/images/members/RAHUL DESAI.jpg

Rahul Desai

The Hollywood Reporter India

A film critic and columnist, Rahul Desai writes for The Hollywood Reporter India and OTTPlay. In his spare time, he runs a weekly movie podcast called IIF.

All reviews by Rahul Desai

Image of scene from the film Vash Level 2

Vash Level 2

Thriller, Horror (Gujarati)

Fear and Loathing in Modern Gujarat

Thu, August 28 2025

This sequel to the Gujarati horror film 'Vash' is a potent blend of craft and commentary

A pack of teenage schoolgirls wreak havoc across a city. They overpower everyone and everything in sight, seemingly possessed by superhuman strength and violent desire. The attack is visceral and unstructured, like the beginning of a dance rehearsal gone wrong. Their school uniforms become a symbol of danger. The police are clueless; the parents are terrified. The setting is notoriously sexist, so the sight of them spreading chaos is oddly empowering. In most movies, it would be. But Vash Level 2 is not most movies. The sequel to Vash (2023), Krishnadev Yagnik’s national award-winning supernatural thriller that was remade as Shaitaan (2024) in Hindi, our simplistic perception of female empowerment is thrown out of the window (or, well, off a terrace). Even their “rebellion” is defined by subservience; their agency is shaped by the crippling lack of one. For they are actually controlled by a sinister male stranger (Hiten Kumar) who laced their lunch with black-magic dust. The rampage is happening against the girls’ wishes; their bodies are weaponised but their minds are scared. Most of them attack hawkers, motorists and street-dwellers and bash their heads in, regardless of gender or status. The smash-the-patriarchy allegory unfolds like a cruel joke. The brainwashing and societal-conditioning metaphors unfold like punchlines.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Momo Deal

Momo Deal

(Hindi)

A Sweet and Direct Seance About Grief

Fri, August 22 2025

The 13-minute film revolves around a conversation between a young man and his dead best friend

Momo Deal opens with the voice of a dead girl at her funeral. Except it’s quirky. This young woman, Mahima (Anushka Kaushik), is reading out her own wishlist for the funeral — the way any manic-pixie hall of famer like Jab We Met’s Geet might (we learn that her favourite song is “Tumse hi”) to lighten the mood. One zoom-out of the camera reveals that none of Mahima’s wishes have been followed, especially the one that demands her best friend Naman (Akashdeep Arora) to weep loudly at the front. Naman is instead numb. His deadpan face suggests he’s an action hero who can’t act, but he’s something more common: an Indian man who can’t — or won’t — express himself. He refuses to cry. Dheeraj Jindal’s 13-minute short then features a late-night conversation between Naman and the ghost of his newly-deceased bestie. They walk the streets of their hometown, Jaipur, and exchange difficult emotions.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Weapons

Weapons

Horror, Mystery (English)

(Written for OTT Play)

The Adolescence Of Horror

Thu, August 14 2025

Zach Cregger's Weapons appeals to our inherent quest for answers — for an endgame — from a horror film, and delights in the journey rather than the destination.

Weapons opens and closes with a kid’s voiceover, but the anonymity of this narrator kind of ties into the film’s thematic fluidity. As viewers, we are simply wired to look for social cues, for hints and allegories. Weapons knows this and toys with our instincts. The meaning — or lack of it — lies in the eyes of the beholder. The horror in the film becomes anything we want it to be. For some, it could be a self-aware take on community trauma and urban isolation. For some, it could be a nifty riff on our biases about witchcraft and creepy relatives. For some, it could be a naughty satire on our perception of true-crime and supernatural stories. For some, it’s the wicked title, where the emotional ‘weaponisation’ of an entire town on edge prevents them from looking in the most obvious places. The twist — of a fragile outsider arriving to cast a voodoo over victims and turn them into literal weapons — is an entertaining rendition of this simple idea.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Andhera

Andhera

Drama, Mystery (Hindi)

Will The Real Darkness Please Stand Up?

Thu, August 14 2025

The 8-episode horror show trades mental health metaphors for paranormal inactivity.

Cold on the heels of Mandala Murders, Andhera (“darkness”) is yet another supernatural thriller that ends up becoming a cautionary tale on narrative ambition. This genre of horror is so shapeless that, if the theme isn’t as culturally focused as a Khauf or even an Asur, it tends to spiral into several directions without doing justice to any. It’s like a batsman who keeps swinging big — regardless of the match situation — under the pretext of “intent”. It doesn’t help that Andhera is one of the longest Hindi shows of the year. Or perhaps its 8 episodes feel longer because the world-building just never stops building; it’s not a good sign when a central character says “we were wrong all along” in the penultimate episode. It’s obvious that I’ve run out of patience because I usually don’t hit the ground running with criticism in the opening paragraph. I like some suspense and world-building too. But life is short and, if the title is anything to go by, I’m one typo away from reviewing the suburb I live in (Andheri).

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film War 2

War 2

Action, Adventure, Thriller (Hindi)

Two Heroes, No Spectacle, No Debacle

Thu, August 14 2025

Ayan Mukerji’s restlessly-mounted action thriller lacks both method and madness

On (very expensive) paper, War 2 continues the trademarks of the YRF Spy Universe. The globe-trotting reaches a point where it’s just showing off: Japan, Spain, Italy, Abu Dhabi, Switzerland, probably Siberia. Characters dare not meet in a non-exotic (or local) landscape; conversations that could be emails happen in ice caves too. The set-pieces feature cobblestoned car chases, a snowy samurai slaughterhouse (with two expressive wolves), physics-mocking airplane action, speeding train accidents, ships and speedboats on F1 tracks, even cable cars. I’m almost afraid to see the passports of the production crew. There’s plenty of homoerotic tension parading as male friendship (level: one rod pierces two bodies), a dance-off, furtive glances above the clouds, tragic lines like “I couldn’t belong to anybody — not even my country — after you”.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Court Kacheri

Court Kacheri

Comedy, Drama (Hindi)

A Performative TVF Dramedy That Loses A Case to Itself

Wed, August 13 2025

Starring Pawan Malhotra and Ashish Verma, the 5-episode TVF series resembles a sweet-talking man who becomes a red flag

Court Kacheri does a lot right for its first three (out of five) episodes. It unfolds as a legal dramedy that questions its own identity. The young protagonist, Param (Ashish Verma), is a reluctant second-generation lawyer by virtue of being the son of a popular senior advocate, Harish Mathur (Pawan Malhotra). Param detests the profession — he’s seen his dad entertain all kinds of criminals, shady clients and corrupt politicians over the years. All he wants to do is leave for either Dubai or Canada, but a Police Clearance Certificate (PCC) becomes a conflict after he’s caught in a fake-marksheet scam. Basically, he’s a nepo-baby who can’t handle the pressure of legacy. The outsider, Suraj (Puneet Batra), is Harish’s loyal assistant. Unlike Param, he wishes he was his mentor’s son with silver-spoon privileges; his passion for law sees him hustle to start a secret practice with a friend (Amarjeet Singh) behind Harish’s back. In short, there’s a toxic patriarch and two boys desperate to escape his shadow and become their own men.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Saare Jahan Se Accha

Saare Jahan Se Accha

Drama (Hindi)

Pratik Gandhi's Espionage Drama Is Lost In Translation

Wed, August 13 2025

The six-episode spy thriller is compromised by its own mixed identity

Just like the Bhagat Singh story became a first-come-first-serve race for Bollywood historicals in the early 2000s, the Bangladesh Liberation War became the medium to stage Indian patriotism a few years ago. This month marks the beginning of a new period device for Hindi productions: the spymaster story. The recent Salaakar did its clumsiest best to fictionalise the career of India’s National Security Advisor (NSA) Ajit Doval. The role of an intelligence agent who sabotages Pakistan’s covert mission to go nuclear in the 1970s is reduced to a series of tacky espionage cliches and cultural stereotypes. It even uses two timelines to double the sense of victory.

Continue Reading…

Image of scene from the film Wednesday S02 Part 1

Wednesday S02 Part 1

Sci-Fi & Fantasy, Mystery, Comedy (English)

(Written for OTT Play)

Thank God It’s (Finally) Friday

Sat, August 9 2025

Not the most satisfying watch, especially because the belated comeback feels like a cash-grabbing dash to reproduce more rather than course-correcting a greedy formula.

Wednesday Season 2 (Part 1: the first four episodes) arrives nearly three years after the goth-deadpan teenager and her morbid adventures became the most watched Netflix show of all time. Immortalised (not a term these characters are fond of) by actress Jenna Ortega, a death-coded Wednesday Addams saved her unmerry school of outcasts, the Nevermore Academy, by cracking a murder mystery and discovering that the boy she liked is a serial-killing monster puppeted by a psychopathic botany teacher. Season 2 takes an interesting route, more or less writing the new-age popularity of the series into its storyline. It opens with a Sixth-Sense-weds-Unbreakable tribute — extra marks for that — to show that Wednesday has learnt to control her psychic powers. She returns to Nevermore for the Fall semester. Except now she’s famous — and it annoys the hell out of her. Everyone knows her, and as an aspiring writer, it gets on her numbed nerves.

Continue Reading…

Latest Reviews

Image of scene from the film Vash Level 2
Vash Level 2

Thriller, Horror (Gujarati)

Twelve years after saving his daughter Arya from a dark force, Atharva learns it never left… (more)

Image of scene from the film Lokah Chapter 1 Chandra
Lokah Chapter 1 Chandra

Action, Adventure, Fantasy (Malayalam)

The story follows Chandra , a mysterious, goth-influenced woman who has just moved to Bangalore and… (more)

Image of scene from the film Hridayapoorvam
Hridayapoorvam

Romance, Comedy, Drama, Family (Malayalam)

Sandeep, a middle-aged bachelor who recently got a heart transplant, travels to Pune to attend the… (more)

Image of scene from the film Bring Her Back
FCG Rating for the film
Bring Her Back

Horror (English)

Following the death of their father, a brother and sister are introduced to their new sibling… (more)