
Ishita Sengupta
Ishita Sengupta is an independent film critic and culture writer with a keen focus on nonfiction work. Her writing is informed with gender, pop culture and politics and it has appeared in publications like The Indian Express, The Hindu Frontline, OTT Play among others.
All reviews by Ishita Sengupta

| Director: | Shauna Gautam |
|---|---|
| Cast: | Ibrahim Ali Khan, Khushi Kapoor, Suniel Shetty, Mahima Chaudhry, Jugal Hansraj, Dia Mirza, Agastya Shah, Apoorva Makhija, Aaliyah Qureishi |
Nadaaniyan
Romance, Comedy (Hindi)
Where Are We Headed?
Sun, March 9 2025
Shauna Gautam’s debut feature Nadaaniyan's leads are so dull that even in a ranking of Hindi cinema’s most forgettable protagonists, Pia (Khushi Kapoor) and Arjun (Ibrahim Ali Khan) wouldn’t qualify.
History is proof that the most memorable Hindi films have centred on impossible deals. I will offer some examples. In Raj Kanwar’s Judaai (1997), a wife sold her husband to another woman for a briefcase of cash. In Satish Kaushik’s Hum Aapke Dil Mein Rehte Hain (1999), the two principal characters enter into a one-year marriage contract; in S. Shankar’s Nayak: The Real Hero (2001), a journalist makes a deal with a chief minister to fill in his shoes for a day. Apart from finding Anil Kapoor, the actor present in all three films, either brokering deals or being brokered in such agreements, the instances highlight the commonality of these segues.

| Director: | Tanushre Das, Saumyananda Sahi |
|---|---|
| Cast: | Tillotama Shome, Chandan Bisht, Sayan Karmakar, Suman Saha |
Baksho Bondi (Shadowbox)
Drama (Bengali)
This Review appeared in 'Berlinale Talent Press'
Shadowbox: A Nebulous Tale of Captivity and Resistance
Sun, February 23 2025
In a literal world, ‘Baksho Bondi’ — Bengali words carrying set meanings — need not exist together. When translated to English, ‘baksho’ means ‘box’ and ‘bondi’ is ‘captive’; both denoting the idea of being boxed up. But then again, in a literal world the verbatim translation of ‘Baksho Bondi’ would be a phrase: captive in a box. Yet first-time directors Tanushree Das and Saumyananda Sahi forsake precision in favour of interpretation, choosing Shadowbox (Baksho Bondi, 2025), meaning to fight with an imaginary adversary, as the English title, and in doing so, shrink the subjectivity of a person to the objectivity of an experience. The result is a film that unfolds as an interplay of both titles —imbued with the angst of confinement and the spirit of resistance— while mirroring the ambiguity that comes with it. Maya (Tillotama Shome) lives with her husband and son in Barrackpore, a neighbourhood located at the fringes of Kolkata, a densely populated Indian city. She works constantly although the specificity of her labour takes shape later. She irons clothes and ferries them from door to door on a cycle, and does domestic work for a family. In between, she outlines her husband’s routine and instructs their teenage son Debu to help him with it.

| Director: | Kalees |
|---|---|
| Cast: | Varun Dhawan, Keerthy Suresh, Wamiqa Gabbi, Rajpal Yadav, Sheeba Chaddha, Jackie Shroff, Salman Khan, Sanya Malhotra, Khushi Bhardwaj, Resh Lamba |
| Writer: | Kalees |
Baby John
Action, Drama, Thriller, Crime (Hindi)
The Worst Film Of The Year
Thu, December 26 2024
With Baby John, Varun Dhawan joins the long line of male actors transitioning to action stars who willingly hack and chop. He does the same but with an abject insincerity that gleams from the screen.
Like all bad films, Kalees’ Baby John gets worse by the second. But like a special kind of bad film, the progression happens in leaps and bounds. If the first fifteen minutes are infuriating, half an hour later the film makes you question your life’s choices. By the time the first half closes, you are having an existential meltdown and as the end credits roll, your orientation to reality has altered. Was that real? Was he real? Is any of this real or are we stuck in a parallel universe of Atlee’s imagination where everything on screen unravels as a duller version of his stylistic choices?

| Director: | Payal Kapadia |
|---|---|
| Cast: | Kani Kusruti, Divya Prabha, Chhaya Kadam, Hridhu Haroon, Azees Nedumangad, Tintumol Joseph, Anand Sami, Lovleen Mishra, Madhu Raja, Shweta Prajapati |
| Writer: | Payal Kapadia |
All We Imagine as Light
Drama (Malayalam)
This Review appeared in 'OTT Play'
A Moving Ode To Mumbai & Sisterhood
Tue, November 26 2024
Payal Kapadia's All We Imagine as Light is one of those life-altering gems that is transcendental and a moving memoir of mundane, transformative and a crushing reiteration of community sustenance.
Three women, monsoon and a severe city. If Payal Kapadia’s iridescent All We Imagine as Light was a novel, there would be dried flowers stuck between its pages. Since it is a film, the intangible feeling is imbued with visual tactility. It is present in the way Prabha (Kani Kusruti), a middle-aged woman, holds a totem of cold technology within the warmth of her embrace. It is embossed on the face of Parvaty (Chhaya Kadam), a woman in the middle of a crisis, as she listens to a fiery political speech about reclaiming what is hers. And it drips from the text messages a young Anu (Divya Prabha) sends to her lover: “I am sending you kisses through the clouds so that when it rains my kisses touch your lips.” Kapadia’s film is suffused with such ache that if you extend your hand you can touch it.

| Director: | Nikkhil Advani |
|---|---|
| Cast: | Sidhant Gupta, Chirag Vohra, Rajendra Chawla, Arif Zakaria, Ira Dubey, Rajesh Kumar, Luke McGibney, Cordelia Bugeja, Malishka Mendonsa, K.C. Shankar |
| Writer: | Abhinandan Gupta, Adwitiya Kareng, Gundeep Kaur, Divy Nidhi Sharma, Revanta Sarabhai, Ethan Taylor |
Freedom at Midnight
Drama (Hindi)
This Review appeared in 'OTT Play'
Nikhil Advani’s Pre-Independence Drama Is Immensely Watchable
Sat, November 16 2024
Freedom at Midnight is about the historicity of 1947 conveyed through the lives of those who curated the history.
With Freedom at Midnight, Nikhil Advani continues looking at big cultural moments through the microscopic gaze of an insider. Across the two seasons of his breakout show Mumbai Diaries, the filmmaker portrayed pressing social crises through the labour of medical practitioners attending to the casualties. This shift in slant sidestepped the showiness prone to cinematic excess and allowed for a more intimate rendering of public events, transforming, therefore, the narrative around them. In his latest long-form work, Advani turns his gaze to the wide spectrum of India’s independence and reiterates his style of focusing on the bureaucratic bottleneck, telling the story therefore of the people living inside towering buildings and not on the street. Freedom at Midnight is about the historicity of 1947 conveyed through the lives of those who curated the history.

| Director: | Rohit Shetty |
|---|---|
| Cast: | Ajay Devgn, Kareena Kapoor Khan, Arjun Kapoor, Ranveer Singh, Tiger Shroff, Deepika Padukone, Akshay Kumar, Jackie Shroff, Shweta Tiwari, Dayanand Shetty |
Singham Again
Action, Drama, Thriller, Crime (Hindi)
A Modern-Day, Cop-Addled Reimagination Of The Ramayana
Fri, November 1 2024
Of all the improbable things in Rohit Shetty’s Singham Again, like a car flying over a helicopter, like the same car landing without a scratch, like gifted actors dialling down their craft to match the trite script, like six people writing that script, like Ajay Devgn mistaking walking for acting, like the film mistaking walking for acting, the one that sticks out the most is Shetty assembling half the Hindi film industry (an exaggeration but you get the drift) to combat Arjun Kapoor.

| Director: | Vasan Bala |
|---|---|
| Cast: | Alia Bhatt, Vedang Raina, Manoj Pahwa, Vivek Gomber, Akashdeep Sabir, Harssh A. Singh, Aditya Nanda, Adhiraj Singh, Rahul Ravindran, Ankur Khanna |
| Writer: | Debashish Irengbam |
Jigra
Crime, Drama, Thriller (Hindi)
Alia Bhatt In And As The Angry Young Woman
Sat, October 12 2024
In Vasan Bala’s Jigra (Courage) Alia Bhatt is Amitabh Bachchan. The suggestion seems both foolish and foolhardy, not least because both actors have disparate, almost contrasting, physicalities. They act differently, they react differently. And more crucially, a punch lands on them differently. If Bachchan in his youth stumbled upon being hit, then Bhatt crumples like a paper bag. If the former’s daunting presence intimidates the frame then the latter’s diminutive silhouette makes space for others. Alia Bhatt is nothing like Amitabh Bachchan yet Bala insists that she is, for she has the jigra.
Latest Reviews


Spider-Man: Brand New Day
Science Fiction, Action, Adventure (English)
Fighting crime full-time as Spider-Man in a world that doesn't remember him—and the pressure of seeing… (more)

The Legend of Karna
Animation, Action & Adventure, Drama (Hindi)
A warrior from the Mahabharata who is born to Kunti and the Sun God Surya but… (more)

The Bombing of Pan Am 103
Drama, Crime (English)
On December 21, 1988, Pan Am Flight 103 exploded over the small Scottish town of Lockerbie,… (more)


Musafir Cafe
Drama (Hindi)
Chander feels an undeniable connection with Sudha. Years later, he builds a new life in the… (more)