3561 Reviews ● 1073 Films ● 56 Top Critics & Growing

/images/members/RAHUL DESAI.jpg

Rahul Desai

The Hollywood Reporter India

A film critic and columnist, Rahul Desai writes for The Hollywood Reporter India and OTT Play. In his spare time, he runs a weekly movie podcast called IIF.

All reviews by Rahul Desai

Image of scene from the film Perfect Family
Cast:Neha Dhupia, Manoj Pahwa, Seema Pahwa, Gulshan Devaiah, Girija Oak, Kaveri Seth, Hirva Samir Trivedi

Perfect Family

Family, Drama (Hindi)

A Therapeutic, Well-Acted Portrait of Dysfunctional Familyhood

Wed, December 3 2025

The 8-episode drama, streaming on YouTube, is imperfect but compelling enough to subvert a preachy genre

If you’ve watched enough modern Hindi socials over the years, chances are you’re well-acquainted with its red flags. Especially if the themes sound like hashtags: #DysfunctionalFamily, #Therapy, #MentalHealth, #NobodyIsPerfect, #SeekHelp. The preachiness aside, the stories are often designed to offer solutions to everything short of death (or sometimes even that). If not solutions, then righteous advice at the very least. It’s why I both loved and hated Dil Dhadakne Do (and a show like Made In Heaven); the staging of dysfunctionality and cultural quirks are the fun parts, but there’s always a sense that nothing is beyond repair. Every ‘condition’ is curable. The great thing about Perfect Family is that, over 8 fairly long episodes, it puts itself in a position to humanise the hashtags more than feature-length movies do. Its imperfections have character, and even if the intent is tethered to a message of change and higher wisdom, the show feels like more of a journey than a destination. Which is precisely the anatomy of being “fixed” these days; it’s a process with no beginning and ending.

Continue Reading…


Image of scene from the film Kaisi Ye Paheli
Director:Ananyabrata Chakravorty
Cast:Sukant Goel, Sadhana Singh, Rajit Kapoor, Chittaranjan Giri, Rahul Nawach Mukhia, Nishu Dikshit, Rinchen Sherpa, Bindhiya Dhamala, Rajendra Maskey, Ujjaini Deb
Writer:Ananyabrata Chakravorty

Kaisi Ye Paheli

Mystery, Thriller (Hindi)

Technical Glitches Mar A Good One-Liner

Sat, November 29 2025

Ananyabrata Chakravorty’s small-town whodunnit has the ideas, but fails to contain its excitement

Conceptually, Kaisi Ye Paheli goes for broke. The 95-minute independent film, written and directed by Ananyabrata Chakravorty, wears the cloak of yet another small-town whodunnit. There’s a death in misty Kalimpong; sullen cop Uttam (Sukant Goel) and his boss, Tamang (Chittaranjan Giri), are flummoxed by the details: a religious girl poisoned by a holy sweet? The theatrical Bondo (Rajit Kapur, always) is summoned from Kolkata by the powers that be; the senior sleuth has a direct line to “Didi,” and behaves like he’s an amalgamation of Byomkesh Bakshi and Feluda in his head. Meanwhile, Uttam’s home situation is complicated — he resents his widowed mother (Sadhana Singh) for various reasons, not least because she constantly recalls their past life and late husband. The mother-son bond is strained, she aches for his attention, so it’s amusing when Tamang and team unofficially recruit her to be part of the investigation because of her passion for Bengali detective novels. Uttam’s colleagues confide in her like sons in their downtime; it’s a quirky touch without the energy of a quirky touch.

Continue Reading…


Image of scene from the film Tere Ishk Mein
Director:Aanand L. Rai
Cast:Dhanush, Kriti Sanon, Priyanshu Painyuli, Prakash Raj, Sushil Dahiya
Writer:Himanshu Sharma, Neeraj Yadav

Tere Ishk Mein

Romance, Drama, Action (Hindi)

When ‘Raanjhanaa’ and ‘Animal’ Enter A Toxic Relationship

Sat, November 29 2025

Starring Dhanush and Kriti Sanon, Aanand L. Rai’s latest monument to the madness of love is very difficult to sit through.

Animal’s Rannvijay, Kabir Singh’s Kabir, Rockstar’s Jordan, Tamasha’s Ved and Haseen Dillruba’s Rishu walk into a bar. There is no punchline here, because they are no joke. They participate in a victimhood-measuring contest. Rannvijay declares he had to sleep with a female agent knowing who she was and cheated on his wife to make his dad proud; it was very difficult. Kabir claims he slapped a girl to make her love his alpha masculinity; it was very hard. Jordan says he quotes Rumi and chose to meet his dead soulmate in a field beyond; it wasn’t easy. Ved claims his girlfriend fixed him by rejecting his alter-ego; it was terrible. Rishu declares he chopped off his hand to be with his bad-boy-craving wife; it’s been a sacrifice. In walks Tere Ishk Mein’s Shankar, who lights a cigarette and scoffs at them all.

Continue Reading…


Image of scene from the film Gustaakh Ishq
Director:Vibhu Puri
Cast:Naseeruddin Shah, Vijay Varma, Fatima Sana Shaikh, Sharib Hashmi, Natasha Rastogi, Rohan Verma, Lilliput (M. M. Faruqui), Shashi Bhushan, Jaya Bhattacharya, Samiksha Tripathi
Writer:Vibhu Puri

Gustaakh Ishq

Romance, Drama (Hindi)

Let There Be Poetry

Sat, November 29 2025

Vibhu Puri’s metrical film pays ode to Sanjay Leela Bhansali, but also becomes its own treaty on the preservation of love and language

The test of an effective Hindi film these days is the post-screening afterglow. If it’s a loud historical, the chaotic traffic and fumes outside feel like a relief. If it’s a button-pushing social thriller, some walk out with big chests and a renewed passion to blame someone. If it’s a patriotic biopic, there might be wet eyes and a desire to be very Indian. If it’s a love story, men stride out with an inflated sense of self-worth, corny grins and cloud-nine-sized delusions. At different points in life, I’ve been guilty of doing all of the above. Add Gustaakh Ishq to the list, a period drama about poets and lovers that’s so immersive and committed to its setting that I was overcome by an urge to speak in chaste Urdu and rhyme idioms with emotions. The cab driver did not appreciate my use of “qaatil” to describe the waiting time. He sped away the second I started waxing lyrical about English being a flight and Urdu being the nest we come home to.

Continue Reading…


Image of scene from the film Zootopia 2
Director:Jared Bush, Byron Howard
Cast:Ginnifer Goodwin, Jason Bateman, Ke Huy Quan, Fortune Feimster, Andy Samberg, David Strathairn, Idris Elba, Shakira, Patrick Warburton, Quinta Brunson
Writer:Jared Bush

Zootopia 2

Animation, Family, Comedy, Adventure, Mystery (English)

(Written for OTT Play)

The Snaky Path To Greatness

Fri, November 28 2025

Blends animal puns, political fables and sly humour to attempt the near-impossible — giving snakes the redemption arc history denied them.

Of all the Disney movies over the years with PG-13 racial metaphors and diversity parables, Zootopia 2 faces the most uphill battle there ever was. For it takes on the task of doing the near-impossible: the destigmatisation of Snakes. The fear and distrust of this reptile is so historically and genetically entrenched in human systems that the real-world subtext is almost secondary. In Zootopia 2, the unlikely police pairing of hyper-rabbit Judy Hopps and red fox Nick Wilde try their darndest to unscramble snake propaganda — a pit viper named Gary De’Snake emerges in the mainland, and everyone is terrorised. Except Judy, who trusts that the snake is the good guy whose ‘people’ have been maligned by the ruling family of lynxes. Gary wants to prove that the land was theirs to begin with (duh), and the patent was stolen by the sly lynxes. History students, unite.

Continue Reading…


Image of scene from the film Mastiii 4
Director:Milap Zaveri
Cast:Riteish Deshmukh, Vivek Oberoi, Aftab Shivdasani, Ruhi Singh, Shreya Sharma, Elnaaz Norouzi, Tusshar Kapoor, Shaad Randhawa, Nishant Malkani, Arshad Warsi
Writer:Milap Zaveri, Farrukh Dhondy

Mastiii 4

Comedy (Hindi)

Eternal Sunshine of the Stunted Male Mind

Fri, November 21 2025

Milap Zaveri’s latest plays out like a prudish porn fantasy parading as an unwatchable sex comedy.

It’s only noon and I’ve already had three showers today. Under normal circumstances, I’d say it’s because I had to step out in the morning and Mumbai’s AQI is beyond redemption. Under normal circumstances, that’s a perfectly valid reason. But these are extraordinary circumstances. I stepped out to watch a morning show of Mastiii 4, a cinematic pollutant so noxious that I’ve been frantically trying to wash off its fumes after reaching home. Say what you may about a Milap Zaveri film, but it works wonders for my personal hygiene.

Continue Reading…


Image of scene from the film 120 Bahadur
Director:Razneesh Ghai
Cast:Farhan Akhtar, Raashii Khanna, Sparsh Walia, Ankit Siwach, Vivan Bhatena, Dhanveer Singh, Brijesh Karanwal, Sahib Verma, Eijaz Khan, Ajinkya Deo

120 Bahadur

Action, War (Hindi)

The Battle is Lost in Farhan Akhtar's Historical Drama

Fri, November 21 2025

Starring Farhan Akhtar, the historical drama set during the 1962 Sino-Indian war is ambushed by its own mediocrity.

You want to believe 120 Bahadur is a different historical drama. It’s from the makers of Lakshya (2004). The enemy is not Pakistan. It’s inspired by a passage of the 1962 Sino-Indian war. The optics speak to a more modern movement of resistance. The regiment in question is made up almost entirely of the Ahir community, a telling choice in the aftermath of the Indian farmers’ protest. The landscape is Ladakh. The film even addresses that there were doubts about the authenticity of the fabled Battle of Rezang La, where 120 Indian soldiers are said to have defended a pass against more than 3000 Chinese soldiers; both countries had their own versions. You also want to believe it knows the distinction between patriotism and jingoism. You just want to believe.

Continue Reading…


Image of scene from the film The Family Man 3
Cast:Manoj Bajpayee, Priyamani, Vedant Sinha, Ashlesha Thakur, Darshan Kumaar, Jaideep Ahlawat, Nimrat Kaur

The Family Man 3

Drama, Action & Adventure (Hindi)

A Dip In Form, But Good Enough

Fri, November 21 2025

Season 3 of the homegrown spy thriller has its moments, but there are signs of narrative gentrification

A high-profile summit between Delhi and North-East India — the ‘mainland’ and the ‘margins’ — is around the corner. Nagaland is the sensitive face of this summit. The region is divided between rebel factions who distrust the centre and older statesmen who bat for peace and integration. A veteran leader is killed. Officers from outside arrive to lead an uncertain investigation featuring political strife, local divides, drug dealers, foreign forces, covert business interests, historical trauma, traitors, scapegoats and shifting loyalties. A secondary character dies, making it personal for the grief-stricken protagonist; his allegiances are questioned, and he is suspended. There is a mole in the midst. A little orphan searches for belonging. A conspiracy unfolds beyond borders and within governments. Our hero in a dysfunctional marriage must clear his name without compromising on his moral fibre. But enough about Season 2 of Paatal Lok.

Continue Reading…


Latest Reviews

Image of scene from the film Main Vaapas Aaunga
FCG Rating for the film Main Vaapas Aaunga: 65/100
Main Vaapas Aaunga

Romance, Drama (Hindi)

An elderly man remains haunted by a childhood romance and memories of love lost during the… (more)

Image of scene from the film Maa Inti Bangaaram
FCG Rating for the film Maa Inti Bangaaram: 63/100
Maa Inti Bangaaram

Action, Thriller, Drama (Telugu)

Through both her moments of fear and bravery, a woman discovers that embracing her vulnerabilities is… (more)

Image of scene from the film Cocktail 2
FCG Rating for the film Cocktail 2: 42/100
Cocktail 2

Romance, Comedy (Hindi)

After a decade together, Diya and Kunal's relationship is shaken when Ally, an old friend, re-enters… (more)

Image of scene from the film Nooru Sami
FCG Rating for the film Nooru Sami: 63/100
Nooru Sami

Drama, Family (Tamil)

Selvi, a widowed mother, devotes her life to raising her two sons in a conservative village.… (more)