vengeful anarchist.

Continue Reading…

Latest Reviews

Image of scene from the film Param Sundari
FCG Rating for the film
Param Sundari

Romance, Drama, Comedy (Hindi)

In Kerala's picturesque backwaters, a North Indian and South Indian find unexpected love. Their cultural differences… (more)

Image of scene from the film Hridayapoorvam
FCG Rating for the film
Hridayapoorvam

Romance, Comedy, Drama, Family (Malayalam)

Sandeep, a middle-aged bachelor who recently got a heart transplant, travels to Pune to attend the… (more)

Image of scene from the film The Chronicles of the 4.5 Gang
The Chronicles of the 4.5 Gang

Comedy, Crime (Malayalam)

It follows four slum-dwelling youngsters and a midget who plan to run their neighbourhood's temple festival,… (more)

Image of scene from the film The Roses
FCG Rating for the film
The Roses

Comedy, Drama (English)

Life seems easy for picture-perfect couple Ivy and Theo: successful careers, a loving marriage, great kids.… (more)