/images/members/RAHUL DESAI.jpg

Rahul Desai

The Hollywood Reporter India

A film critic and columnist, Rahul Desai writes for The Hollywood Reporter India and OTTPlay. In his spare time, he runs a weekly movie podcast called IIF.

All reviews by Rahul Desai

Image of scene from the film Anuja

Anuja

Drama (English)

Classic Oscar Bait, Little Substance

Fri, February 7 2025

The Oscar-nominated live action short film greedily panders to the western gaze.

On paper, Anuja is a noble project. It’s made in association with Salaam Baalak Trust, a Delhi-based non-profit organisation that supports street kids. It stars one of its children, Sajda Pathan, as a gifted nine-year-old garment factory worker who is conflicted between earning a livelihood and getting an education. It’s an Indian American production. It is backed by diaspora-global celebrities like Mindy Kaling, Priyanka Chopra Jonas and Guneet Monga Kapoor. And it’s about spirited orphans in a big bad world. Which is to say: Anuja is so noble that it’s only a project. At its best, it’s a creative presentation slide. At its worst, it’s less of a short film and more of a look-poor-people-hungry-people aesthetic. It brings back memories of the famous and infamous Slumdog Millionaire (2008) — and not in a good way.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Sweet Dreams

Sweet Dreams

Romance, Drama (Hindi)

A Promising Love Story Ruined By Instagram Film-making

Fri, January 24 2025

The over-designed romcom, starring Amol Parashar and Mithila Palkar, wastes a dreamy premise

Sweet Dreams has a sweet premise. It begins with a J.R.R. Tolkien quote, setting the stage for a fantasy-coded romcom. And it opens with a dreamy date between a flirty Diya (Mithila Palkar) and the cool Kennith (Amol Parashar) at a cafe. We soon learn that this is a shared dream between two strangers — a recurring habit for both — leading completely different lives. Kennith, an influencer and recycle artist, is newly single and he speaks to his psychiatrist (Faye D’Souza; a surprise-but-meek cameo) about this mysterious girl he keeps meeting in his dreams. He’s convinced she exists. Diya, a career drifter who writes and sings, is in an autopilot relationship with Ishant (Meiyang Chang); she, too, is baffled by how real and tangible her dreams feel. The film follows their attempts to find each other and (re)unite.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Sky Force

Sky Force

Action, Thriller (Hindi)

Akshay Kumar Hijacks A One-way Flight To Nowhere

Fri, January 24 2025

Inspired by the unique story of two Indian Air Force (IAF) officers, ‘Sky Force’ succumbs to the fictions of today

There are two ways to be disappointed with Sky Force. One, through the lens of its creators. Up until now, the production company Maddock Films — on a high following the dizzying success of its horror-comedy multiverse — has managed to innovate and stay interesting without conforming to mass trends and jingoistic patterns. It’s worth noting that Sky Force is its first real foray into this zone. But within the contours of the herd-mentality move, it tries something different. It chooses to dramatise a real-life story that’s equal parts war movie and investigative drama.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film A Real Pain

A Real Pain

Comedy, Drama (English)

(Written for OTT Play)

The Art, & Heart, Of Suffering

Sat, January 18 2025

Jesse Eisenberg’s film, featuring a great Kieran Culkin performance, lives in the nuances of depression.

A Real Pain, starring Eisenberg and Kieran Culkin as cousins, is exactly the kind of film you imagine if Eisenberg and Culkin played cousins. It’s funny, awkward, edgy, poignant, light, chatty, alert, minor-key and Sundancey (an adjective for the brand of tragicomic American quirk that the snowy festival loves to showcase). There are echoes of the uptight mom and no-filter teen from the actor’s directorial debut, When You Finish Saving The World, in the uptight David (Eisenberg) and the free-spirited-but-troubled Benji (Culkin). Family man David and drifter Benji head to Poland to process their Jewish heritage through a guided Holocaust tour and, more importantly, visit their late camp-survivor grandmother’s childhood home. As in most movies, it’s the interiority of the oddball journey that matters.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Emergency

Emergency

Drama (Hindi)

Kangana Ranaut Places the Hindi Historical Under Curfew

Sat, January 18 2025

The 147-minute Indira Gandhi biopic is all irony and no self-awareness

In Emergency, Kangana Ranaut plays Indira Gandhi who plays Kangana Ranaut. Let me explain. Ranaut performs as the former Prime Minister of India when the politician is flawed, cruel, paranoid, a nepotism hire, power-hungry, guilty, and the mother of Sanjay Gandhi. Her voice becomes high-pitched, uneven and shaky in these parts. But Indira Gandhi seems to perform as Ranaut when the woman is defiant, patriotic, headstrong, resilient, reverential towards the opposition (Janata Party leaders Jayaprakash Narayan and Atal Bihari Vajpayee), and the mother of the nation. Her voice becomes firm, furious and confident in these parts.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Paatal Lok S02

Paatal Lok S02

Crime, Drama (Hindi)

A World-Class Sequel Well Worth the Wait

Sat, January 18 2025

Jaideep Ahlawat leads a series that trades instant gratification for a slow-burning cultural audit.

A beloved political leader from Nagaland is found brutally murdered in Delhi. The timing is dubious. It’s on the eve of a landmark business summit between the ‘mainland’ and the ‘margins’: The central government is primed to invest thousands of crores into the development and tourism sector of Nagaland. Protests break out in Kohima; conflicts erupt between the slain man’s loyalists and the rebel factions against this soul-selling deal. The case is given to ACP Imran Ansari (Ishwak Singh), fresh from topping his IPS batch. The optics are irresistible: A Muslim officer must lead an investigation into the killing of an unprotected guest — an Indian outsider — in the capital. If things go wrong, Ansari is a readymade scapegoat. Meanwhile, jaded protagonist and Ansari’s ex-boss Hathi Ram Chaudhary (Jaideep Ahlawat) continues to bat in the minor league. He flirts with the idea of quitting, but an inconspicuous case of a missing husband puts him on a collision course with the high-profile investigation. Most officers are expected to do their job, but Hathi Ram is destined to do his duty.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Azaad

Azaad

Drama, Action (Hindi)

Dear Bollywood, Stop Horsing Around

Sat, January 18 2025

Abhishek Kapoor’s period actioner is a dull and broken spectacle

Azaad is fit, handsome, muscular and agile. His flowy hair is the talk of the town. He plays hard to get. He looks away and sighs if he isn’t interested. He loves his whisky neat — and straight from the bottle. He sits on a bed when he’s tired. He loses his appetite when he’s sad; he eats only if his food is spiked with alcohol. He has expensive taste. He farts in a closed room. He isn’t afraid to defy outdated perceptions of masculinity: his eyes go glassy when he gets a whiff of his late companion’s scent from a turban. He remembers the day they met and necked. He remembers their adolescent-love song together: “Ab jeene ki koi wajah toh hai” (I now have a reason to live). He isn’t ashamed of weeping. He likes dancing. He loves racing, too. Azaad is an expressive action hero; this film is his big-budget launch vehicle. There’s only one problem though: Azaad is a horse.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film The Roshans

The Roshans

Documentary (Hindi)

When Nonfiction Behaves Like Fiction

Sat, January 18 2025

The Netflix docu-series on the Roshan family is equal parts hollow and comforting.

You’ve heard of “Prestige TV”: the term for quality long-form film-making, cinematic production values, A-list acting and complex screenwriting. But in the Netflix non-fiction universe, Prestige TV is a far more literal term. It stands for self-produced and self-congratulatory celebrity documentaries with infinite access that explore the sanitised prestige of fame. The symptoms: prestigious movie and music legacies, prestigious anecdotes, prestigious lives, prestigious prestige. You get the gist. Or maybe you didn’t. Think of the line from Christopher Nolan’s The Prestige (2006): “Making something disappear isn’t enough, you have to bring it back”. This hagiographic genre is all about bringing things back. Some call it the magic of movies, others call it a nostalgia grab.

Continue Reading…

Latest Reviews

Image of scene from the film Dhurandhar: The Revenge
FCG Rating for the film Dhurandhar: The Revenge: 53/100
Dhurandhar: The Revenge

Action, Crime, Thriller (Hindi)

As rival gangs, corrupt officials and a ruthless Major Iqbal close in, Hamza's mission for his… (more)

Image of scene from the film Chiraiya
FCG Rating for the film Chiraiya: 43/100
Chiraiya

Drama (Hindi)

Kamlesh's world as a devoted wife and daughter-in-law shatters when her new sister-in-law confides a disturbing… (more)

Image of scene from the film Jazz City
Jazz City

(Bengali)

Set in 1971 Calcutta, a jazz club becomes the backdrop for a revolutionary awakening as music… (more)

Image of scene from the film Aadu 3
Aadu 3

Comedy, Fantasy (Malayalam)

Shaji Pappan and Co. opens a Pandora's box of reincarnations and multiple timelines leading to… (more)