← Previous Next →

Guild Reviews

Image of scene from the film Freedom at Midnight S02
FCG Rating for the film Freedom at Midnight S02: 72/100
Freedom at Midnight S02

Drama, War & Politics (Hindi)

Freedom at Midnight is the electrifying story of India's struggle for independence. Based on the bestselling book of the same name, it recounts the partition of India and Pakistan, and the religious and socio-political dynamics of the era.

Cast: Sidhant Gupta, Chirag Vohra, Rajendra Chawla, Arif Zakaria, Rajesh Kumar
Director: Nikkhil Advani


FCG Member Reviewer Anuj Kumar
Anuj Kumar | The Hindu
Nikkhil Advani hits the sweet spot between text and context

Sat, January 10 2026

Intense, reflective, but selective in its depiction of events and agent provocateurs, the series humanises political icons and puts their era-defining decisions in perspective

History lovers often crave the human drama behind epochal events. They pine for the backroom intrigue, the clash of egos, the creases in the starched characters that decorate our history books, not to forget the impact of their moral stand on the man on the street. These days, ancient and medieval history offers plenty of elbow room to play with the past, but when it comes to modern Indian history, filmmakers tend to draw back, as the wounds are still fresh and memories of Partition linger.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Sonal Pandya
Sonal Pandya | Times Now, Zoom
Nikkhil Advani's Historical Series Delves Deep Into Partition Trauma

Sat, January 10 2026

After a compelling first season, Freedom at Midnight returns after a year for a stellar second season that follows the events after India and Pakistan's independence.

After premiering in November 2024 on SonyLIV, Freedom at Midnight has returned to pick up the story after independence was announced for India and Pakistan by the British Raj. The historical drama, created by Nikkhil Advani, is more thoughtful and poignant in this second season as the emotional impact of the Partition hits you deep. Backed by a strong cast and excellent writing, Freedom at Midnight takes viewers right in to the heart of creating the two neighbouring nations and the toll it created for the citizens, then and now.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Bharathi Pradhan
Bharathi Pradhan | Lehren.com
The Pangs Of Pre-Partition Politics

Sat, January 10 2026

Clueless Sir Cyril Radcliffe calmly cut his steak on the flight out of India, leaving behind a nation he’d just carved into two. Louis Mounbatten (Luke McGibney) became India’s first Governor-General, content that the Partition had happened without spilling a drop of British blood. But what about Indian blood, his wife countered. Jinnah (Arif Zakaria) crowned himself Qaed-e-Azam, tore himself from beloved Bombay to settle down in Karachi, hid his illness which, if made public, may not have led to a new Muslim country, and ego-butted Mountbatten as his equal in rank. With sister Fatima (Ira Dubey) as his ally all the way.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film People We Meet on Vacation
People We Meet on Vacation

Romance, Comedy, Drama (English)

Poppy's a free spirit. Alex loves a plan. After years of summer vacations, these polar-opposite pals wonder if they could be a perfect romantic match.

Cast: Emily Bader, Tom Blyth, Sarah Catherine Hook, Jameela Jamil, Lucien Laviscount, Lukas Gage, Miles Heizer, Alan Ruck, Molly Shannon, Tommy Do
Director: Brett Haley


FCG Member Reviewer Sonal Pandya
Sonal Pandya | Times Now, Zoom
Tom Blyth, Emily Bader Charm In Funny, Delightful Rom-Com

Sat, January 10 2026

Adapted from Emily Henry's popular book, the story of best friends Alex (Tom Blyth) and Poppy (Emily Bader) soars beyond the cliches.

The first adaptation of author Emily Henry’s work is off to a flying start. Director Brett Haley stays close to Henry’s work with People We Meet on Vacation, as two best friends, Alex (Tom Blyth) and Poppy (Emily Bader), reunite every summer to travel to new places. Of course, with every trip, their relationship changes as they wonder if they could be right for one another. The Netflix film doesn’t change the genre by any means, but Blyth and Bader elevate the material with their chemistry and witty banter.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film The Raja Saab
FCG Rating for the film The Raja Saab: 30/100
The Raja Saab

Comedy, Horror, Fantasy (Telugu)

A young heir embraces both his royal heritage and rebellious spirit as he rises to power, establishing unprecedented rules during his reign as Raja Saab.

Cast: Prabhas, Sanjay Dutt, Nidhhi Agerwal, Malavika Mohanan, Riddhi Kumar, Boman Irani, Zarina Wahab, Samuthirakani, VTV Ganesh, Saptagiri
Director: Maruthi Dasari
Writer: Maruthi Dasari


FCG Member Reviewer Anmol Jamwal
Anmol Jamwal | Tried & Refused Productions

Sat, January 10 2026

FCG Member Reviewer Sangeetha Devi Dundoo
Sangeetha Devi Dundoo | The Hindu
A bizarre spectacle where the joke never lands

Sat, January 10 2026

Prabhas, Zarina Wahab and Sanjay Dutt try hard, but director Maruthi’s ‘The Raja Saab’ is a messy horror-comedy fantasy

Early on in The Raja Saab, a health scare prompts Prabhas to ask comedian Mahesh Achanta to fetch an odd assortment of items, from footwear to cigarettes. When Mahesh asks if he is serious, Prabhas snaps back with: do the needful — call an ambulance. The exchange is meant to be funny, but it lands flat, setting the tone for what follows. Written and directed by Maruthi, The Raja Saab aims to rewind Telugu cinema to a pre-Baahubali Prabhas — when he thrived in light-hearted roles with space for romance and comedy, à la Darling or Mr Perfect. The actor appears willing to embrace this blend of horror, comedy, fantasy and romance. Yet the film collapses into a baffling hotchpotch that squanders a promising premise. At 189 minutes, it becomes an endurance test, where the occasional spark of fun is smothered by a dull, meandering narrative.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Janani K
Janani K | India Today
Prabhas's horror comedy is devoid of charm, thrills and chills

Sat, January 10 2026

Director Maruthi's The Raja Saab, starring Prabhas, Sanjay Dutt and Nidhhi Agerwal, is a fantasy horror comedy that relies heavily on the lead actor. However, there's hardly anything that's redeemable in this soulless film.

Prabhas’s much-anticipated film, The Raja Saab is about a search for a missing grandfather. Over its three-hour runtime, viewers also end up searching for more than a grandfather. They seek plot cohesion, character depth, genuine scares, or consistent entertainment value - must-haves for every film. Like the film’s protagonist wandering through a haunted palace, you may feel a lack of clear direction or a fully satisfying destination. The Raja Saab begins with Raja (Prabhas) living with his grandmother Gangamma, played by Zarina Wahab. Gangamma suffers from Alzheimer’s and remembers only her missing husband Kanakaraju (Sanjay Dutt) and her grandson. She tells Raja to keep looking for his missing grandfather, who often appears in her dreams.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film Laalo
Laalo

Family, Drama (Gujarati)

A rickshaw driver trapped in a farmhouse confronts his past demons while experiencing visions of Lord Krishna, who guides him through a transformative journey of self-discovery and healing.

Cast: Reeva Racch, Shruhad Goswami, Karan Joshi
Director: Ankit Sakhiya
Writer: Vicky Poornima, Krushansh Vaja, Ankit Sakhiya


FCG Member Reviewer Anupama Chopra
Anupama Chopra | The Hollywood Reporter India
While the film draws from Frank Capra's 'It's a Wonderful Life' and Vikramaditya Motwane's 'Trapped', it ultimately delivers a universal message about living with grace and generosity.

Sat, January 10 2026

FCG Member Reviewer Deepak Dua
Deepak Dua | Independent Film Journalist & Critic
आस्था और कर्म का मार्ग दिखलाती ‘लालो’

Sat, January 10 2026

पहले तो यह जान लीजिए कि ‘लालो’ हिन्दी में डब होकर आई एक गुजराती फिल्म है जिसे बिना उपयुक्त प्रचार के रिलीज़ कर दिया गया है, शायद यह सोच कर कि यह अपनी राह खुद बना लेगी। लेकिन इसे बनाने वाले लोग शायद हिन्दी के दर्शकों का मिज़ाज नहीं जानते कि ये लोग सिर्फ उसी चीज़ के पीछे भागते हैं जिसके भीतर भले ही दम हो या न हो लेकिन जिसका ढोल ज़ोर-ज़ोर से बजाया गया हो। तो सुनिए, इस फिल्म ‘लालो-श्रीकृष्ण सदा सहायते’ का ढोल इस तरह से बजाया जा सकता है कि अक्टूबर, 2025 में गुजराती में रिलीज़ हुई यह फिल्म गुजराती सिनेमा के इतिहास की सबसे बड़ी हिट फिल्म है। इसके आने से पहले जहां सबसे बड़ी हिट गुजराती फिल्म का कलैक्शन 50 करोड़ था वहीं इस फिल्म का कलैक्शन 120 करोड़ तक जा पहुंचा है। माउथ पब्लिसिटी के दम पर इतनी बड़ी हिट होने के बाद अब यह हिन्दी में डब होकर आई है। ज़ाहिर है इसमें कुछ तो खास होगा ही, आइए देखते हैं।

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film Haq
FCG Rating for the film Haq: 64/100
Haq

Drama (Hindi)

In 1980s India, Shazia Bano takes her husband to court after he abandons her and their children, sparking a national battle over faith, women’s rights, and justice.

Cast: Yami Gautam, Emraan Hashmi, Danish Husain, Sheeba Chaddha, Vartika Singh, Aseem Hattangady
Director: Suparn Verma
Writer: Reshu Nath


FCG Member Reviewer Rohan Naahar
Rohan Naahar | Independent Film Critic
A Spotify Review

Wed, January 7 2026

Haq, the new propaganda movie starring Yami Gautam Dhar and Emraan Hashmi, is even more insidious than Dhurandhar. We talk about the film’s harmful stereotypes, the irresponsibility of presenting an entire community as savages, and drawing a direct line between bad behaviour and faith. We also discuss the film’s sloppy storytelling, childish approach to complex ideas, and its constant need to spoon-feed its audience.

FCG Member Reviewer Akhil Arora
Akhil Arora | akhilarora.com
A Spotify Review

Wed, January 7 2026

Haq, the new propaganda movie starring Yami Gautam Dhar and Emraan Hashmi, is even more insidious than. We talk about the film’s harmful stereotypes, the irresponsibility of presenting an entire community as savages, and drawing a direct line between bad behaviour and faith. We also discuss the film’s sloppy storytelling, childish approach to complex ideas, and its constant need to spoon-feed its audience.

FCG Member Reviewer Ishita Sengupta
Ishita Sengupta | Independent Film Critic
(Writing for OTT Play)
Suparn Varma’s Haq Is A Persuasive Take On The Shah Bano Case

Tue, November 11 2025

Haq, designed as one woman’s battle against the system, underlines the patriarchal readings of the Quran, the redundancy of triple talaq, and how women are forced to bear the brunt of religion.

HAQ becomes a better film once it ends. The Suparn Verma directorial feature is based on the landmark 1985 Shah Bano case, where a Muslim woman won her right to alimony. Although personal, her fight assumed big proportions because it revealed the knotty relationship between Muslim Personal Law, where a husband is entitled to provide maintenance during the iddat period after divorce, and the Indian secular law. In this particular case, the Supreme Court ruled in favour of Bano; later, the then-Congress government offset the judgment by sanctioning women to receive “reasonable and fair provision and maintenance" for three months after the divorce; Haq concludes by mentioning this, applauding, in the same breath, the current government for criminalising triple talaq and passing the Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Marriage) Act, 2019.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film The Pitt S02
The Pitt S02

Drama (English)

The staff of Pittsburgh's Trauma Medical Center work around the clock to save lives in an overcrowded and underfunded emergency department.

Cast: Noah Wyle, Patrick Ball, Katherine LaNasa, Supriya Ganesh, Fiona Dourif, Taylor Dearden, Isa Briones, Gerran Howell, Shabana Azeez, Sepideh Moafi


FCG Member Reviewer Sonal Pandya
Sonal Pandya | Times Now, Zoom
Emmy-Winning Medical Drama Makes Confident Return With New Obstacles, Faces

Tue, January 6 2026

Created by R. Scott Gemmill, the series is back for another grueling 15-hour shift that gives an enlightening look at the American medical system.

The first season of HBO Max’s The Pitt became a breakout hit after it focused its attention on the forgotten frontline workers in a Pittsburgh hospital. Now, a year after its premiere, the medical drama is back with its unique storytelling format and more urgent conditions for its characters. With each episode taking place over an hour, The Pitt highlights the many challenges faced by healthcare workers in America. This time, the show unfolds over the busy national holiday on the Fourth of July and delves more into the doctors’ and nurses’ lives as well.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film Ikkis
FCG Rating for the film Ikkis: 71/100
Ikkis

History, War, Drama (Hindi)

Against the backdrop of the 1971 war, Arun Khetrapal defies all odds to become a Second Lieutenant and India's youngest Param Vir Chakra recipient.

Cast: Agastya Nanda, Dharmendra, Jaideep Ahlawat, Simar Bhatia, Ekavali Khanna, Shree Bishnoi, Sikandar Kher, Madhusudan Bishnoi, Suhasini Mulay, Vivaan Shah
Director: Sriram Raghavan
Writer: Sriram Raghavan, Pooja Ladha Surti, Arijit Biswas


FCG Member Reviewer Arnab Banerjee
Arnab Banerjee | Indpendent Film Critic
Triumph that outlives the war

Mon, January 5 2026

A meditation on war, memory, and humanism—moving beyond jingoism to examine loss, empathy, and the moral aftermath of conflict across borders.

Set against the turbulent dawn of the 1970s, Ikkis opens on the formative years of Arun Khetrapal (Agastya Nanda), a young army officer of exceptional promise undergoing rigorous training to command a tank regiment. Distinguished early for his leadership, Arun appears poised for a life defined by purpose and quiet fulfilment. Love, too, smiles upon him in the form of Kiran (Simar Bhatia), and the future stretches before him, radiant with possibility. History, however, is rarely so benevolent. The outbreak of the 1971 war with Pakistan violently disrupts this fragile equilibrium, thrusting Arun—just twenty-one—into the crucible where youth, duty, and destiny irrevocably converge.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Keyur Seta
Keyur Seta | Bollywood Hungama
(Writing for The Common Man Speaks)
A war film that gives an anti-war message in a profound way

Mon, January 5 2026

Ikkis is primarily about a young man who fought the 1971 India-Pakistan war and attained martyrdom. In a typical Hindi war film, we would have shown his life from childhood or teenage years to him joining the army, fighting for the nation and ultimately sacrificing his life for the country. But Ikkis isn’t a typical war film by any means. Along with portraying the martyrdom of the young man, the film gives equal importance at giving an anti-war message through the track of Dharmendra and Jaideep Ahlawat. It says loudly without saying much – ultimately there are humans on both sides of the border who die during a war. And the film achieves this even while showing the bravery of a young martyr.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Tatsam Mukherjee
Tatsam Mukherjee | The Wire
Determinedly Swims Against the Tide of Jingoistic War Films, and Makes Shore

Sat, January 3 2026

In an era of easy outrage, Ikkis chooses restraint and moral clarity.

I found myself tearing up a few times while watching Sriram Raghavan’s Ikkis. It’s not because of the film alone, which is based on the military service of India’s youngest Paramvir Chakra awardee, Second Lt Arun Khetarpal – who died during the 1971 Indo-Pak war. It had more to do with the Bollywood war film – a genre that has assumed the responsibility to rile up obvious jingoistic sentiments, thinking it’s the only way to make itself a successful enterprise. Raghavan is too much of a ‘thinking’ and a self-assured filmmaker to give into the temptations of the box office. We’ve also seen dozens of these idols exhibit feet of clay in the last decade.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film Stranger Things S05
FCG Rating for the film Stranger Things S05: 62/100
Stranger Things S05

Sci-Fi & Fantasy, Mystery, Action & Adventure (English)

When a young boy vanishes, a small town uncovers a mystery involving secret experiments, terrifying supernatural forces, and one strange little girl.

Cast: Millie Bobby Brown, Winona Ryder, David Harbour, Finn Wolfhard, Gaten Matarazzo, Caleb McLaughlin, Noah Schnapp, Sadie Sink, Natalia Dyer, Charlie Heaton


FCG Member Reviewer Sonal Pandya
Sonal Pandya | Times Now, Zoom
Vol 3: Millie And Jamie Deliver Satisfying - But Safe - Final Showdown

Sun, January 4 2026

After nearly a decade and 42 episodes, Stranger Things comes to an end with a thrilling final chapter.

It all comes down to this! The Netflix series, Stranger Things, ends with a big bang and lots of emotional moments with the last episode titled The Rightside Up. Co-creators Matt and Ross Duffer must wind down the story of Hawkins, Indiana, and its residents, who were terrorised by the Upside Down for the past five seasons. Now, they must vanquish the big villain and make it out alive. The result is a satisfying but expected ending that is sure to leave fans discussing it for years to come.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Priyanka Roy
Priyanka Roy | The Telegraph
Vol. 2: Sets up the action for the grand finale.

Fri, December 26 2025

As the characters navigate dense lore and emotional arcs, Eleven teams up with Kali to combat looming threats in Hawkins.

Exposition. Explanation. Emotion. Stranger Things Season 5 Vol 2 rests on these three Es. The other ‘E’ that worms its way into the three episodes of this volume — before the grand finale drops less than a week later — is ‘Exotic Matter’ and with it the realisation (courtesy Dustin Henderson) that everything we have thought of the Upside Down over the last decade is not really it. In reality, the evil parallel dimension that has been at the heart of Stranger Things is, well, not a parallel dimension at all. It is, in fact, a wormhole to an even worse dimension that Vecna is trying to “collapse”, with an eye on taking over the world.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Sonal Pandya
Sonal Pandya | Times Now, Zoom
Vol. 2: Noah Schnapp, Jamie Campbell Bower Take Centerstage In Heated Final Battle

Fri, December 26 2025

After a month, the hit supernatural sci-fi series returns to continue the story of Hawkins, Indiana, and its battle with the Upside Down.

The second part of Stranger Things opens after the exhilarating and devastating events of the last four episodes of Season 5. Noah Schnapp’s Will Byers has powers, and Vecna (Jamie Campbell Bower) has captured all 12 children to the Upside Down for his grand plan. What’s afoot? Co-created by the Duffer Brothers, Matt and Ross, the final season of the Netflix show hurtles towards an epic showdown that promises casualties this time. Who will make it out alive at the end?

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film The Housemaid
The Housemaid

Mystery, Thriller (English)

Trying to escape her past, Millie Calloway accepts a job as a live-in housemaid for the wealthy Nina and Andrew Winchester. But what begins as a dream job quickly unravels into something far more dangerous—a sexy, seductive game of secrets, scandal, and power.

Cast: Sydney Sweeney, Amanda Seyfried, Brandon Sklenar, Elizabeth Perkins, Michele Morrone, Indiana Elle, Arabella Olivia Clark, Megan Ferguson, Ellen Tamaki, Amanda Joy Erickson
Director: Paul Feig


FCG Member Reviewer Sachin Chatte
Sachin Chatte | The Navhind Times Goa
One Batty After Another

Sat, January 3 2026

Imagine if you were forcibly confined in a room without food, and your captor is so cruel that he compels you to inflict twenty-one cuts on your stomach with shattered chinaware, merely for amusement. If you somehow manage to escape and imprison your captor in that room, what would your next step be? (a) Seek medical assistance (b) Flee from that house as fast as possible or (c) Relax in the living room and watch television. The character in The Housemaid opts for the absurd choice of C, while the menacing figure upstairs attempts to break free

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film Sirai
Sirai

Drama, Romance (Tamil)

As he transfers a young convict from prison to court, a police officer learns about the chain of events that led to the young man's conviction for violence.

Cast: Vikram Prabhu, Lk akshay kumar, Anishma Anilkumar, Ananda Thambirajah, Vaishaali vijay, Rajapandi
Director: Suresh Rajakumari
Writer: Suresh Rajakumari


FCG Member Reviewer Vishal Menon
Vishal Menon | The Hollywood Reporter India
Well-Written Drama About a Cop Transforming from Hero to Human

Fri, January 2 2026

With many smart touches in the writing, Vikram Prabhu's 'Sirai' makes a living, breathing life form of what could easily have remained an intellectual exercise

As far-fetched as it may seem, one can make the case for Sirai to be added to a list of suggested reading material along with Rajinikanth’s Vettaiyan. They are both films about impossibly upright protagonists who invariably prefer to take law into their own hands, as long as it fits into their notions of having a moral conscience. They are both films that begin by making us sympathise with these heroes, who are as good as the heroes of a hundred other cop movies, only to then realise that even they could go terribly wrong. Their transformation from a trigger-happy hero to an empathetic human is the arc both films take. But if Vettaiyan was burdened by the weight of its mega star voltage, Sirai is more than happy to make the movie about other characters too, resulting in an unadulterated debate about encounter killings and the biases that make this act more complex.

Continue reading …

FCG Member Reviewer Janani K
Janani K | India Today
Vikram Prabhu film tackles minority struggle, bias with quiet strength

Fri, December 26 2025

Director Suresh Rajakumari's Sirai, starring Vikram Prabhu, LK Akshay Kumar and Anishma, is a crisp procedural drama. With restrained performances and exceptional social commentary on minority oppression, the film serves as a fitting conclusion to 2025.

Actor Vikram Prabhu’s choice of scripts has been impressive in the recent past. His upcoming venture, Sirai, marks his second collaboration with writer Tamizh (also an actor) after their critically acclaimed Taanakkaran. Sirai, like Taanakkaran, casts Vikram Prabhu’s protagonist as a police officer, but from the district armed reserve wing.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film Psych Siddhartha
Psych Siddhartha

Comedy, Romance (Telugu)

Siddharth's life is a string of misfortunes, losing love, money, and dignity, making him the unwitting star of a slum-based comedy of errors. Hope only reappears in the form of Shravya, a no-nonsense single mother. However, just as Siddharth begins to rebuild his life and pursue a chance at love, his past resurfaces to threaten everything.

Cast: Nandu Vijay Krishna, Yamini Bhaskar, Priyanka Srinivas, Sukesh Reddy, Sakshi Chaturvedi, Pradyumna Billuri, Bobby Ratakonda, Narsing Wadekar
Director: Varun Reddy
Writer: Varun Reddy


FCG Member Reviewer Sangeetha Devi Dundoo
Sangeetha Devi Dundoo | The Hindu
Shree Nandu and Yaamini Bhaskar impress in an edgy relationship drama

Fri, January 2 2026

Director Varun Reddy’s comic book style presentation of a relationship drama hits the right notes when it doesn’t try too hard to be quirky

There’s something disarming about a first-time filmmaker’s eagerness to break free of established norms of storytelling. Architect-turned-filmmaker Varun Reddy’s Telugu film Psych Siddhartha is a case in point. Varun, who has written and co-produced the film with actor Shree Nandu, presents a fairly simple relationship drama like a comic book for adults, wanting to speak the language of Gen Z. The film may not be perfect but ushers in a promising voice that’s eager to push the boundaries of storytelling.

Continue reading …

Image of scene from the film Krantijyoti Vidyalay Marathi Madhyam
Krantijyoti Vidyalay Marathi Madhyam

Comedy, Drama (Marathi)

Students and teachers from a Marathi school come together to save their school from demolition, as an international school is set to be built in its place. Personal challenges merge with institutional struggles as they seek preservation of Marathi-medium schools and their local culture, while also acknowledging the need for change.

Cast: Sachin Khedekar, Amey Wagh, Siddharth Chandekar, Prajakta Koli, Kshitee Jog, Harish Dudhade, Kadambari Kadam, Pushkaraj Chirputkar
Director: Hemant Dhome
Writer: Hemant Dhome


FCG Member Reviewer Keyur Seta
Keyur Seta | Bollywood Hungama
Tackles an important issue but in a convenient way

Fri, January 2 2026

The film revolves around a 99-year-old Marathi school in Alibaug called Krantijyoti Vidyalay Marathi Madhyam. The school is everything for its Principal Shirke sir (Sachin Khedekar). But currently, the school doesn’t have any future. The state government has ordered to raze the school as, according to them, its lease period is over and the structure of the building has become weak. The plan is also to make an English medium international school in its place. This has happened to thousands of Marathi schools in Maharashtra.

Continue reading …